Konan v Sound 4

Beans2

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
8,937
Reaction score
462
While I write my reply, in the meantime you can counter this. Because there's no reason for me to need to address the entire post when Konan won't ever be caught in the genjutsu in the first place due to the strategy I introduced in the last sentence of my previous post.

While the remaining sound 5 do nothing...Not to mention this would mess up her view and Jirobo who can use hiding like a mole would take advantage of this trapping her. Plus if she's focused on Tayuya, webs can catch her off guard, Kimmi can shoot out Teshi Sendan. There just a lot of combos that can come after he once she's caught off guard. They all need to protect Tayuya and that's it.

I addressed the Yin argument.

Except the remaining sound 5 can do nothing to Konan in paper form. It wouldn't mess up her view because Konan has shown to spread her consciousness throughout her papers, allowing her to search through an entire city [ ] and locate a single individual. Konan=airborne. Jirobo's techniques=earth based. Therefore Jirobo has no way of trapping her. Konan doesn't have to "focus" on Tayuya as she can multitask on the Sound 5 all at once. Kidomaru's webs are useless since they would only catch a handful of papers out of Konan's millions when she's spread out, and besides she can blow up the webs and escape even if she somehow were to get caught. Then there's the fact that none of Kimimaro's attacks are going to do crap to her in paper form.

Honestly this discussion shouldn't even be continued. With explosions to drown out the sound of Tayuya's flute, everything has been countered (not to mention the idea of that genjutsu one shotting is dumb in the first place.) Not a single member of the sound 5 can counter Konan then . She does this to them one at a time starting with Tayuya.

Konan debaters take this thread. Cannot wait to see what counter Haizaki comes up with to this.
 

Draegod

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Sep 23, 2010
Messages
7,432
Reaction score
852
While I write my reply, in the meantime you can counter this. Because there's no reason for me to need to address the entire post when Konan won't ever be caught in the genjutsu in the first place due to the strategy I introduced in the last sentence of my previous post.



Except the remaining sound 5 can do nothing to Konan in paper form. It wouldn't mess up her view because Konan has shown to spread her consciousness throughout her papers, allowing her to search through an entire city [ ] and locate a single individual. Konan=airborne. Jirobo's techniques=earth based. Therefore Jirobo has no way of trapping her. Konan doesn't have to "focus" on Tayuya as she can multitask on the Sound 5 all at once. Kidomaru's webs are useless since they would only catch a handful of papers out of Konan's millions when she's spread out, and besides she can blow up the webs and escape even if she somehow were to get caught. Then there's the fact that none of Kimimaro's attacks are going to do crap to her in paper form.

Honestly this discussion shouldn't even be continued. With explosions to drown out the sound of Tayuya's flute, everything has been countered (not to mention the idea of that genjutsu one shotting is dumb in the first place.) Not a single member of the sound 5 can counter Konan then . She does this to them one at a time starting with Tayuya.

Konan debaters take this thread. Cannot wait to see what counter Haizaki comes up with to this.

Thinks slow swarming of papers is the end all be all.lol I swear Konan supporters are something else.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
Would just like to address this part since I think you are misinterpreting what I was saying. I am not saying the two ninjutsu are the same, I am saying the Yin is the same in any case of any jutsu. While Susano (or any jutsu) is ethereal (in a predominantly Yin state), it craves a balance like Kakashi mentioned once early on in the manga [ ]. To use jutsu the physical and spiritual energy must be in a balance as he states. So when Tayuya releases her jutsu the spirits search for physical energy in order to create that balance and become stable. It gets that physical energy from other sources, not the user. Susano takes physical energy from the user in order to obtain that balance. The same Susano can disappear once chakra is no longer expended by the user. In the same way, once physical energy is no longer expended by the user, it would go back to the ethereal state. So his body is constantly aching because he's constantly maintaining Susano. It's not a jutsu were you can form the chakra and then have it up eternally since it requires no maintenance, because it clearly does.

Wait this is were it gets tricky and to prove the bold is an assumption..I'll say this. The DB state Tayuya's spirits are made of almost Mental energy so they are in an unstable state. Hence when they get that energy, they attain a physical state and no longer search for the energy/stability because it has been attained


So this is the part where I disagree with you...If Susano'o already attains a physical state, it shouldn't still crave for physical energy because it has already attained it. You go against what is said because you're claiming it needs physical energy in order to be maintained but what's stated is it needs physical energy in order to be stable. Susano'o attains stability once that physical energy has been attained. However, it's false to state that it still needs that physical energy to be maintained being the reason why it draws comparison to the spirits.

NINJUTSU; Makyou no Ran (Riot of the Poltergeist*)
User: Tayuya
Offensive; Close, Medium ranges; Rank: B

Main text

Tayuya manipulates three Angry Demons with the sound of her flute. Her releasing of the materialized spirits - which is to say the special chakra sealed inside of those Demons - marks the start of the grand finale, a feast: the Riot of the Poltergeist... The materialized spirits are composed almost only of mental energy, so the chakra is in an unstable state. Therefore, they are starved for physical energy, search for it and gnash at it greedily...! There is no choice: the prey engaged in this endless pursuit perishes in the unsightly, frantic choregraphy.

Because the spirits are composed of mental energy and have an unstable, they search for physical energy...Hence if composed of physical energy, it shouldn't search for physical energy still when the stable state has been attained because datebook states only in and unstable state with almost all mental energy you search for that physical energy. You talk of physical energy in order for it t be maintained when that's not the case as they only need physical energy for the stable state to be attained and not maintained.


@Beans I'll take a look at your post later and I like how you jump from how Genjutsu isn't a factor when it won't hit her anyways. I'll take it as a concession. As for the rest, I'll give it a look later on considering how cocky and disrespectful you're getting by telling me to change my post.

I have something for the Konan fans who think her paper is faster than KCM Naruto's running speed. We'll have to wait lol.
 
Last edited:

Beans2

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
8,937
Reaction score
462
Itachi's crow clone which doesn't take up to half his chakra like the shadow clone could pull out a Ribcage but Itachi couldn't pull it out because it takes a considerable amount of chakra despite pulling Tsukoyomi which also does? Makes no sene.....Where's your proof that a Ribcage takes more than that? None. Susano'o has different forms and they take different amounts of chakra. Unless you think PS takes the same amount as a Ribcage which was never noted to take that much like Tsukoyomi. You're only making up the fact that it takes much.

First off, wrong. Crow clone never used ribcage, the most it's done is use a basic Susanoo shroud [ ]. The rest of your post is irrelevant since I never mentioned any Susanoo version besides ribcage. In fact this paragraph doesn't even make grammatical sense so I'm having trouble understanding it. So once again. Itachi's shadow clone can use Tsukuyomi because it has enough chakra to do so. I've been asking you for an actual reason why this wouldn't be possible for three posts now, and you haven't actually given me anything which makes me think you didn't have an argument to begin with.

This sickening logic you're employing simply because you have 0 proof that a Ribcage takes that much. Because he didn't use this doesn't mean he couldn't have employed it. That's crap. Not to mention there could be reasons why he didn't use Susano'o but it's unknown to us. Don't bring in "he didn't use a Ribcage" when you don't have valid enough reasons except well, anticipate he didn't use it because it takes more chakra. Plus the fact that there was a distance between them and that wall and the fact that it required enough speed to get rid of that due to the wall of flesh behind them being swift hence Itachi had no choice but to clear the one in front of him before he got there

I crossed out the part where you denied evidence. "He didn't use Susanoo but it's unknown to us why he didn't"=I have no counterargument.

1. We already have the Viz of Itachi saying he was forced to use Amaterasu.
2. We know that ribcage could have accomplished the feat just as easily, if not more easily.
3. We know that Itachi had just used Tsukuyomi and was trying to preserve chakra.

What more do you want? I'm literally reading the manga to you at this point. As for the rest of your paragraph, are you implying that wall of flesh>Itachi's shunshin in speed? Given Itachi's speed feats, he can easily reach the wall as he manifests Susanoo then tear a hole through it with a Susanoo sword before the flesh wall closes in.

Keep saying these things. Not to mention what makes this moronic is the fact that a crow clone contains less amount of chakra that the shadow clone as stated by the DB so it means a Ribcage definitely doesn't take that much.

How about no? My evidence is based on that fact that you BEANS have zero scans to prove the fact that a RIBCAGE takes a large amount of chakra....Your comparison is weak because different forms of Susano'o require different level of chakra.

If only crow clone had actually used a ribcage Susanoo. Quit throwing around the word "zero proof" like I haven't provided any. I've given you proof time and time again, but you either deny it or ignore it. My favorite part is you keep insisting that Itachi's shadow clone can't use Tsukuyomi or Amaterasu but for the last three posts you have provided...zero proof.

Pretty sure you need to realize how you sound. Also, google the definition of considerable and I don't care because it's been stated either way that it does take a large amount. A crow clone was only shown to use a Ribcage and that's it. Sasuke's chakras were growing weaker to the point where he couldn't do much and yet he could still maintain a Ribcage eve though he couldn't use other forms...Upon his chakra being replenished, he could employ higher versions of Susano'o. Your arguments don't make sense because you can't even prove that a Ribcage takes as much chakra...You're only using "Susano'o" as an argument which is nonsensical..When a Ribcage doesn't take as much chakra in that contained crow clone which isn't close to the shadow in terms of chakra reserves? Yet I'm supposed to believe it taking a considerable amount like Tsukoyomi and Amaterasu?

Bring proof that a Ribcage takes a large amount like those 2 or don't bother.

Oh lord. I DON'T CARE IF TSUKUYOMI TAKES A CONSIDERABLE AMOUNT OF CHAKRA, BECAUSE IT'S IRRELEVANT UNLESS YOU CAN PROVE IT TAKES MORE CHAKRA THAN SUSANOO. Points you've failed on:

-Stating crow clone used ribcage.
-Stating I'm talking about other versions of Susanoo, when I never mentioned other versions of Susanoo.
-Acting like Kakashi's statement holds any relevance when Kakashi only heard about Tsukuyomi's side effects secondhand.

I hope you realize how retarded your argument sounds. Haizaki logic: Tsukuyomi was stated to take a considerable amount of chakra, ribcage Susanoo has no such statement therefore Tsukuyomi takes more chakra than ribcage Susanoo. And you act like my evidence is shit :lol. Higher versions of Susanoo have no such statement either, does this mean Tsukuyomi takes more chakra than V4 Susanoo? Obviously not. Drop this "Kakashi's statement" point right now because that argument is pure ass.

Something I've already addressed.

And you addressed it very poorly at that.

Susano'o has different forms, hence different levels of chakra.

Irrelevant because even a ribcage Susanoo takes chakra from both eyes unlike Tsukuyomi which takes chakra from only one eye. Lord, this is so irrelevant.

Irrelevant

You just said "irrelevant" without giving any explanation. Are you expecting me to take your word for it? :lol.

All there is to it is that you failed horribly to prove your point of why a large amount can which is more than or around a Ribcage.

- Itachi's crow clone doesn't take up to half but can use a Ribcage showing it doesn't taken that much..Yet Itachi couldn't pull it out? You're trying to serious? I'll give you sometime to rethink how silly you sound.

Ribcage Susanoo doesn't have to take a significant amount more chakra than Tsukuyomi, it just has to take more, and I've already given multiple points of evidence so don't you dare say "zero proof." I'm just going to strike through every time you say crow clone used ribcage.

If it doesn't then it stands no chance. Nothing suggest Konan can control paper in these circumstances.

Very well then, you asked for it. Yugito Nii has detonated paper bombs [ ] and she is not listed as a user for yin or yang release. Therefore it doesn't take yang chakra to explode a paper bomb. Therefore Konan can explode a paper bomb perfectly fine even if her yang chakra is being supressed. Yin and yang has nothing to do with it. End of story.

No but notice none responded to my last post because of the points I raised.

Or maybe they haven't got around to replying. No way am I going to read through all of their posts and yours, but I trust Apex and KidGamer's judgment more than yours.

He obviously would have done it if it could isn't an argument you know? Not to mention the Genjutsu suppressing them are different. Genjutsu controls the chakra in your head and Killer B was filled with Hachibi's chakra . Hence that chakra should have been suppressed since that's the chakra being controlled. Plus the bottom right of this scan, B states his almost absorbed most of my chakra despite us knowing it was Hachibi's chakra given to him at that point . He couldn't because that was the Chakra given to him for him to control.

Hence that chakra should have been suppressed.

No. Hachibi's chakra=/=Bee's chakra. Bee was put under genjutsu. Hachibi wasn't. Therefore Bee's chakra got supressed. Hachibi's didn't. Being the jinchuuriki of the Hachibi doesn't change that. Bee made that statement because Kisame absorbed most of Bee's chakra as well as a good portion of Hachibi's.

Show me where the panels indicate them hovering...Show me where got them from. I really wonder where...Explain to me why there's one above her head and 3 in from of her in different positions. She could have manipulated them while Nagato strengthened it or made it faster. Why are they not shown being manipulated? That's an assumption.

I've never been surprised before...Let's look at the 2 panels and you tell me if the position of the bottom right and bottom left are the same Hell no..They cleared as she threw it and in the Nagato panel, there's no paper there. They won't be scattering about if she could control them and the one above won't be that far from her head in the next panel. Minimal evidence that she did. Why didn't the fire the other ones? Why just 2? Maybe because she couldn't freely manipulate them because she fired 4-5 at a time in her paper state at Obito in this state.

I've addressed all this already and honestly don't feel like doing it again.

That you have no point.

Ok? You were the one who brought up Tobirama. I don't see how that scan has anything to do with what we're discussing.

- Konan slaps to activate her God technique. That could just mean the paper bombs were way too much to be controlled at the same time..1 billion anyways which is why it was made into a technique.

Which only further supports my point that Konan manipulates papers on a larger scale when she aids in physical movement, and has nothing to do with her being in paper form.

- Konan creates paper into a sword to stab Jiraiya?

Why didn't she remotely stab the ninja by manipulating the paper sword instead of going up to him and physically stabbing him?

- Konan is manipulating her paper Lol..She's activating her Shikigami technique.

She moved her hand out in front of her for no apparent reason.

- How does that even show Konan using hand movements to manipulate her paper? She's releasing paper from her body and firing it at him.

To me it looks like she physically threw the shurikens.

- Not sure how that show her having to user hand movements to control them? Because she flies upwards and then her paper moves at the same time with her moving towards Obito.

Look at her left hand. She moved it.

Let's assume your point was made, it would never ever show that Base Konan can replicate the same. Not to mention the first time she tried firing paper at Obito, she had to transform first to throw that much at him? Why? Why not in her Base form and then when she wanted to attack him directly, she could have transformed then to save chakra.

Yes it does because it would show that Konan sometimes moves to control paper and sometimes she doesn't, for the same reason Gaara sometimes does and sometimes doesn't. Most likely explanation? She can manipulate paper faster and on a larger scale when she directly manipulates chakra through movement, just like Gaara. Proof for the bold?

Thanks, another proof that she requires physical movement in order to manipulate paper. There's a reason to why there are 2 forms...Paper form and Base form. Shows that her flexibility with the paper is much greater than her base form asides this assumption.

Smh, no. She moved her hand into a position so that the boquet of flowers would be in her hand after she formed it.

While the remaining sound 5 do nothing...Not to mention this would mess up her view and Jirobo who can use hiding like a mole would take advantage of this trapping her. Plus if she's focused on Tayuya, webs can catch her off guard, Kimmi can shoot out Teshi Sendan. There just a lot of combos that can come after he once she's caught off guard. They all need to protect Tayuya and that's it.

I addressed the Yin argument.

Addressed this argument. Even you shouldn't be denying that Konan wins now. The drowning out flute music with explosions was the final nail in the coffin.
 
Last edited:

Beans2

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
8,937
Reaction score
462
@Beans I'll take a look at your post later and I like how you jump from how Genjutsu isn't a factor when it won't hit her anyways. I'll take it as a concession. As for the rest, I'll give it a look later on considering how cocky and disrespectful you're getting by telling me to change my post.

You've been nothing but cocky and disrespectful this whole time, and only now am I giving you the same treatment.
 

Apêx1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
6,929
Reaction score
442
Wait this is were it gets tricky and to prove the bold is an assumption..I'll say this. The DB state Tayuya's spirits are made of almost Mental energy so they are in an unstable state. Hence when they get that energy, they attain a physical state and no longer search for the energy/stability because it has been attained


So this is the part where I disagree with you...If Susano'o already attains a physical state, it shouldn't still crave for physical energy because it has already attained it. You go against what is said because you're claiming it needs physical energy in order to be maintained but what's stated is it needs physical energy in order to be stable. Susano'o attains stability once that physical energy has been attained. However, it's false to state that it still needs that physical energy to be maintained being the reason why it draws comparison to the spirits.

That's not how it works bro. Susano has canonically reverted to its ethereal state when the user was far too drained physically . And yes, it was only physical because he clearly still had the chakra to use it based on the fact that he used a v4 Susano later on. And no, Karin's healing is only physical healing, it does not provide the person who bites with chakra by itself, contrary to popular belief. It uses chakra to heal, if you want to prove it outright grants chakra then go ahead and try to support such an argument. And anyways, Sasuke forms the Susano with his own chakra, not with Karin's chakra (she refers to his chakra potency when it reaches v4 [wouldn't be the case if it was her weaker chakra]). Don't use the "Karin says x is sucking up her chakra" because her healing expends her own chakra logically speaking. Don't confuse giving chakra which heals (her life force) and giving chakra by itself. Keep in mind, Karin has also used this jutsu on herself [ ]. Susano attains stability because of the user's physical energy being in the equation. The equation is basically: Yin+physical energy=stable Susano. Take away the physical energy and it becomes Yin=ethereal Susano. Your argument would only be valid if the user no longer needed to exert chakra to maintain his Susano, or if the user would feel absolutely no draw backs from the Susano regardless of how long he maintained it, which obviously is not the case.

Because the spirits are composed of mental energy and have an unstable, they search for physical energy...Hence if composed of physical energy, it shouldn't search for physical energy still when the stable state has been attained because datebook states only in and unstable state with almost all mental energy you search for that physical energy. You talk of physical energy in order for it t be maintained when that's not the case as they only need physical energy for the stable state to be attained and not maintained.

There's a constant craving for stability by both physical and spiritual energies. They work in a balance as Kakashi stated. It would constantly require the Susano user's physical energy in order to maintain that stability, thus it continuously uses it.
 
Last edited:

Beans2

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
8,937
Reaction score
462
You know what? I'll say f**k it and concede that entire last post. This will make things easier for you Haizaki, just reply to my post before that. I don't care about sticking to my original arguments, this thread can go to hell as long as Konan wins in the end.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
That's not how it works bro. Susano has canonically reverted to its ethereal state when the user was far too drained physically . And yes, it was only physical because he clearly still had the chakra to use it based on the fact that he used a v4 Susano later on. And no, Karin's healing is only physical healing, it does not provide the person who bites with chakra by itself, contrary to popular belief. It uses chakra to heal, if you want to prove it outright grants chakra then go ahead and try to support such an argument. And anyways, Sasuke forms the Susano with his own chakra, not with Karin's chakra (she refers to his chakra potency when it reaches v4 [wouldn't be the case if it was her weaker chakra]). Don't use the "Karin says x is sucking up her chakra" because her healing expends her own chakra logically speaking. Don't confuse giving chakra which heals (her life force) and giving chakra by itself. Keep in mind, Karin has also used this jutsu on herself [ ]. Susano attains stability because of the user's physical energy being in the equation. The equation is basically: Yin+physical energy=stable Susano. Take away the physical energy and it becomes Yin=ethereal Susano. Your argument would only be valid if the user no longer needed to exert chakra to maintain his Susano, or if the user would feel absolutely no draw backs from the Susano regardless of how long he maintained it, which obviously is not the case

When Sasuke tried activating a higher form, his chakra started growing weaker but when his chakra was replenished, he could then activate higher forms. He could only activate a V4 later on and that didn't last long. Just like he struggled to activate Susano'o against Mei and it disappeared shortly.

Your argument goes like this:

1. Susano'o - Yin state. Therefore unstable state.
2. Susano'o takes physical energy and therefore becomes stable
3. Susano'o still takes in physical energy despite attaining a stable state but in this case to maintain its stable state? From where though? Where was it stated they need to constantly crave this physical energy to maintain a stable state? Even when it's been attained?

Absolutely not...I think you should look at this carefully again as there's some big indication:

The materialized spirits are composed almost only of mental energy, so the chakra is in an unstable state. Therefore, they are starved for physical energy, search for it

There's a big hint there telling us that physical energy is only searched when a stable state isn't attained. Not for it to be maintained. As for the ethereal,

I won't refer to it as ethereal state but the Aura as I don't think Naruto's cloak is also ethereal(We've seen this as well against Madara taking Kurama from him):

You must be registered for see images



There's a constant craving for stability by both physical and spiritual energies. They work in a balance as Kakashi stated. It would constantly require the Susano user's physical energy in order to maintain that stability, thus it continuously uses it.

Like I stated, the physical energy is to attain a stable state not to maintain. Why does Sasuke's Susano'o still crave physical energy when a stable state is attained? If we go by what that DB states to use, Physical energy is only craved for when a stable state isn't reached not when a stable state is reached. Sasuke already attains a stable state so it should be wrong that his energy is still being drained despite already attained that state. That energy is only craved when one is in an unstable state not in order to maintain a stable state. Where was that from?

@Beans, Yeah it was getting ridiculously long but I'll address that other post of yours.
 
Last edited:

Apêx1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
6,929
Reaction score
442
When Sasuke tried activating a higher form, his chakra started growing weaker but when his chakra was replenished, he could then activate higher forms. He could only activate a V4 later on and that didn't last long. Just like he struggled to activate Susano'o against Mei and it disappeared shortly.

Your argument goes like this:

1. Susano'o - Yin state. Therefore unstable state.
2. Susano'o takes physical energy and therefore becomes stable
3. Susano'o still takes in physical energy despite attaining a stable state but in this case to maintain its stable state? From where though? Where was it stated they need to constantly crave this physical energy to maintain a stable state? Even when it's been attained?

Absolutely not...I think you should look at this carefully again as there's some big indication:



There's a big hint there telling us that physical energy is only searched when a stable state isn't attained. Not for it to be maintained. As for the ethereal,

I won't refer to it as ethereal state but the Aura as I don't think Naruto's cloak is also ethereal(We've seen this as well against Madara taking Kurama from him):

You must be registered for see images





Like I stated, the physical energy is to attain a stable state not to maintain. Why does Sasuke's Susano'o still crave physical energy when a stable state is attained? If we go by what that DB states to use, Physical energy is only craved for when a stable state isn't reached not when a stable state is reached. Sasuke already attains a stable state so it should be wrong that his energy is still being drained despite already attained that state. That energy is only craved when one is in an unstable state not in order to maintain a stable state. Where was that from?

@Beans, Yeah it was getting ridiculously long but I'll address that other post of yours.

This should end the whole debate; Susano is never in a completely stable state. Look at the ethereal marks still present [ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ]. That should destroy your argument since it would constantly crave physical energy given it's never in a completely stable state. Cannot possibly see how you intend to counter this since you'd have to go against your own logic.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
This should end the whole debate; Susano is never in a completely stable state. Look at the ethereal marks still present [ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ]. That should destroy your argument since it would constantly crave physical energy given it's never in a completely stable state. Cannot possibly see how you intend to counter this since you'd have to go against your own logic.

I can't believe you right now especially when you said it was stable, Once again that's Aura... "Chakra takes a physical form" ? Not to mention this makes things worse for you ignoring the fact that you've now shown Onoki stating this upon PS coming out:

You must be registered for see images

Even further proof that what you've been showing all along has been the Aura considering PS is among the examples. So explain to me why physical energy is still drained? Even at this.


DB states "Chakra takes a physical form"...Apex states "Chakra takes a physical and well who knows what's the other" . Not to mention I asked you earlier if you knew what you were saying relating to this and your reply:

@bold, It's a very simple explanation. Tayuya's spirits crave stability, they want physical energy to become a stable state ie physical. Sasuke's Susano already has the necessary physical energy for it to be stable and thus it turns into a physical state. I showed you Susano in its ethereal form, that's it's spiritual state. When you supply it with physical energy it turns into a stable physical state. It's a very logical and clear explanation and I can't see you possibly disagreeing with it given the logic and support behind it.

Now you're stating it's half stable and what? Smh Apex I don't think this should be argued anymore as you've heavily contradicted yourself. Now you've agreed and seen that what I stated and provide with the DB is factual regarding to the attainment and maintenance argument so you go to state this? Clearly false seeing as it strictly takes a physical form and that has to be the Aura as I've drawn similar comparisons. Now you've gone against yourself, what next? Very bad for you now since it's more like a dead end.
 
Last edited:

Apêx1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
6,929
Reaction score
442
I can't believe you right now especially when you said it was stable, Once again that's Aura... "Chakra takes a physical form" ? Not to mention this makes things worse for you ignoring the fact that you've now shown Onoki stating this upon PS coming out:

You must be registered for see images

Even further proof that what you've been showing all along has been the Aura considering PS is among the examples. So explain to me why physical energy is still drained? Even at this.


DB states "Chakra takes a physical form"...Apex states "Chakra takes a physical and well who knows what's the other" . Not to mention I asked you earlier if you knew what you were saying relating to this and your reply:



Now you're stating it's half stable and what? Smh Apex I don't think this should be argued anymore as you've heavily contradicted yourself. Now you've agreed and seen that what I stated and provide with the DB is factual regarding to the attainment and maintenance argument so you go to state this? Clearly false seeing as it strictly takes a physical form and that has to be the Aura as I've drawn similar comparisons. Now you've gone against yourself, what next? Very bad for you now since it's more like a dead end.

It is stable. Whether it's completely stable or not is completely irrelevant though, because it if it's completely stable then it would follow the equation I already gave you before, and physical energy would still need to be consistently expended in order to maintain the balance. If it isn't then I'm still right since it would still be craving stability. You're just going in circles since my original counter, and not countering much of anything. Also, I have no idea why you keep mentioning aura when Susano clearly works nothing like Zabuza's aura. It's its ethereal form. You're just grasping at straws at this point, because I've proven beyond reasonable doubt that it's Yin.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
It is stable. Whether it's completely stable or not is completely irrelevant though, because it if it's completely stable then it would follow the equation I already gave you before, and physical energy would still need to be consistently expended in order to maintain the balance. If it isn't then I'm still right since it would still be craving stability. You're just going in circles since my original counter, and not countering much of anything. Also, I have no idea why you keep mentioning aura when Susano clearly works nothing like Zabuza's aura. It's its ethereal form. You're just grasping at straws at this point, because I've proven beyond reasonable doubt that it's Yin.

You don't know what you're saying because if you did, you'll address my previous point. You conceded to that point which was why you brought in this complete/incomplete stability which is clearly false given the description and not your assumption.

Lmao Grasping at straws? You know what that means? You've directly contradicted yourself yet I'm the one grasping? Plus the fact that I showed Zabuza releasing Aura before he released his Hidden mist was just an example. However looking at the comparisons I showed with the avatar(Look at that spoiler I showed which clearly shows this perfectly)...Look at the fact that PS is stable but still has that Aura round it and by the way Apex, what makes you state this is ethereal? Where from? I hope it's not the passing through because it's shown one can pass through the avatar. Yet is it ethereal? You've also failed to tell me why it's in a spiritual/physical state but yet the DB states solely "Chakra takes a physical form"

Once again refer to my attain/maintenance argument going by strictly the description given to us. It would show to you that your take on it is wrong plus the fact the physical form argument I dropped
 

Apêx1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
6,929
Reaction score
442
You don't know what you're saying because if you did, you'll address my previous point. You conceded to that point which was why you brought in this complete/incomplete stability which is clearly false given the description and not your assumption.

Lmao Grasping at straws? You know what that means? You've directly contradicted yourself yet I'm the one grasping? Plus the fact that I showed Zabuza releasing Aura before he released his Hidden mist was just an example. However looking at the comparisons I showed with the avatar(Look at that spoiler I showed which clearly shows this perfectly)...Look at the fact that PS is stable but still has that Aura round it and by the way Apex, what makes you state this is ethereal? Where from? I hope it's not the passing through because it's shown one can pass through the avatar. Yet is it ethereal? You've also failed to tell me why it's in a spiritual/physical state but yet the DB states solely "Chakra takes a physical form"

Once again refer to my attain/maintenance argument going by strictly the description given to us. It would show to you that your take on it is wrong plus the fact the physical form argument I dropped

Conceded my ass, I raised up something else as an alternative because you mentioned the same trash after I already countered it. EVERYONE has been convinced by me and everyone is liking my posts yet nobody is liking yours. I wonder what that means. :rolleyes: This is a joke and should've been finished on post #158, yet you kept going because you're too stubborn to ever concede. Same with out previous debates, where people are convinced by my arguments ie Itachi vs Bee yet nobody is convinced by yours. No point in me needing to continuously explain the same thing and then having you raise the same defeated points as a desperate attempt to grasp at straws.

Your attain/maintain argument would only be right if the chakra would stay in that state indefinitely. Since it needs to be maintained then the chakra would be constantly striving for the balance by taking a constant amount of his physical energy. It's not only striving for a balance when it's craving physical energy, it would strive for a balance even if it was craving spiritual energy. That's why it's called a balance. Once it's balanced it strives to maintain that balance, if it wasn't taking any physical energy from the user then it wouldn't be maintaining that balance in the first place now would it?.. Last time I try, next time you reply with the same defeated arguments I won't even bother.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
Conceded my ass, I raised up something else as an alternative because you mentioned the same trash after I already countered it. EVERYONE has been convinced by me and everyone is liking my posts yet nobody is liking yours. I wonder what that means. :rolleyes: This is a joke and should've been finished on post #158, yet you kept going because you're too stubborn to ever concede. Same with out previous debates, where people are convinced by my arguments ie Itachi vs Bee yet nobody is convinced by yours. No point in me needing to continuously explain the same thing and then having you raise the same defeated points as a desperate attempt to grasp at straws.

Your attain/maintain argument would only be right if the chakra would stay in that state indefinitely. Since it needs to be maintained then the chakra would be constantly striving for the balance by taking a constant amount of his physical energy. It's not only striving for a balance when it's craving physical energy, it would strive for a balance even if it was craving spiritual energy. That's why it's called a balance. Once it's balanced it strives to maintain that balance, if it wasn't taking any physical energy from the user then it wouldn't be maintaining that balance in the first place now would it?.. Last time I try, next time you reply with the same defeated arguments I won't even bother.

Apex please shut up...You've directly contradicted yourself and the people convinced by you are either the Konan fans or KidGamer who isn't sure. Though I bet right now he won't want to stick by your side now that's it's evidently clear that you contradicted yourself.

Before I reply, I want to know what your stand is? Susano'o being chakra in a physical state/ spiritual state or just a physical state? i'm asking you because you've directly contradicted yourself by stating it's in one state and then stating it being in another state in different post. Where's your stand now? Once you tell me this I know where to finish your arguments. Also, I was hoping we'll get solid proof of your ethereal state rather than the Aura but we didn't.
 
Last edited:

Apêx1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
6,929
Reaction score
442
Apex please shut up...You've directly contradicted yourself and the people convinced by you are either the Konan fans or KidGamer who isn't sure. Though I bet right now he won't want to stick by your side now that's it's evidently clear that you contradicted yourself.

Before I reply, I want to know what your stand is? Susano'o being chakra in a physical state/ spiritual state or just a physical state? i'm asking you because you've directly contradicted yourself by stating it's in one state and then stating it being in another state in different post. Where's your stand now? Once you tell me this I know where to finish your arguments. Also, I was hoping we'll get solid proof of your ethereal state rather than the Aura but we didn't.

How is it a contradiction? Please learn what an alternative argument is; I can provide alternatives as long as my main argument is un-countered. My two arguments don't coincide with one another, they're simply to support the possibility of Susano being Yin beyond a reasonable doubt.

I see no arguments at all, you can go ahead and counter the thing you've failed to counter in your last 2-3 posts:

Your attain/maintain argument would only be right if the chakra would stay in that state indefinitely. Since it needs to be maintained then the chakra would be constantly striving for the balance by taking a constant amount of his physical energy. It's not only striving for a balance when it's craving physical energy, it would strive for a balance even if it was craving spiritual energy. That's why it's called a balance. Once it's balanced it strives to maintain that balance, if it wasn't taking any physical energy from the user then it wouldn't be maintaining that balance in the first place now would it?.. Last time I try, next time you reply with the same defeated arguments I won't even bother.

I've already shown Susano going ethereal
 
Last edited:

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
How is it a contradiction? Please learn what an alternative argument is; I can provide alternatives as long as my main argument is un-countered. My two arguments don't coincide with one another, they're simply to support the possibility of Susano being Yin beyond a reasonable doubt.

I see no arguments at all, you can go ahead and counter the thing you've failed to counter in your last 2-3 posts:

Your attain/maintain argument would only be right if the chakra would stay in that state indefinitely. Since it needs to be maintained then the chakra would be constantly striving for the balance by taking a constant amount of his physical energy. It's not only striving for a balance when it's craving physical energy, it would strive for a balance even if it was craving spiritual energy. That's why it's called a balance. Once it's balanced it strives to maintain that balance, if it wasn't taking any physical energy from the user then it wouldn't be maintaining that balance in the first place now would it?.. Last time I try, next time you reply with the same defeated arguments I won't even bother.

I've already shown Susano going ethereal

I cannot believe you at this point I swear....I automatically knew you were wrong once you contradicted your arguments. What is an alt argument? The fact that you showed you evidently don't know what you're stating hence twisting the form of Susano'o in both arguments to prove your point?

I countered your point effectively and proved that Susano'o isn't in an ethereal state and physical state at the same time like you stated. This is the only way your balancing argument would make sense. However you've only assumed that's an ethereal state and not actually proved it to us WHY. I claimed it was an aura and my point was 100% correct given the fact that you tried using PS as proof that it's always in both physical state and spiritual state. I prove you wrong yet again which you evidently accepted and this is the more reason why it should lean towards an Aura plus the fact that I showed that Naruto/Sasuke comparison.

You then go ahead to say it's Irrelevant even after you said it's the destruction of my post? Lmfao:

This should end the whole debate; Susano is never in a completely stable state. Look at the ethereal marks still present [ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ][ ]. That should destroy your argument since it would constantly crave physical energy given it's never in a completely stable state. Cannot possibly see how you intend to counter this since you'd have to go against your own logic.

Then what's next? Apex finally accepts that's it's physical energy? Correct? Given he fact that the DB states "Chakra takes a physical form", there's no way we can have both states at a time as that's twisting Kishi's words...Hence KidGamer as well as you(Well probably him alone I recall) thought the only reasonable conclusion from this is that Susano'o is converted from spiritual to physical form...This came up due to you stating it transforms from the Ethereal state to the physical state. However you alone shot your foot once you pulled out scans of Susnao'o still having that Aura(Hence not an ethereal state). We know the DB states chakra takes a physical form and we also know for a fact that Susano'o is stabilized chakra hence that scan you tried to prove with PS failed you badly.

Now considering I've shown it's only completely a physical form..Hence a stable state, we can go back to you addressing this:

Your argument goes like this:

1. Susano'o - Yin state. Therefore unstable state.
2. Susano'o takes physical energy and therefore becomes stable
3. Susano'o still takes in physical energy despite attaining a stable state but in this case to maintain its stable state? From where though? Where was it stated they need to constantly crave this physical energy to maintain a stable state? Even when it's been attained?

Absolutely not...I think you should look at this carefully again as there's some big indication:
The materialized spirits are composed almost only of mental energy, so the chakra is in an unstable state. Therefore, they are starved for physical energy, search for it

Like I stated, the physical energy is to attain a stable state not to maintain. Why does Sasuke's Susano'o still crave physical energy when a stable state is attained? If we go by what that DB states to use, Physical energy is only craved for when a stable state isn't reached not when a stable state is reached. Sasuke already attains a stable state so it should be wrong that his energy is still being drained despite already attained that state. That energy is only craved when one is in an unstable state not in order to maintain a stable state. Where was that from?
There's a big hint there telling us that physical energy is only searched when a stable state isn't attained. Not for it to be maintained.


This was where your "alternative argument" came into play which ended being wrong..Logically that means you knew my post countered yours for you to form something WRONG hence you ignore it stating "whether or not" and go back to speculation while my post uses something fully backed up. Itachi/B situation was controversial because there wasn't proper proof. KG disagreed with you at first there? There wasn't proper proof and even if you may be correct, then that's cool. However in this case? You're wrong given your arguments. Stop acting like I'm the only stubborn when you also disagreed with the Majority regarding that shared vision topic/rain tiger topic, though that was pretty clear compared to the Kunai.
 

Apêx1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
6,929
Reaction score
442
Rofl, won't be bothering with you anymore at this point. Told myself this once before, but this time for sure I won't be wasting my time with someone more stubborn then prime Zex. It's almost like you're too proud to concede, maybe if you took things a little less seriously you'd start seeing things more clearly.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
Rofl, won't be bothering with you anymore at this point. Told myself this once before, but this time for sure I won't be wasting my time with someone more stubborn then prime Zex. It's almost like you're too proud to concede, maybe if you took things a little less seriously you'd start seeing things more clearly.

You know what stubborn is? Stubborn is directly denying something the Manga states. I'm sure my points directly counters yours 100%..I'm sure I countered it because it's not even clear but just speculation on your part..Yours is pure speculation and I can't believe you think you're correct without addressing that aspect I brought up which seems to be true. I can't believe you confidently raise your arms but then contradict yourself? You're excuse is "Oh he denied the Kunai argument before so he's deemed stubborn" "He's too proud" Smh, Proud of WHAT? Apex I have a life outside here so please keep your nonsensical advise to yourself lol.

Not to mention don't call me stubborn when you've been caught outright denying manga evidence several times. Lmao dude please thanks for the advise and when you catch me arguing against something that has been 100% shown by the Manga, come back.
 

Beans2

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
8,937
Reaction score
462
Yall arguing about who KG agreed with lmao.
 

RedRobin

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
Messages
12,929
Reaction score
834
Jirobo and Sakon/Ukon are useless in this match up due to Konan being in the air.

Tayuya risks putting the other sound members in the sound genjustu if she uses it.

Kido is the only dangerous one here but Konan's paper form really makes his attacks non-effective.

The only problem here is Konan not having the best fire power in putting them down but she eventually gets it done.
 
Top