[Theory] Itachi is stronger than Nagato

[Uzumaki Sasuke]

1. Umm okay Nagato had the ability use any technique he wished. Nagato was shown to be adept at the use of genjutsu. He used it to install mental barriers and traps in his minions' minds to prevent others from accessing secret information. not sure how you can say that Nagato Weakness is genjustu but okay I guess you think just cause he was effected by Toad Confrontation Singing used by Fukasaku and Shima thats a weakness.. thats almost like saying because Sasuke got out of Itachi Genjustu that makes Itachi shitty at casting Genjustu.. again wrong.

2. Amateratsu umm okay so Itachi can burn someone hands yay.. your point? Nagato can bring people back from the dead.. okay so umm they both have diffrent abilities.

3. Nagato also has a similar ability if he wanted to use it.. lol Demonic Statue of the Outer Path o snap.. the ability removes the souls of any person it comes in contact with.

4. Okay.. so how long can he use this ability really? and for argument sake if they are both zombies why would it matter?

5. Okay I might have to look and see where Itachi said he was saving energy.. for a future fight but anyways seriously Nagato was still under Obito control.. not exactly an argument here besides the fact that it still took 3 ninja to stop Nagato attack sorry but there is no proof that Itachi could stop it himself just saying.

6. Itachi is smart duh but kinda funny how he overlooked that fact all the time he spent preparing for Sasuke battle that Madara still was able to influence Sasuke.. and he kinda failed in not knowing that Madara was able to extinguish Amateratsu.

It took the combined efforts of Naruto, B and Itachi to defeat Nagato.. Again this argument over this fight is not fair by any means of judging who is better than the other simple as that. It has been stated by many Even Mandara that Nagato is practically invincible just saying.

1. If Nagato cud use any jutsu he wishes Naruto, Bee n Itachi wudda been dead by now so stop saying nonsense. How do u know it was Nagato who put up d Barriers. It cud be Sasori, Itachi or other Akatsuki members. Use ur brain it is said in d manga dat Itachi's Tsukuyomi can only be countered by his own flesh n Blood. U don't know dat d Rinnegan is immune 2 visual genjutsu. Itachi has FINGER GENJUTSU. So d rinnegan is also immune 2 finger genjutsu. If so then u're a naive Nagato fan.
2. Amateratsu burnt Nagato b4 he cud do anything. Itachi cud redirect d Amateratsu 2 his face, legs or even stomach. U didn't state any point 2 backup this fact.
3. Totsuka Blade is faster than dat other seal whatever u call it so it's pointless. Cud Nagato use dat technique of his 2 seal Itachi as quickly as Itachi seaaled him? NO!
4. D Yata Mirror Deflects ALL things. It wasn't said it cud deflect SOME things. GET IT INTO YOUR SKULL!!! If Nagato cud use Shinra Tensei 2 clear Susano'o why did he bother using Chikudan Tensei? A jutsu dat carries more chakra n time 2 perform.
5.Itachi cud but chose NOT TO. U cud see dat after d fight Itachi said he was goung 2 seal d Edo Tenseis. Kabuto is smarter than Nagato. Did u see how he planned his mode of capturing Naruto n Bee. Nagato cudn't have done a better job if he was in dat situation.
6. Cud Nagato have thought as far as Itachi did. He is smarter than Nagato. If u don't agree 2 dat then I wud hav 2 say dat u are d most biased fan in Naruto base.
After all these FACTS I want 2 say d reasons u gave 2 try n counter my previous facts were useless, irrelevant n lame. VERY LAME otherwise I wud not have been able 2 counter them so easily

 

[Shivamcoder3013]

Nagato would easily win depending if one situation is present: Nagato's six paths did not get destroyed by Naruto. In that case genjutsu wouldnt work, fire style would be evaded and susanoo would have been captive by chibaku tensai. For those who think that susanoo could spam attacks at chibaku and break out, its practically impossible. The only reason Naruto broke out of it was because nine-tails went on a rampage and broke through. Susanoo doesnt even come close to the power of nine tails. If his six paths are destroyed, he would still win but it would be a bit harder.

 

[ablepema]

someone was talking about the tailed beast just sayin
when you're a jinchuriki and transform into your tailed beast,the tailed beast gains some intellegence
so the beast was thinking it didn't have animal instinct alone
besides the nine tails seems to be highly intellegent.
it's when they don't have a host they'll probably attack everything in sight
so the 9tails most likely was after pain all along

 

[arv993]

someone was talking about the tailed beast just sayin
when you're a jinchuriki and transform into your tailed beast,the tailed beast gains some intellegence
so the beast was thinking it didn't have animal instinct alone
besides the nine tails seems to be highly intellegent.
it's when they don't have a host they'll probably attack everything in sight
so the 9tails most likely was after pain all along

they have almost little to no intelligence but attack everything in their sight.

 

[ablepema]

1. If Nagato cud use any jutsu he wishes Naruto, Bee n Itachi wudda been dead by now so stop saying nonsense. How do u know it was Nagato who put up d Barriers. It cud be Sasori, Itachi or other Akatsuki members. Use ur brain it is said in d manga dat Itachi's Tsukuyomi can only be countered by his own flesh n Blood. U don't know dat d Rinnegan is immune 2 visual genjutsu. Itachi has FINGER GENJUTSU. So d rinnegan is also immune 2 finger genjutsu. If so then u're a naive Nagato fan.
2. Amateratsu burnt Nagato b4 he cud do anything. Itachi cud redirect d Amateratsu 2 his face, legs or even stomach. U didn't state any point 2 backup this fact.
3. Totsuka Blade is faster than dat other seal whatever u call it so it's pointless. Cud Nagato use dat technique of his 2 seal Itachi as quickly as Itachi seaaled him? NO!
4. D Yata Mirror Deflects ALL things. It wasn't said it cud deflect SOME things. GET IT INTO YOUR SKULL!!! If Nagato cud use Shinra Tensei 2 clear Susano'o why did he bother using Chikudan Tensei? A jutsu dat carries more chakra n time 2 perform.
5.Itachi cud but chose NOT TO. U cud see dat after d fight Itachi said he was goung 2 seal d Edo Tenseis. Kabuto is smarter than Nagato. Did u see how he planned his mode of capturing Naruto n Bee. Nagato cudn't have done a better job if he was in dat situation.
6. Cud Nagato have thought as far as Itachi did. He is smarter than Nagato. If u don't agree 2 dat then I wud hav 2 say dat u are d most biased fan in Naruto base.
After all these FACTS I want 2 say d reasons u gave 2 try n counter my previous facts were useless, irrelevant n lame. VERY LAME otherwise I wud not have been able 2 counter them so easily

you should'nt be calling people naive when it was proven that shinra can affect it because of gravitation and you can absorb it, also the shield no use agaist chikabi tensa too, i just can't give you links

 

[Kira was Righteous]

dude u r right about most of the stuff said here and the reasons u mentioned are reasons why itachi has the better shot at winning than nagato. But we don't kno how strong yasaka is so don't speculate on it that much, it might work or it might not since we do not kno the extent of its powers. Obviously these fanboys are gonna come with a bs reason like mobility is gone so he is not 100% or nagato had an internal struggles with kabuto when itachi sealed him.

Let me get this right your version of Bullshet is saying facts ah now i understand why you think itachi could win and uzumaki sasuke you have been answered so many times but you seem to not understand so you post it over and over again.
This thread never should have started 1 person should have answered No hes not and left the forum but obviously that didnt happen.The general feeling is that Nagato is stronger but itachi is smarter,if itachi is so smart how comes sasuke is with madara now?

 

[ablepema]

they have almost little to no intelligence but attack everything in their sight.

but when they havea host let's say bee they know the enemy

 

[Uzumaki Sasuke]

you should'nt be calling people naive when it was proven that shinra can affect it because of gravitation and you can absorb it, also the shield no use agaist chikabi tensa too, i just can't give you links

I called him naive based on what he said in No.1.
I never said Yata Mirror cud help in Chibaku Tensei.
Itachi wud defeat Nagato with Finger Tsukuyomi ONLY.
3 Yasaka's Magatamas are okay 4 Chibaku Tensei.
It's not possible 2 absorb a sword dat seals ur soul or else both of u seal n absorb each other n u doth die while Itachi remains alive.

 

[arv993]

Let me get this right your version of Bullshet is saying facts ah now i understand why you think itachi could win and uzumaki sasuke you have been answered so many times but you seem to not understand so you post it over and over again.
This thread never should have started 1 person should have answered No hes not and left the forum but obviously that didnt happen.The general feeling is that Nagato is stronger but itachi is smarter,if itachi is so smart how comes sasuke is with madara now?

what facts are u talking about i am not referring to u idk why ur responding to my post. And ur accusing me of saying bs when ur the kid who believes that polls suggest how strong a character is. sasuke with madara is something that itachi had in mind that is why he made amaterasu to kill madara and if that didn't work he even put the crow with Koto amakatsui so that sasuke returns to being good, how the hell is he supposed to predict that kabuto was gonna use edo tensei in which itachi would be summoned. His plan was almost perfect but kabuto screwed it up, no one really could have taken that into account. stop trying to bring the guy down and not make him look smart.

 

[arv993]

but when they havea host let's say bee they know the enemy

bee is a complete jinchurki they don't have to fight for over control like naruto and kyubi did. When naruto was in that six tails mode he was just overcome by hate and just attacked almost anything and everything in his sight, that form shows no signs of intelligence.

 

[PositiveEmotions]

here we go again

 

[arv993]

here we go again

sorry about this man

 

[ali92]

iam really an itachi fan but ithink nagato is stronger than him and dont forget that nagato cant move probably

 

[ackeem1992]

lol you guys are funny

 

[laxus]

bee is a complete jinchurki they don't have to fight for over control like naruto and kyubi did. When naruto was in that six tails mode he was just overcome by hate and just attacked almost anything and everything in his sight, that form shows no signs of intelligence.

you relize that he went after naruto's pain which was nagato which was the 9 tails goal to destroy him he wasn't attack everything in sight wacth planetary devastation.

 

[arv993]

you relize that he went after naruto's pain which was nagato which was the 9 tails goal to destroy him he wasn't attack everything in sight wacth planetary devastation.

yea he was trying to attack pain, but he was destroying everything in its path and just shooting tailed beast bombs everywhere. that is called a rampage, he had no control, i never said he was watching the chibaku tensei but all i am saying is that what naruto was ehn he was in that mode is not something who you call intelligent(even some saying above average shinobi intelligence) or chakra saving killing machine as others described it to be.

 

[Swizzik]

I know you're a Nagato fan n all but u hv 2 give credit where credit is due. Nagato is not as smart as Itachi n Nagato didn't know dat d Totsuka Blade was comin frm d smoke due 2 d collision. Nagato wud never had thought of that. In battle with little time left he was able 2 bring up an accurate, effective n quick plan that saved their lives all.

Nagato wasnt thinking when he fought Itachi B and naruto he was being completely controlled

 

[itachi86]

im a big itachi fan but nagato was being controlled while itachi had his free will, so i dont think you can say itachi is stronger based off of that battle

 

[Rockspeed23]

ITACHI IS THE STRONGEST ONE IN THE MANGA!!!!!!!!!!!! is that what you fan boys wanted to hear.

 

[laxus]

im saying that the nine tails knew the victim and that wasn't distracted, all of it intent's were killing, if it really did shoot everywhere it would have shot down sakura and the other long ago it had some sense because it has a jinchurikki host and notice the blast were all in pains terrortory so he was force to dodge, take the hit,and use his ability.
it will only attack when someone gets in it's way if you look at the 4 tail incident.