Itachi vs Minato: who is more nobler?

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

Minato:

Sacrificed his life for the village

Sealed the Kyuubi in his own son even though he will experience hardships all for the sake of defeating Madara


Itachi:

Killed his clan for the sake of the Village

Joined Akatsuki to protect Konoha

Stopped Edo Tensei

 

[MarkPaul]

Minato ofc, since birth.

 

[Ventalus]

Minato:

Sacrificed his life for the village

Sealed the Kyuubi in his own son even though he will experience hardships all for the sake of defeating Madara


Itachi:

Killed his clan for the sake of the Village

Joined Akatsuki to protect Konoha

Stopped Edo Tensei

Minato, for selling his soul to the Reaper to protect the village.

 

[Midday]

Slaughtering your family and clan isn't really noble.

 

[aGuyNamedQuest]

Slaughtering your family and clan isn't really noble.

agreed. Itachi lived his life through dishonor and deception

 

[The Necromancer]

They're about equal. Itachi accepted his own death and disgrace for his clan all while protecting the village from itself. Minato died to protect the village from the kyuubi, while accepting the possibility of his son's hate in order to make him strong.

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

Slaughtering your family and clan isn't really noble.

he slaughtered them for the sake of peace and the prevention of more bloodbath

 

[Rayder]

Slaughtering your family and clan isn't really noble.

And making yourself known world-wide as a heinous criminal while you did it for the greater good, isn't noble ?

 

[Midday]

he slaughtered them for the sake of peace and the prevention of more bloodbath

Either way it's far from noble.

 

[aGuyNamedQuest]

he slaughtered them for the sake of peace and the prevention of more bloodbath

if you think slaughter is peace...your wrong...there are many ways to do things in life....hiruzen's method of word would have been best...

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

if you think slaughter is peace...your wrong...there are many ways to do things in life....hiruzen's method of word would have been best...

But Danzo and the two elders didnt agree and made Itachi choose, Itachi chose the village for the sake of peace and the preservation of the honor of his clan

 

[CurseSealofEarth]

if you think slaughter is peace...your wrong...there are many ways to do things in life....hiruzen's method of word would have been best...

Had it not worked, Itachi still would have slaughtered them.

 

[SonicBoom]

Itachi lived a much harder life than Minato. Most people can't do what Itachi did, and even if they can, they would probably end up committing suicide.

Minato is more nobler.

 

[2big]

More Noble to the leaf is itachi he killed all his friends and family then fled letting everyone think he is a murderer and then purposly let sasuke beat him so he wouldnt attack the leaf

 

[aGuyNamedQuest]

But Danzo and the two elders didnt agree and made Itachi choose, Itachi chose the village for the sake of peace and the preservation of the honor of his clan

**** DANZO!!! It was his fault by even instagating a choice like that behind hiruzen's back let alone the whole village's view on the situation...

 

[Prince Charles]

Itachi by far..

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

More Noble to the leaf is itachi he killed all his friends and family then fled letting everyone think he is a murderer and then purposly let sasuke beat him so he wouldnt attack the leaf

yeah at least minato was honored for his sacrifice, itachi was shamed and villified for his

 

[Ventalus]

Sure that Itachi lived a harder life. But as well he is free from pain and suffering now. Meanwhile Minato is still in a forever suffering and pain in the belly of the Reaper :/

(That's what third hokage said at least)

 

[gameove]

itachi , to do what he did , kill his parents please, self sacrifice is a true shinobi

 

[2big]

yeah at least minato was honored for his sacrifice, itachi was shamed and villified for his

yeah he basically lived in hell just for the leaf