Itachi, hero?

[VongolaX]

I was referring to the fact you said "Mangas" instead of chapters XD

Yep, itachi appears to be that powerful that he happens to be in every manga out there.

 

[EliteRamenNinja]

A hero doesn't have to do all goodXD

Yes, he does. That's what a hero is.

 

[King Of Crows]

What did the children do? Making War Propaganda?

And the Elders? Making War Tools?

*sigh*

I don't care if he kills babies as long as Ichiraku ramen survives .... And that wouldn't have been possible were there a coup

 

[MadaIzuBros1224]

Yes, he does. That's what a hero is.

Well, what if you have to do bad to stop something even worse?

 

[EliteRamenNinja]

Well, what if you have to do bad to stop something even worse?

What kind of bad? Hitting a police men, stealing a car or killing innocent people?

 

[King Of Crows]

What kind of bad? Hitting a police men, stealing a car or killing innocent people?

Would you kill if you meant you could saved way more lives by doing so ;O ?

 

[EliteRamenNinja]

Would you kill if you meant you could saved way more lives by doing so ;O ?

Yes.

And I am no hero.

 

[King Of Crows]

Yes.

And I am no hero.

Hero is interpreted differently it has no definitive definition.
A hero can be seen as someone who would do anything if it were for the greater good, like what Itachi did in this case. A hero can be also be seen as someone who does not shed blood needlessly and yet saves the day

 

[MadaIzuBros1224]

What kind of bad? Hitting a police men, stealing a car or killing innocent people?

It's wrong to kill innocent people, but if there is no other choice but to do it, it must be done. He had to kill a clan to save a village. There was no way to save both. The negotiations had failed and the Uchiha were going to rebel. Even the kids and elderly had to be killed because they could be possible threats.

 

[EliteRamenNinja]

Hero is interpreted differently it has no definitive definition.
A hero can be seen as someone who would do anything if it were for the greater good, like what Itachi did in this case. A hero can be also be seen as someone who does not shed blood needlessly and yet saves the day

He... killed... innocent... people...... You..... can't.......be.......called.......a.......hero......then!

It's wrong to kill innocent people, but if there is no other choice but to do it, it must be done. He had to kill a clan to save a village. There was no way to save both. The negotiations had failed and the Uchiha were going to rebel. Even the kids and elderly had to be killed because they could be possible threats.

A hero would have known a way. It's actually very simple.

 

[Dark Artist]

Finally someone with logic and common sense

if you call a psychopath who killed his own mother and father and many innocent children and old women ( like a coward ) a hero

then you're mental ****ed up or a dickrider

it's between these 2

it's the first time i hear someone became a hero for killing his own mother and father

 

[King Of Crows]

He... killed... innocent... people...... You..... can't.......be.......called.......a.......hero......then!

You can if it meant saving WAY more innocent people

 

[Jako98146]

Hmm, strange I feel like I've seen this before...
Oh no, I must be in izanami!

 

[EliteRamenNinja]

it's the first time i hear someone became a hero for killing his own mother and father

=D Funny because it is true!

Hmm, strange I feel like I've seen this before...
Oh no, I must be in izanami!

Izanami, don't start with that bullshit jutsu.

 

[MadaIzuBros1224]

He... killed... innocent... people...... You..... can't.......be.......called.......a.......hero......then!





A hero would have known a way. It's actually very simple.

You can't always find a way to save both. Itachi had to make the terrible decision.

 

[EliteRamenNinja]

You can't always find a way to save both. Itachi had to make the terrible decision.

Ok, wich makes from him a perfect soldier. NOT a hero. You agree?

 

[MadaIzuBros1224]

Ok, wich makes from him a perfect soldier. NOT a hero. You agree?

What are you getting by that?

 

[King Of Crows]

Ok, wich makes from him a perfect soldier. NOT a hero. You agree?

Why are you being so stubborn on this ? Kishimoto has called Itachi a hero through characters, you are not going to win this argument because you cannot disagree with what the author depicts his characters as

 

[EliteRamenNinja]

What are you getting by that?

The fact that there is a big difference between both. A perfect soldier is not the same as a hero.

Why are you being so stubborn on this ? Kishimoto has called Itachi a hero through characters, you are not going to win this argument because you cannot disagree with what the author depicts his characters as

This is a discussion forum and I discuss this. I do not agree with Kishi on this!


Anyway, I am out, ready to sleep. I will comment further tomorrow.

 

[King Of Crows]

This is a discussion forum and I discuss this. I do not agree with Kishi on this!


Anyway, I am out, ready to sleep. I will comment further tomorrow.

It doesn't matter if you do not agree ! It's his manga !!! Your opinion on what he does with his own manga is less than nothing !
If kishimoto states that his character is a hero through his unavoidable actions then there's nothing you can do to change that, fact.