Justification of the Uchiha in this picture

[KingHashirama]

You must be registered for see images

^_^ That right there is it my friend. UCHIHAS NEVER BETRAYED THE LEAF. They were the good guys.

 

[Jellal Fernandes]

Chapter 590. Yes we know.

 

[KidGamer65]

I don't see your point. By planning a coup in the first place they betrayed the village.

 

[rollin]

i might have interpreted that manga page differently from you

 

[Joten Uchiha]

I don't see your point. By planning a coup in the first place they betrayed the village.

This, Itachi's actions were justified as they were gonna be wiped out either way.

 

[KonanAkatsuki]

They never even knew exactly if Uchiha would betray them I mean come on no one sided with Madara's plan so what makes them think Uchiha was going to give something as good as living in Konoha up?????

 

[Elementalist]

lol what....the only reason they never betrayed the leaf is because they were killed before the coup could begin.........

 

[Brooks]

True, Danzo was just a mad because Hiruzen owned him at everything....he wanted to do everything to become Hokage.

 

[Ōkami]

Senju defending the Uchiha ain't that some shit

 

[somniferous]

I don't see your point. By planning a coup in the first place they betrayed the village.

This about sums it up

 

[KingHashirama]

I don't see your point. By planning a coup in the first place they betrayed the village.

The Statues they are represented by
Uchiha - Buddha
Danzo - That god who i believe is suppose to be the devil or something

i might have interpreted that manga page differently from you

What did you interpret?

This, Itachi's actions were justified as they were gonna be wiped out either way.

So the people who killed the Jew under Hitler's order were justified? nope.

lol what....the only reason they never betrayed the leaf is because they were killed before the coup could begin.........

They were never going to betray the leaf...... It the leaders of the village that declared them traitors.. They want equality.. only 1 person at that time had the actual brains.. which was Hiruzen Sarutobi.

 

[Brooks]

I don't see your point. By planning a coup in the first place they betrayed the village.

And by pushing the Uchihas from the Village, Konoha also betrayed the Uchihas....see this can go both ways.

 

[Prometheus Beta]

The full story behind the coup, from the clans perspective, is not known yet and I bet you something else will be revealed like Obito/Madara was masterminding it from the shadows by manipulating the clan leaders, thats pretty much the only way I can see Sasuke changing his mind about getting revenge (thered be no point in him wanting to go to the "one who knows everything" if this wasnt going to happen).

 

[Prometheus Beta]

And Danzo was probably the biggest fcktard in this whole affair to be honest, had it not been for him, Shisui wouldve simply stopped the clan with his MS genjutsu -a much better solution than slaughtering an entire group of people, women and presumably children (except Sasuke) included.

 

[KingHashirama]

The full story behind the coup, from the clans perspective, is not known yet and I bet you something else will be revealed like Obito/Madara was masterminding it from the shadows by manipulating the clan leaders, thats pretty much the only way I can see Sasuke changing his mind about getting revenge (thered be no point in him wanting to go to the "one who knows everything" if this wasnt going to happen).

There was no masterminding needed. The clan had the right to everything they were going to do.. The leaders of Konoha chose to blame the whole clan for something they had no proof of. They CHOSE to segregate them out of the city.... ;D.

Also, Sasuke wants revenge for what they did to Itachi.. not the Uchiha clan.

If Danzo hadn't been there then Sarutobi would've just talked to them. The thing is Danzo and the other 2 geezers got scared that the uchiha might take some political power.

 

[KidGamer65]

And by pushing the Uchihas from the Village Konoha also betrayed the Uchihas....see this can go both ways.

I completely forgot about this, you make a very good point. The Village started the "chain of hate" between the Uchiha and the Leaf.

 

[Exaar]

There was no masterminding needed. The clan had the right to everything they were going to do.. The leaders of Konoha chose to blame the whole clan for something they had no proof of. They CHOSE to segregate them out of the city.... ;D.

Also, Sasuke wants revenge for what they did to Itachi.. not the Uchiha clan.

The uchiha's had no right to try to take over the leaf.

The Village had proof of this, Itachi was the informant and was the person who most likely brought it to their attention in the first place.

 

[Elementalist]

The Statues they are represented by
Uchiha - Buddha
Danzo - That god who i believe is suppose to be the devil or something


What did you interpret?

So the people who killed the Jew under Hitler's order were justified? nope.


They were never going to betray the leaf...... It the leaders of the village that declared them traitors.. They want equality.. only 1 person at that time had the actual brains.. which was Hiruzen Sarutobi.

hhmm I see where your coming from, but still there are other ways to find equality. I mean the uchiha went for a coup that would probably, if they succeeded, tipped the balance and given them way to much control in the village, and that's not equality, that my friend, is downright mutiny

 

[KingHashirama]

The uchiha's had no right to try to take over the leaf.

The Village had proof of this, Itachi was the informant and was the person who most likely brought it to their attention in the first place.

Do we have proof of their plan? nope. Do we know that they were aggressive? nope... Why? Because Fugaku didn't even try to fight back against his own son.. He simply gave up ....

WRONG. Only the 4 konoha leaders knew about this. And that guy who brought information to them was a 13 year old naive guy who now thinks he could've changed something if he had told Sasuke about it back then.

Uchiha protect the village for a long time mate. But were segregated because of a assumption.. its basically if California was to be put on a lockdown.. woudl you expect the people of California to sit quiet? uh no why? Because its their country also. .. Hell even Sarutobi felt the same way. And notice how they old lady geezer got mad when she got the idea that they might try to take some political power ;].

hhmm I see where your coming from, but still there are other ways to find equality. I mean the uchiha went for a coup that would probably, if they succeeded, tipped the balance and given them way to much control in the village, and that's not equality, that my friend, is downright mutiny

The thing is we DON"T KNOW if it was a coup or not. We simply don't. Now what can be analyzed is that when Itachi brought them the news.. it was about Uchiha going for a revolution... but the old lady said if by that Revolution they want political power BACK.. then they will be treated as traitors.

Also, if they really were against the village.. then Fugaku would've done something Itachi. He already knew that Itachi was being a double spy.

 

[Prometheus Beta]

There was no masterminding needed. The clan had the right to everything they were going to do.. The leaders of Konoha chose to blame the whole clan for something they had no proof of. They CHOSE to segregate them out of the city.... ;D.

Also, Sasuke wants revenge for what they did to Itachi.. not the Uchiha clan.

If Danzo hadn't been there then Sarutobi would've just talked to them. The thing is Danzo and the other 2 geezers got scared that the uchiha might take some political power.

As far as we know, the only thing the leaf did was segregate and be suspicious of them, nothing more. That doesnt warrant a coup detat that would without a doubt lead to civil war. The leaf had nothing to do with Itachi, only the elders (mostly just Danzo) did. However you look at it, Sasuke wanting to destroy the entire leaf village along with its inhabitants cannot be justified.