Madara might possibly be good

[Grasiano]

You must be registered for see links

Madara said "into this state" i think he means the current state of events, ei Tobi's plan going well. Tobi's plan is obviously increadibly evil. Madara also says that "Things don't seem to be going as according to plan very well." That obviously means that Madara's plan is failing. If Tobi's plan going well means that Madara's is failing does that mean Madara is good?

 

[lubricati0n]

No because Tobi and Madara both say Rinnei Tensei was for "me", meaning Madara. That is the part of the plan that has failed due to Kabuto using edo tensei to revive Madara instead. And as we know, Kabuto is a shifty man.

 

[zombiejesus]

i think it means the fact he was needed in tobis (and probably his plan) was bad

 

[Qu4zi]

i like pie but i still think Tobi is Madara

 

[Rozzy]

i like pie but i still think Tobi is Madara

hahaha gas

 

[Cfighter]

He clearly has a bad vibe just from his actions. Put the theories on who Tobi is and his plan aside and your left with Edo Madara. The past edo zombies who had no intention of truly fighting the army either exposed all their secrets and weaknesses or made it clear they didnt want to fight in some way.

Madara went all out with the intention to kill. He wasnt brainwashed, he had -limited- control over his actions yet he gave no hint of loosening up on the army.

 

[EggesGabo]

He is damn WICKED. i don't see any sign of him being good.

 

[Grasiano]

He clearly has a bad vibe just from his actions. Put the theories on who Tobi is and his plan aside and your left with Edo Madara. The past edo zombies who had no intention of truly fighting the army either exposed all their secrets and weaknesses or made it clear they didnt want to fight in some way.

Madara went all out with the intention to kill. He wasnt brainwashed, he had -limited- control over his actions yet he gave no hint of loosening up on the army.

You're probably right. I'm just overthinking things.

 

[EternalMangekyouRinnegan]

You must be registered for see links

Madara said "into this state" i think he means the current state of events, ei Tobi's plan going well. Tobi's plan is obviously increadibly evil. Madara also says that "Things don't seem to be going as according to plan very well." That obviously means that Madara's plan is failing. If Tobi's plan going well means that Madara's is failing does that mean Madara is good?

Wow I can't believe that noone would think of this. You are absolutely right.
This state = war, not in state of Edo Tensei.
"his" doing = this war is caused by him(tobi).
According to plan = to who's plan? Madara's or Tobi's? This is crucial for us to know so we can understand how come Madara knew about Nagato.
If they would be allies than Madara would have known what is his plan.

You must be registered for see links

Kabuto says he needs Sasuke, a living Uchiha, for his plan in discovering truth behind ninjutsus(probably becoming SO6P). It has something to do with his body and his blood. Madara also said something like "you have discovered secrets of my body..?"

There's still question to why Madara is attacking everyone. Is it because of the Edo Tensei auto-attack? Allied forces attack him first. Maybe Madara is just THAT badass that he won't allow anyone to fuk with him? He never was a good guy to begin with but he's not absolutely evil either. He probably doesn't care much for the allied forces.

 

[Lividus]

He is damn WICKED. i don't see any sign of him being good.

^This.

The current war goes in with what madara wanted to begin with, so I see him going along with it because he gains the most by aligning himself with tobi. Through this war, Konoha/Senju could be crushed, so I see him freeing himself from the jutsu somehow like itachi, but still staying on that side of the war.

 

[Floydical]

Wow I can't believe that noone would think of this. You are absolutely right.
This state = war, not in state of Edo Tensei.
"his" doing = this war is caused by him(tobi).
According to plan = to who's plan? Madara's or Tobi's? This is crucial for us to know so we can understand how come Madara knew about Nagato.
If they would be allies than Madara would have known what is his plan.

You must be registered for see links

Kabuto says he needs Sasuke, a living Uchiha, for his plan in discovering truth behind ninjutsus(probably becoming SO6P). It has something to do with his body and his blood. Madara also said something like "you have discovered secrets of my body..?"

There's still question to why Madara is attacking everyone. Is it because of the Edo Tensei auto-attack? Allied forces attack him first. Maybe Madara is just THAT badass that he won't allow anyone to fuk with him? He never was a good guy to begin with but he's not absolutely evil either. He probably doesn't care much for the allied forces.

When he said "this state" he meant being so young. If he was revived just before he died, like most edos, he would have been older. But his edo form is that of when he was young (+ one powerup we don't know about). And Madara is not on auto pilot, he is doing all this at his own free will. Here's a better translation of those two pages:

You must be registered for see links

You must be registered for see links

Kabuto wasn't saying "Show me the legendary power of the Uchiha" he was saying "Show me the legendary power of Uchiha Madara" and got cut off. Afterward, Madara dodged the attack and willingly agreed to show his full power. This is clarified by him following it up by saying "Fine.."

 

[Strata Uchiha]

Nah, I see Madara as being just "neutral." Not good or bad. He just wants to go back into his coffin and sleep. Zzzzz.

 

[Tarheel09]

Nah, I see Madara as being just "neutral." Not good or bad. He just wants to go back into his coffin and sleep. Zzzzz.

i agree with this. i see him just kind of responding to which ever side summoned him regardless of the circumstances

 

[psukkar]

I think he doesent care about the villages.

But I do think he HATES being controlled or in a situation of being controlled.

Wouldnt surpirse me if madara gets a chance he will kill kabuto.

 

[warlee]

He is the darkness, pure evil.

 

[Lividus]

I think he doesent care about the villages.

But I do think he HATES being controlled or in a situation of being controlled.

Wouldnt surpirse me if madara gets a chance he will kill kabuto.

Definately, I can see him killing kabuto for it because kabuto is being too cocky. But I can't see him good, or even neutral, because his goals can be accomplished by aligning with "tobi".

 

[Strata Uchiha]

I think he doesent care about the villages.

But I do think he HATES being controlled or in a situation of being controlled.

Wouldnt surpirse me if madara gets a chance he will kill kabuto.

He's the mightiest of his whole entire clan...The Infamous Uchiha of Legend...

....being reduced to a puppet on strings. Oh...I KNOW he wants to murder Kabuto in cold blood...like...the most painful death imaginable.

So yeah you're correct. ^^ +rep.

 

[FK166]

nahh I think Madara is on neither side, kinda sounds like he had his own plan to carry out..
He sures is awesome though, killing techniques and the Rinnegan...ahhhh Im on his side, stuff the army.

 

[Kisaragi]

Nahh >_>