Itachi Vs Kakashi(No Sharingans in this match)

Winner?


  • Total voters
    179

Kato.

Active member
Elite
Joined
Dec 12, 2011
Messages
6,783
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Itachi cannot use his genjutsu????
lol... i gues the thread maker even removed itachi's hand....
ahh i forgot about itachi using his fingers for genjustsu, i was more focused on the stronger genjustsu itachi uses with his sharingan, hmm... that makes me think the fight would be more close than i originally thought
 

Ultimatevirus

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
4,939
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
ahh i forgot about itachi using his fingers for genjustsu, i was more focused on the stronger genjustsu itachi uses with his sharingan, hmm... that makes me think the fight would be more close than i originally thought
plus itachi's fingering oops i mean by finger genjutsu is not weak... it is a decent one.... ithink decent enough to beat kakashi at genjutsu
 

Itachi Namikaze

Active member
Elite
Joined
Mar 28, 2011
Messages
5,545
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I never downgrade anyone.

It's true that itachi is a bit faster than kakashi, but then again, itachi doesn't have his sharingan either and it will be hard to keep up with kakashi himself despite not being as fast.

They are both extremely smart, but I would probably give itachi a slight edge as well.

Itachi is very adept at genjutsu no doubt, but that doesn't mean that kakashi is unable to counter with any at all despite his inferiority in the matter.

You can't even say itachi has higher levels if it's not equal, even if you don't take account for his illness. The databook most likely wouldn't take such factors into account as the illness was an unknown factor that hindered his abilities.

And of course ninjutsu is mostly kakashi's profession as he is most known for his skill with it, similar with itachi to genjutsu. As you said, he also has the elemental advantage.

I will not discuss his legendary items that he has, but if you go onto my twin thread, then we can discuss this w/o the legendary items as i specifically restricted itachi from using them as it gives him yet another ridiculous advantage.

Kakashi is also an elite jonin wthout it as he doesn't rely on it as much as people thinks he does and kage material with it. If the leaf had no hokages or sannin, then these two would definitely be the most likely candidates for becoming hokage.

I'm not saying that kakashi is GOING to win, but I think it is a pretty even match
When I say downgrading I mean that you weren't giving Itachi his fair credit. If he has an advantage you have to say he has the advantage, not say that they are about even.

If I lose to someone in a contest, I still lose, even if I barely lost. Oh man, I never thought I would quote vin diesel but here goes "It doesn't matter if you win by an inch or a mile".

See what I mean? I didn't mean downgrading like you hate him or think he is weak, just that you aren't saying he has the advantage when he does.

And so you agreed with everything else, other than about his chakra levels. I think the databooks has them both at either 3 or 3.5 so they are equal. But we have seen Itachi wear out a curse mark Sasuke who had absorbed Oro, while Kakashi was almost out of chakra just when he used Kamui on that Susanoo arrow.

So I guess it is relative because it seems like Itachi has better chakra control then and can use moves for less chakra.
 

Tendou00

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Sep 17, 2011
Messages
64,191
Kin
12💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
If I lose to someone in a contest, I still lose, even if I barely lost.
I think the databooks has them both at either 3 or 3.5 so they are equal.
that's called this hypocrisy.

But we have seen Itachi wear out a curse mark Sasuke who had absorbed Oro, while Kakashi was almost out of chakra just when he used Kamui on that Susanoo arrow.
almost out of chakra?
you should reread the manga against pein with only 50% of his chakra he used 1 raikiri , 1 doton and 2 kamui.
vs sasuke he was going to re use it again without any problem when tobi saved sasuke.you're obviousely the one who downgrading kakashi.

so without sharingan kakashi's will got a better stanima and control than itachi .
 
Last edited:

Sabuto Hayashi

Active member
Elite
Joined
Aug 16, 2010
Messages
5,276
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The fight would almost be a stalemate, but Kakashi would pull through in the end.
Kakashi has Earth jutsu to counter most of Itachi's Water-based jutsu, as well having Water jutsu to counter Itachi's Fire Jutsu.
On top of that, Kakashi has Raikiri, which could potentially end the battle if he can get a hit on Itachi. Then again, that depends on how well Kakashi can use Raikiri without the Sharingan.
 

zombiejesus

Active member
Elite
Joined
Aug 15, 2011
Messages
8,807
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
o waw >.> a couple of dogs

OH and to top it all off! Raikiri is a incomplete jutsu without Sharingan >< he can't see the opponents counterattack, and will get killed easily.....


Sigh -_-





Because they were in the middle of a war, so rank processing went by much faster... they needed skilled people on the ffrontlines,
I thought iruka explained this :|
i gotta respectivley disagree i mean there in a war now and a genninn is owning everyone (naruto) and yes he is tec a sage but his rank is gennin the strongest ever lol
 

fastrthnwind

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jun 9, 2011
Messages
4,539
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
When I say downgrading I mean that you weren't giving Itachi his fair credit. If he has an advantage you have to say he has the advantage, not say that they are about even.

If I lose to someone in a contest, I still lose, even if I barely lost. Oh man, I never thought I would quote vin diesel but here goes "It doesn't matter if you win by an inch or a mile".

See what I mean? I didn't mean downgrading like you hate him or think he is weak, just that you aren't saying he has the advantage when he does.

And so you agreed with everything else, other than about his chakra levels. I think the databooks has them both at either 3 or 3.5 so they are equal. But we have seen Itachi wear out a curse mark Sasuke who had absorbed Oro, while Kakashi was almost out of chakra just when he used Kamui on that Susanoo arrow.

So I guess it is relative because it seems like Itachi has better chakra control then and can use moves for less chakra.
I see what you are referring to, but I am willing to give anyone fair credit whenever its due, such as itachi's skill in genjutsu, his speed, and his intelligence.

I am even willing to argue on the other side of the debate. Such as itachi's skill in dedeucing the weaknesses in kakashi's jutsus and acting accordingly with his skill with his ninjutsu, genjutsu, and taijutsu in order to defeat kakashi.
 

ganotsri

Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2011
Messages
117
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
kakashi lose his chidori with sharingan, I mean as the Minato told, this tecnic is not good for usual spead and reaction, no sharingan, no scidori. Itachi seems to lose every thing exept katon. So even not interesting battle.
Please remind which is stronger lightning or fire???
 

fastrthnwind

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jun 9, 2011
Messages
4,539
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
kakashi lose his chidori with sharingan, I mean as the Minato told, this tecnic is not good for usual spead and reaction, no sharingan, no scidori. Itachi seems to lose every thing exept katon. So even not interesting battle.
Please remind which is stronger lightning or fire???
battles are not all ninjutsu. kakashi still has rasengan, earth and water techniques plus summonings and a few genjutsu.
 

itachi49

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Sep 2, 2011
Messages
10,140
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
first things that need to says is that databook stoped at chapter 409
so about 160 chapter ago !

while itachi died ,kakashi did great progress that have not been include in databook.

according to the manga and old databook that stoped at chapter 409 :

genjutsu : itachi

databook --> kakashi : 4 itachi : 5

kakashi and itachi can use genjutsu without sharingan but at lower level than sharingan genjutsus,since kakashi shown only 1 i'll put itachi above kakashi because of his 2 finger midle level genjutsus Dusk Crow Genjutsu and Ephemeral .

ninjutsu : : kakashi

databook --> kakashi : 5 itachi : 5

affinities can't be copied so they both still have all their elements,
itachi can use katon and suiton ,has a good fireball jutsu and can use housenka as well and a good fast suiton attack,
kakashi can use suiton,raiton and doton so more jutsu than itachi and got advantages to counter any itachi's attack.

people keep saying he only has chidori and forgot that he also got kage bunshin,Summoning Tracking Fang,raiton kage bunshin,raiju hashiri and raikiri and some suiton and doton impressing jutsu like suiji heki and doton shinju zanshu etc...

chakra : kakashi

databook --> kakashi : 3 itachi : 2.5

thread says no sharingan, kakashi will a better endurance than itachi who has 2.5 .

strengh : kakashi

databook --> kakashi : 3.5 itachi : 3.5

they're equal but the fact that kakashi can use gate is largely enough to put him above itachi,it's clearly stated only for the 1st gate

The Gate of Opening (開門, Kaimon), located in the brain. This gate removes the restraints of the brain on the muscles so 100% of their strength can be used whereas normally, a person can only use 20% of their muscles' strength to keep them from disintegrating. Unlocking this gate allows the user to use the Front Lotus.
taijutsu : draw

databook --> kakashi : 4.5 itachi : 4.5

they're about equal ,personally i prefer kakashi's style sicne he passed all his life to fight with gai to perform his taijutsu.

speed : itachi

databook --> kakashi : 4.5 itachi : 5

itachi is faster than kakashi according to the last databoo ,i believe that the actual kakashi is about at itachi's speed,that's not in databook which stop at chapter 409 but manga stated that nagato and tobi rekognized his good speed and he was able to save naruto from tobi in the last second before that tobi kill naruto.


Intelligence:
draw


databook --> kakashi : 5 itachi : 5


they are both geniuses, suspecting if either one was smarter would be completely ignorant and incompetent. Itachi didn't plan anything, and he failed anyway's. Kakashi's just really smart, and has good intellect. And Itachi is basically just a boy Genius who can throw Kunai good. Itachi is a smart ass, and is loyal, Kakashi came up with a technique of his own at the age of 13 that is just as bit as good as Rasengan.


finally kakashi will win that fight but itachi will put a good fight.kakashi is just better than him without sharingan and he didn't stop to increase his skill contrary to itachi who died.
 
Last edited:

Pein67

Active member
Regular
Joined
Sep 17, 2011
Messages
1,355
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
first things that need to says is that databook stoped at chapter 409
so about 160 chapter ago !

while itachi died ,kakashi did great progress that have not been include in databook.

according to the manga and old databook that stoped at chapter 409 :

genjutsu : itachi

databook --> kakashi : 4 itachi : 5

kakashi and itachi can use genjutsu without sharingan but at lower level than sharingan genjutsus,since kakashi shown only 1 i'll put itachi above kakashi because of his 2 finger midle level genjutsus Dusk Crow Genjutsu and Ephemeral .

ninjutsu : : kakashi

databook --> kakashi : 5 itachi : 5

affinities can't be copied so they both still have all their elements,
itachi can use katon and suiton ,has a good fireball jutsu and can use housenka as well and a good fast suiton attack,
kakashi can use suiton,raiton and doton so more jutsu than itachi and got advantages to counter any itachi's attack.

people keep saying he only has chidori and forgot that he also got kage bunshin,Summoning Tracking Fang,raiton kage bunshin,raiju hashiri and raikiri and some suiton and doton impressing jutsu like suiji heki and doton shinju zanshu etc...

chakra : kakashi

databook --> kakashi : 3 itachi : 2.5

thread says no sharingan, kakashi will a better endurance than itachi who has 2.5 .

strengh : kakashi

databook --> kakashi : 3.5 itachi : 3.5

they're equal but the fact that kakashi can use gate is largely enough to put him above itachi,it's clearly stated only for the 1st gate



taijutsu : draw

databook --> kakashi : 4.5 itachi : 4.5

they're about equal ,personally i prefer kakashi's style sicne he passed all his life to fight with gai to perform his taijutsu.

speed : itachi

databook --> kakashi : 4.5 itachi : 5

itachi is faster than kakashi according to the last databoo ,i believe that the actual kakashi is about at itachi's speed,that's not in databook which stop at chapter 409 but manga stated that nagato and tobi rekognized his good speed and he was able to save naruto from tobi in the last second before that tobi kill naruto.


Intelligence:
draw


databook --> kakashi : 5 itachi : 5


they are both geniuses, suspecting if either one was smarter would be completely ignorant and incompetent. Itachi didn't plan anything, and he failed anyway's. Kakashi's just really smart, and has good intellect. And Itachi is basically just a boy Genius who can throw Kunai good. Itachi is a smart ass, and is loyal, Kakashi came up with a technique of his own at the age of 13 that is just as bit as good as Rasengan.


finally kakashi will win that fight but itachi will put a good fight.kakashi is just better than him without sharingan and he didn't stop to increase his skill contrary to itachi who died.
nice post rep +
 

TheSleepyAkatsuki

Active member
Regular
Joined
Dec 6, 2011
Messages
733
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Without the Sharringan, Itachi is limited to basic genjutsu and fire release.
Kakashi has Water, Earth and lightning.

Kakashi wins the nin/Gen jutsu round.

Now for tai. Itachi is so use to using his eyes, I doubt his Tai will be a match for Kakashi, who spars with.... DAMNIC ENTRY! /Gets kicked in the head and sent flying, as the mighty Gai sits at my laptop/

Kakashi is worse then me, but better then any Akatsuki scum ;D By the way, do you think kishi is gonna make me get fat?
 

TheSleepyAkatsuki

Active member
Regular
Joined
Dec 6, 2011
Messages
733
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Not really. Kakashi could still use it, the speed would just be too much for his normal eyes. Also, we don't see him whip out the Sharringan every time he uses it, so maybe his normal eye is adapted to it.
 

Mygenjutsu

Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2011
Messages
156
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
first things that need to says is that databook stoped at chapter 409
so about 160 chapter ago !

while itachi died ,kakashi did great progress that have not been include in databook.

according to the manga and old databook that stoped at chapter 409 :

genjutsu : itachi

databook --> kakashi : 4 itachi : 5

kakashi and itachi can use genjutsu without sharingan but at lower level than sharingan genjutsus,since kakashi shown only 1 i'll put itachi above kakashi because of his 2 finger midle level genjutsus Dusk Crow Genjutsu and Ephemeral .

ninjutsu : : kakashi

databook --> kakashi : 5 itachi : 5

affinities can't be copied so they both still have all their elements,
itachi can use katon and suiton ,has a good fireball jutsu and can use housenka as well and a good fast suiton attack,
kakashi can use suiton,raiton and doton so more jutsu than itachi and got advantages to counter any itachi's attack.

people keep saying he only has chidori and forgot that he also got kage bunshin,Summoning Tracking Fang,raiton kage bunshin,raiju hashiri and raikiri and some suiton and doton impressing jutsu like suiji heki and doton shinju zanshu etc...

chakra : kakashi

databook --> kakashi : 3 itachi : 2.5

thread says no sharingan, kakashi will a better endurance than itachi who has 2.5 .

strengh : kakashi

databook --> kakashi : 3.5 itachi : 3.5

they're equal but the fact that kakashi can use gate is largely enough to put him above itachi,it's clearly stated only for the 1st gate



taijutsu : draw

databook --> kakashi : 4.5 itachi : 4.5

they're about equal ,personally i prefer kakashi's style sicne he passed all his life to fight with gai to perform his taijutsu.

speed : itachi

databook --> kakashi : 4.5 itachi : 5

itachi is faster than kakashi according to the last databoo ,i believe that the actual kakashi is about at itachi's speed,that's not in databook which stop at chapter 409 but manga stated that nagato and tobi rekognized his good speed and he was able to save naruto from tobi in the last second before that tobi kill naruto.


Intelligence:
draw


databook --> kakashi : 5 itachi : 5


they are both geniuses, suspecting if either one was smarter would be completely ignorant and incompetent. Itachi didn't plan anything, and he failed anyway's. Kakashi's just really smart, and has good intellect. And Itachi is basically just a boy Genius who can throw Kunai good. Itachi is a smart ass, and is loyal, Kakashi came up with a technique of his own at the age of 13 that is just as bit as good as Rasengan.


finally kakashi will win that fight but itachi will put a good fight.kakashi is just better than him without sharingan and he didn't stop to increase his skill contrary to itachi who died.
nice one but this wil lead to a draw
now ur saying their loyal and nice and etc but
+ we didn see itachi's real speed i mean he wasnt even trying in the last fight and he whiped multiple times the floor with thim..
give me the exact point where he will defeat itachi in.......

overall in the databook itachi has more points
and why do you give strength to kakashi?
its bot 3.5

so basicly you fell in some parts in your fanboism but i dont blame you for that cause i also do ^^.
 
Last edited:

Kyuubikiller

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jun 13, 2011
Messages
1,060
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Kakashi wins. Even without the Sharingan, Kakashi has Earth, Water and lightning jutsu, so even without his 1000 jutsu, he will still have a shit ton. Kakashi has summons, gifting him with advanced scent and hearing senses that can come in handy in battle.

Itachi without sharingan has some genjutsu i'm sure, but how do we know his sharingan wasn't the reason he was so proficient at using his regular genjutsu?? And people are saying his regular genjutsu would win the battle as if it manipulates time like tsukiyomi does, it really doesn't lol I see him being ok in genjutsu skill w/o sharingan because we all know that's the reason why he's so good at it, you can't deny his lineage. Sharingan lets you recognize a technique, so sharingan helped him master his genjutsu a lot faster, he doesn't have it in this fight, so he would probably be just a skilled genjutsu user, which Kakashi is too without the sharingan as well.

Itachi has water and fire jutsu, and I would put his speed slightly above kakashi, but he is not levels above him in speed. Itachi was known for his fast reflexes in waiving hand signs, which would pose a problem because kakashi wouldn't know how to counter. Stamina wise they are about equal, but w/o sharingan I would put kakashi above Itachi. his sharingan put a lot of strain on his body, partly due to the fact he was not an Uchiha, so without it I imagine he would have average chakra levels, Itachi too.

I don't see Itachi winning with genjutsu, Kakashi is smart, they are both geniuses, so it's not like they will really outsmart each other. I just see Kakashi as more of the rounded fighter w/o sharingan, he worked hard for a lot w/o the use of it, so I'm giving it to Kakashi.
 
Top