[Theory] Luffy will not fight big mom

[Naruto Power]

Sorry but there will not be a Luffy big mom fight.
Big mom will pass out after losing so much energy and eating the cake.
When this happen Luffy will come out of the mirror world with a beaten muchi man and burlee at his feet. This will make the big mom crews not wanting to challenge them knowing Luffy has beat the strongest other then big mom..
They leave. For Zoro and wano.

When big mom wakes up she has a fit. She will want revenge and go to destroy Fishman island. Luffy will get news of this and will beat kido to go save his friends and Fishman island. This will be when one of the big op secrets is revealed regarding the boat and the. Pics of all things.

 

[Relostar Devil]

That would be very big of an asspull by oda, if he defeats katakuri...

 

[WoldOfFingo]

There we go again.
Katakuri had his chance.
He failed to prevent Luffy running off (who just used gear 4 and took direct hits from Katakuri)
Katakuri failed to even slow down Luffy in any way

 

[Tyrance sasuke]

Katakuri could sh*t on luffy's arsenal.

 

[Caliburn]

At this point I thought it was a given that Luffy wouldn't fight BM. From the start the premise of this arc was not to take on a Yonkou, but to 1) get Sanji and 2) BM's poneglyphs. Yes they tried to take her down along the way, but that was due to the necessity of the situation and was in line of the first objective. It was not so much that it had to succeed, but that they had no other choice than trying.

The pace of the story also doesn't allow this either. Luffy has been entangled with Dogtooth for a quite a while now and this after the climaxing wedding. The pace would be messed up if Luffy and BM would have a showdown, a fight that should put to shame all the fights of this arc together, right after BM had possibly her worst fit ever and Luffy just had an exhausting fight with Dogtooth. A battle like this should be the pinnacle of an arc, while currently that would be like you just ran a marathon and already crossed the finish line, but suddenly you have to start sprinting. It simply doesn't work.

Honestly I don't think many people were even still expecting to see a showdown between BM and Luffy either way. For some Dogtooth fighting Luffy was already unnecessary and felt like dragging it all out, let alone an additional bout with BM. We know that BM can black out completely when she's eating and most likely Sanji's cake will be the best thing she ever ate, so I always imagined that the moment she starts eating, they will flee and that afterwards BM will simply fall asleep satisfied. And if Luffy beats Dogtooth, well escaping shouldn't be too hard anymore. Any possible problem that might occur from that point on can be handled by the Vinsmokes.

Your 2nd paragraph doesn't make any sense though, I'm not even sure how this would tie to a boat (Pluton?), pics (?) and a big secret? Yes BM most certainly will be pissed and will possibly try to chaise the Strawhats. Only why would she go to FI instead of going after the Strawhats themselves? In particular because the Firetank pirates have no connection to FI and if she wants to punish them too, she will have to send people out regardless. It isn't very realistic either to expect that Luffy is going to deal swiftly with Kaidou, in what is possibly going to be the best arc ever, because he heard that BM is after FI, which is located at the ENTRANCE of the New World. Just the shear impracticality of this makes this scenario unlikely.

If BM would indeed attempt such a thing, most likely she wouldn't get that far and/or a third party would get involved.

 

[loj]

I think that was obvious from the start of the arc and constant throwing Luffy to Katakuri rather than BM....

 

[mangawise]

Honestly I really can't say anything at this point, Oda is really pushing it.

I have been longing to ask this, what Is the use of the voice of all things in this arc?

 

[Dgrayman]

Luffy will most definitely beat katuraki , oda didn't hype their round 2 for nothing

 

[Passerby]

How would you guys feel if Luffy knocks Big Mom because she became thin and was not as powerful as she was when she is big?

 

[Naruto Power]

That would be awesome.
Caliburn - big mom is known to kill people for just not showing up. The reason that you can figure out is the straw hats get the credit of beating her with the aid of the fishmen and firetanks. Plus too her loosing Jinbie is a greater loss then Capone. Big mom will also want to punish jinbie and the Fishman crew that went against her.
Also Fishman island stops payment to her at fly straw hat flag.
Also with the worlds best navigators we have seen at war of the great that some people like shanks can make great time.
Oda said in jump that he will be show an op secret but the secret is not the voice of all things it’s the purpose of the ship at the bottom of the sea.

The voice is the master level of haki. It’s like one with the matrix. After Fishman island it will touch on it. And the ancient weapons.

 

[Caliburn]

That would be awesome.
Caliburn - big mom is known to kill people for just not showing up. The reason that you can figure out is the straw hats get the credit of beating her with the aid of the fishmen and firetanks. Plus too her loosing Jinbie is a greater loss then Capone. Big mom will also want to punish jinbie and the Fishman crew that went against her.
Also Fishman island stops payment to her at fly straw hat flag.
Also with the worlds best navigators we have seen at war of the great that some people like shanks can make great time.
Oda said in jump that he will be show an op secret but the secret is not the voice of all things it’s the purpose of the ship at the bottom of the sea.

The voice is the master level of haki. It’s like one with the matrix. After Fishman island it will touch on it. And the ancient weapons.

She kills someone related to the person who doesn't accept her invitation, however essentially it's not that big of a deal. It just shows how self-centered and nuts she is. What Luffy and Bege did however is outside category. This can't even be compared to someone not coming to her parties. The Strawhats invaded her territory and made it all the way to the center, they tried to assassinate her with Bege, most likely will escape afterwards and led waste to everything in their path or were at least indirectly responsible for the destruction.

BM is a Yonkou. After all the things they did, just going after some relations while leaving the main culprits alone is quite pitiful and underwhelming. The fact that Jinbei already officially stated that he will join the Strawhats, means that even if she wants to punish him, we end up again with the Strawhats themselves. BM also said at FI to Luffy that she would direct her rage from FI to him. We might see the Sun Pirates, Jinbei and FI as one and the same, but that doesn't mean everyone in the story does.

And having good navigators isn't really relevant here. Crews like those of Shanks, WB and BM have been sailing these seas for decades, but the Strawhats are here for the first time. From a story perspective it also makes no sense that suddenly the Strawhats can go back and forth on a whim. That works for characters who only sporadically appear, but not the ones we follow all the time.

Of course that doesn't take away BM might just send some lesser soldiers to destroy FI purely out of anger, but again the Strawhats can't help, so hence I said that even if she would try it, a third party or something else would possibly block it. Don't forget that it's almost the Reverie, that the Marine HQ is now in the New World and that Mariejois is right above FI. Not really the most ideal of locations for a Yonkou to start destroying things.

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

I can actually see that happening and Luffy would have a reputation for beat Cracker and Dogtooth which would actually interest some yonkous even more.

 

[Wrappering_]

All they have to do is get Law to TP the rest of the crew onto the island; with Law, Luffy, Sanji, and Robin they can easily defeat mama and get out of there. They'll have to leave quickly though, cause BB is on his way to cake island to pull a magic trick involving a pencil on Mama. RIP

 

[Anduril]

Baka ka Umaira!

You must be registered for see images

 

[Bogard]

Meme doesn't even deserve to be defeated by Luffy's hands anyway.
I expect her to get off-paneled by someone

 

[Naruto Power]

Big mom will not be considered a yonko after this.
It will be called a defeat. Most of her crew leave. This way she stops taking their live span.
She will not step foot into kidos territory where both Luffy and jinbie will be going. Others will be going for her now open for a challenge territory.
She will want to hurt jimbie and Fishman island is the only way. Also sun pirates will be there. They stopped the communication on the ocean floor.
Nami still has not shown what she learned in her training. Also with jimbie it’s possibe to pull a straw hat.

 

[Tyrance sasuke]

Probably won't, but there still a possibility. Zoro would go with a team to Wano, Big mom continues her fight with luffy, like what happened dressrosa.

 

[Lord Tywin]

Katakuri is the only opponent in this arc that can elevate luffy

 

[Passerby]

Meme doesn't even deserve to be defeated by Luffy's hands anyway.
I expect her to get off-paneled by someone

Just imagine a skinny Big Mom gobbling up Sanji's cake. She is too weak and hungry to notice her surroundings.
And then we hear the words "Zehahahahaa...!"