- Joined
- Nov 15, 2011
- Messages
- 18,518
- Reaction score
- 1,067
they wanted to go down in histroy as revolutionaries fighting a corrupt power hungry government. itachi stole that right from them by refusing to just tell everyone this.He didnt chose not to resolve things with his clan, it was past that point. His clan were in the end stages of planning their coup de tat and Konoha was getting ready to come down on them. He knew that he couldnt convince his claim to stop because they were too prideful, exemplified by the speech he gives the Uchiha that accuse him of killing Shishui, and he knew if they went ahead with the coup they would all die and many innocents would have been killed in the process. So he chose to safe the pride of his family and his little brother. Less they go down in history as corrupt power hungry traitors.
innocents died regardless since itachi committed genocide. how is killing EVERY uchiha stopping the coup? killing only half or so would do the trick nicely.
he had no right to decide their fate for them and decide how they want to be remembered
that is a poor excuse. he condemned sauske to UTTER ****ING MISERY AND PAIN FOR THE REST OF HIS LIFE for that? to be proud of being the only one left of his clan? who are fukin dead and never coming back? no one wants to be in that position. to be utterly alone.He let Sasuke live in hatred for 2 reasons:
A) He wanted Sasuke to be prideful of being an Uchiha, i
even after knowing everything sauske still loved his family. because theyre his fukin family!
again theyre his family and he deserves to know everything. they would have told him themselves if sasuke was a little older. and hell he might have actually agreed and vowed to support those revolutionary beliefs. then whats itachi gonna do. oh right brainwash and enslave sasuke and forcibly make sasuke do what he wants and not what sasuke wants. this is selfish and insane. he cant handle the fact that things dont always go his way and that maybe the leaf isnt that nice of a place.if he hadnt left then Sasuke would have known what his family were plotting against the leaf and would have been shamed
sasuke can be strong without hatred. did hashirama need hatred to become as strong as he became? did minato? did shisui? did third raikage? all these legendary ninjas and not one of them needed to be tortured, humiliated and beat the fuk down to become powerful.He needed Sasuke be strong as many people would have attempted to kidnap or kill him just to get his Sharingan, Orochimaru is a prime example.
also sasuke can take care of himself. he had hiruzen there. adnd as it turns out, orochimarus plan to take sasuke only failed because SASUKE WAS TRAINING WITH KAKASHI and beat gaara down. to be calm and methodical and skilled. not a blood hungry hatred filled maniac.
false. he had a thousand options. and guess what? he fukin picked wrong.Admittedly Itachi questions whether the choices he made were really the correct ones, but all in all he had no options and no time.
its easy to actually. itachi chose consciously to brutally torture and mindrape an innocent screaming young boy. thats what he chose to fukin doIts hard to question the judgement of a person under that kind of pressure.
ok. so therefore itachi killed orochimaru, kabuto, obito and kisame. too evil, save lives kinda thing? he wasnt gonna be trusted by obito anyway so his role as a spy was useless. might as well take down as many as he can.There was no saving them they were to evil. So he got rid of them and saved a lot of lives
wait...wait...
oh thats right.
itachi is selfish and got thousands of people killed because he was too much of an idiot and a coward to kill evil villains and threats to his home.
he can kill sleeping uchihas. but mass murdering mad scientists? nah they are off limits
like how itachi did nothing about orochimaru and akatsuki for 10 years, watching as they only got stronger and stronger, and his brother more and more evil.a real coward is someone who would have done nothing.
like how meyer stated bella swan is an ordinary young woman and lucas said anakin is a hero who fell? we shouldnt have to accept garbage fed to us by bad writersHe was, undoubtedly a hero. Stated by kishimoto.
possibly. or possibly someone else could just take out the ringleaders and make a deal with the uchiha survivors to surrender. you know...like a sensible ruler of a city would do.Doesn't change the fact he saved their lives. Whether they know it or not, he is a hero to them.
also save them from what? the war happened anyway. mostly because itachi did nothing about orochimaru till it was too late. hiruzens blood is on itachis hands.
ok. so what about all the other villains that itachi did not take down? orochimaru, zabuza, danzo, sasuke etc. was he saving lives by letting them run rampant and massacre innocents?The uchiha's would have been wiped out with thousands of other people...
He chose quantity over quality
itachi is a coward. he is only able and willing to kill sleeping defenceless men and women. and even then betrays their memory by painting a false ideal of what they were like instead of the brave revolutionaries they actually were.
he stood by and watched as danzos corruption destroyed konoha.