Is Sasuke a criminal?

Is Sasuke a criminal?

  • Yes

    Votes: 64 66.0%
  • No

    Votes: 33 34.0%

  • Total voters
    97

FoolzBeWeary

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jul 3, 2014
Messages
1,460
Reaction score
73
Yes he's a criminal but what he's done isn't so bad that he absolutely should be punished.The Akatsuki would of went after Bee regardless of if he "joined" or not and if he hadn't Joined then they most likely would have gotten Bee completely and the War would of started inorder to get just Naruto,and with Tobi getting the Jar that had Kinkaku and Ginkaku's Kyuubi chakra then the incomplete Juubi would have been summoned,resulting an even more deaths.

But your speaking on what ifs. It still doesn't change the fact that he made them more capable to start the war. He should absolutely be punished. For the people that died from the incomplete juubi. Doesn't matter your trying to downplay his crimes. His actions are of a criminal.
 

CookieMan9000

Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2014
Messages
218
Reaction score
13
But your speaking on what ifs. It still doesn't change the fact that he made them more capable to start the war. He should absolutely be punished. For the people that died from the incomplete juubi. Doesn't matter your trying to downplay his crimes. His actions are of a criminal.

How exactly will he be punished anyway? After the war will be over, Sasuke and Naruto will be practically the strongest people alive at that point. And Naruto sure as hell won't try to fight Sasuke to punish him for his previous crimes.
 

FoolzBeWeary

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jul 3, 2014
Messages
1,460
Reaction score
73
How exactly will he be punished anyway? After the war will be over, Sasuke and Naruto will be practically the strongest people alive at that point. And Naruto sure as hell won't try to fight Sasuke to punish him for his previous crimes.

Naruto will do what he thinks is right. But this thread is Sasuke a criminal and the answer is yes cold hard fact that he is. Naruto said the obito should came back to the village and face his punishment. Meaning me believe those who do wrong must face their punishment.
 

Naruto X Hunter

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 13, 2014
Messages
10,191
Reaction score
1,248
He's a criminal. He invaded another village, attacked their jinchuuriki, attempted kidnapping, joined a band of terrorists, and attacked the nv world equivalent un. He should be dead by now.

Yes he should be dead,cause the SA should of stopped focusing on the Juubi,Obito,and Madara,and attack Sasuke who was on their side

But your speaking on what ifs. It still doesn't change the fact that he made them more capable to start the war. He should absolutely be punished. For the people that died from the incomplete juubi. Doesn't matter your trying to downplay his crimes. His actions are of a criminal.

He should absolutely be punished? By who? Shinobi Nations who have used the Akatsuki themselves? Shinobi Nations who hire Shinobi to assasinate people? Shinobi Nations who use Shinobi to kill people?

Yeah,it sounds like they have the right to punish Sasuke
 
Last edited:

Dannie

/
Immortal
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
47,160
Reaction score
2,798
Before he became a member of Akatsuki, pre Shippuden, Hebi Sasuke, he wasn't. So he left the village at 16. Big deal. It's not like he was doing anything wrong or harming anyone. He just wanted to get stronger so he decided to leave a nursery and enter the warzone. They are ninja's. It is one of their responsibilities to get stronger. If he never left then he would have never been able to fight Itachi.

He did the world a favor with absorbing Orochimaru. Even if he did join him, it's not like he participated in his experiments. In fact, that was the very reason why he absorbed him.

When Sasuke fought Deidara, he did the world a favor with Deidara's suicidal attempt. Deidara is a known terrorist that nukes unknown territories with his explosives. If Deidara never died, then he would have still been bombing unwarranted residents.

Sasuke's "crimes", as people like to call it only started when he tried to capture Bee. Did he try to capture Bee? Yes. Did he actually succeed? No. So what exactly is the problem again? I see very faulty logic in blaming Sasuke for trying to kidnap Bee when in fact the Cloud has tried to do this same notion with Lady Hinata in the past, but the Leaf let it go and said forget it. Why aren't the Cloud considered criminals? Is it just because it's Sasuke? The Cloud only got angry because their leader is an uncontrollable hot head who cant control his temper. As soon as he heard the news of Sasuke kidnapping Bee, he called for a conference with the other Kage. Bee is still alive. Bee is not dead. He is still alive and breathing. Better alive than dead.

When it comes to the samurai, Sasuke was at fault here, but Sasuke explicitly warned them not to interfere. Samurai have no place to be fighting with ninja's in the first place, so if they want to risk their lives fighting a fight that they can't win then that's their own problem. Did Sasuke intrude into the conference? Yes. Did Sasuke walk into unwanted territory? Yes. Was Sasuke trying to kill those Samurai? No. Sasuke was only after Danzo, but everyone else decided to butt into something that didn't concern them.

And then we move to Danzo. Some people think that Sasuke's actions towards Danzo are trifling and menacing, but who in this ninja world actually cared for him, besides Sai and his other fodder followers? Even the other Kages and his own Leaf peers didn't trust him. Danzo did some heinous crimes in the past and Danzo's death should be a light to the world.

Sasuke also announced that he was going to destroy the Leaf, but did he do it? No. Sasuke announced that he was going to kill everyone in the Leaf who smile on his misery, but did he do it? No.

There are many things that Sasuke said that he was going to do or try to do, but he never actually did them because of changed events. If I lived my whole life searching and trying to get stronger, just to kill a certain guy that caused my dispair, but then I turn around and find out that he was actually a good person and just cared for the village and me, do you honestly expect me to go back to the very same hometown that plotted my brothers demise? The Leaf village and the elders are selfish and Sasuke knows this, and that's why he wants to change it.

If Sasuke does get punished for his crimes then his only crime would be killing those fodder samurai, but when you look at the concept of them being ninja's and fighting everyday of their lives, killing some insignificant warriors shouldn't be much of a concern, considering that past warriors between neighboring nations would involve the killing of many people. If you want to call Sasuke a criminal for killing some Samurai; then you should also call those ninja's that have been fighting in previous wars killing other nina's criminals as well.

Sasuke was not always like this and after his talk with Hashirama he decided to protect what his brother wants to protect. You are basically calling him a criminal and harping on events that have happened long before he changed his ways of saving the world. I guess saving the world from the biggest threat to ever exist in NV completely pales to killing some stupid fodder samurai who were destined to die anyway. Gaara also killed many innocent people. Is he a criminal? Of course not, because he's not Sasuke.
 
Last edited:

CookieMan9000

Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2014
Messages
218
Reaction score
13
Naruto will do what he thinks is right. But this thread is Sasuke a criminal and the answer is yes cold hard fact that he is. Naruto said the obito should came back to the village and face his punishment. Meaning me believe those who do wrong must face their punishment.

Well I agree Sasuke is a criminal.
But I was wondering what will happen. I mean Sasuke isn't just going to stand there and be punished. And after all of the trouble they went through to get Sasuke on the good side again, I doubt Naruto will risk everyone's safety just to get justice.
 

BenjerminGaye

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Nov 1, 2012
Messages
19,423
Reaction score
823
Yes he should be dead,cause the SA should of stopped focusing on the Juubi,Obito,and Madara,and attack Sasuke who was on their side

War time compromise. Oro is pure evil but they didn't hunt him either.

To me your saying if Sadam cured cancer we shouldn't hunt him for the 9/11 attacks.
 

Hebi Sasuke

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Feb 20, 2013
Messages
3,108
Reaction score
392
Shinobi world before the war definitely thought of him as a criminal...But I justify his actions...Anyone would do the same thing...But besides killing Danzo and that kage summit I don't see him doing anything so harmful ...After his actions in the war,he is more than redeemed ,even though he doesn't care about that.
 

FoolzBeWeary

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jul 3, 2014
Messages
1,460
Reaction score
73
Well I agree Sasuke is a criminal.
But I was wondering what will happen. I mean Sasuke isn't just going to stand there and be punished. And after all of the trouble they went through to get Sasuke on the good side again, I doubt Naruto will risk everyone's safety just to get justice.

That what naruto does. He did it with pain and obito. What's to say he won't do it for Sasuke. Naruto know that people won't just flat out forgive Sasuke for his crimes. The only way they will if justice is involved. Meaning he will have to pay for it one way or another. That's how the cycle of hate will stop.
 

BenjerminGaye

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Nov 1, 2012
Messages
19,423
Reaction score
823
Is Sasuke is a criminal, then Gaara is an even bigger criminal.

False. Garra's actions were under his village and pardoned by said village. Sasuke's actions were under a terrorist probation organization and yet to be pardoned.
 

FoolzBeWeary

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jul 3, 2014
Messages
1,460
Reaction score
73
Shinobi world before the war definitely thought of him as a criminal...But I justify his actions...Anyone would do the same thing...But besides killing Danzo and that kage summit I don't see him doing anything so harmful ...After his actions in the war,he is more than redeemed ,even though he doesn't care about that.

He help revive the incomplete juubi which killed like 200 people that makes him a mass murder by default bro. Even if it was one of the eight tails tail it was planty of chakra to make it happen.
 

CookieMan9000

Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2014
Messages
218
Reaction score
13
That what naruto does. He did it with pain and obito. What's to say he won't do it for Sasuke. Naruto know that people won't just flat out forgive Sasuke for his crimes. The only way they will if justice is involved. Meaning he will have to pay for it one way or another. That's how the cycle of hate will stop.

If Sasuke will get punished, it will fuel again his hate. But who knows, maybe Kishi will do a part three where Sasuke is the villain because he gets branded as a criminal. I doubt it will happen, but it might...

Obito and Pain did much worse stuff and they weren't his friends though.
 
Last edited:

Uchihajin Sasuke

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Feb 15, 2012
Messages
2,532
Reaction score
204
False. Garra's actions were under his village and pardoned by said village. Sasuke's actions were under a terrorist probation organization and yet to be pardoned.

Pardoned or not Gaara did commit those crimes.

Either way all the charges against Sasuke will be lifted and he will be hailed as a hero of the shinobi world.
 

EternalFlame

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
May 11, 2013
Messages
1,255
Reaction score
115
On paper he is still a criminal, but that's just that... it's on paper.

As for other characters opinons on him? When Sasuke first entered the war and his reunion with K11, it's been shown that they don't want to acknowledged him or they don't trust him. However, that was then... and this is now. If by the time the war is over and he's still labelled as a criminal then Sasuke's point of the system being broken as **** is cemented even more, ESPECIALLY if he literally saves the world by breaking IT something hinted at that only he can do.

My opinion on him? Even if he doesn't break IT, he's contributed enough to this war to have his international criminal past wiped, not forgotten but he won't be going to prison or anything.
 

Naruto X Hunter

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 13, 2014
Messages
10,191
Reaction score
1,248
War time compromise. Oro is pure evil but they didn't hunt him either.

To me your saying if Sadam cured cancer we shouldn't hunt him for the 9/11 attacks.


Lol dude you said he should be dead by now - the only time anyone has seen him since the summit where the Kages tried to kill him was during the War - and i simply pionted out how stupid it would be for them to try to kill him then.
Is Sasuke is a criminal, then Gaara is an even bigger criminal.

lol i completely forgot about Gaara ever being bad.
False. Garra's actions were under his village and pardoned by said village. Sasuke's actions were under a terrorist probation organization and yet to be pardoned.

Lol what about other villages? Do they get no say in this?He was a major force in the Konoha invasion,so should Konoha go after him? Sasuke hasn't harmed Konoha,he only invaded the Cloud and tried to get Bee,and got part of him which led to the juubi and a few deaths.Konoha lost alot of Shinobi and civilians from the attack which Gaara was a major part of.His involvement led to their deaths yet he's KazeKage now.
 
Last edited:

Hebi Sasuke

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Feb 20, 2013
Messages
3,108
Reaction score
392
He help revive the incomplete juubi which killed like 200 people that makes him a mass murder by default bro. Even if it was one of the eight tails tail it was planty of chakra to make it happen.

Like Obito wouldn't find another way...
 

FoolzBeWeary

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jul 3, 2014
Messages
1,460
Reaction score
73
If Sasuke will get punished, it will fuel again his hate. But who knows, maybe Kishi will do a part three where Sasuke is the new Madara. I doubt it will happen, but it might...

Obito and Pain did much worse stuff and they weren't his friends though.

Sasuke killed like 200 people because of the incomplete juubi. That's like half a village bro. Yes but his so called hokage statement won't happen if he doesn't get punished for his actions. Sasuke is doing the same thing as pain to a since. He help revive the juubi to destroy the leaf to end the pain on the clan. Wait one sec pains goal was a lot better then sasukes pain wanted peace Sasuke wanted to kill for just revenge. Obito wanted peace be it false peace. But all three killed innocent people for their idea. They are all equal murders.
 
Top