Is Kishi a genius or a terrible writer?

[narutoblitz]

Honestly it seems like the villains are either being

a) VERY poorly written
b) Have a back-up plan.

Obito's acting erratically. Madara is literally doing nothing. Juubi is getting fodderized and basically tossed around like a football. Sasuke has arbitrarily decided to become "good" due to Hashi's history lecture. Orochimaru has stopped being selfish and the main symbol of corruption and evil?

Either Kishi is a genius that's waiting with a huge plot twist... Or this series is dead.

 

[Uzumaki Menma]

If that's how you feel I guess.

 

[-immortal-]

he is just normal

You must be registered for see images

 

[Versatile jutsu]

orochimaru never was true villian

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

He is normal writer tho I suspect he's writing it along as he goes ..

 

[narutoblitz]

Madara sitting there while the Juubi gets owned really just makes no sense at all guys.

 

[FireBird Marco]

Calling him a writer is stretching it!

 

[Blaze Release]

Both.

He has good ideas, but fails to deliver.

Basically this manga had really ideas that kishi has either not touched upon or briefly touched upon.
His ideas, if he was to actually put effort into it would have been something special, but i guess it was overwhelming in the end.

Great ideas, piss poor 'writer'

 

[saw2097]

Didn't you quit, you clearly said you were dropping the manga, if you don't like Kishi's story then don't read it.

I think he is a genius.

 

[Floydical]

Madara is just sitting there because all he cares about is his own pleasure. ATM all he cares about is fighting Hashi, that trumps his overall plans atm. Yes I believe that Kishi is a genius but at the same time not the best writer. He has had plenty of bad points, but he has plenty of good points as well.

 

[Ψ Veritas Ψ]

Both.

He has good ideas, but fails to deliver.

Basically this manga had really ideas that kishi has either not touched upon or briefly touched upon.
His ideas, if he was to actually put effort into it would have been something special, but i guess it was overwhelming in the end.

Great ideas, piss poor 'writer'

he has taken most of his ideas from the japanese mythlogogies.

 

[Detective L]

He is normal writer tho I suspect he's writing it along as he goes ..

^ This guy says it.Unlike Oda,who plans years ahead

 

[Mr Hiru]

Honestly it seems like the villains are either being

a) VERY poorly written
b) Have a back-up plan.

Obito's acting erratically. Madara is literally doing nothing. Juubi is getting fodderized and basically tossed around like a football. Sasuke has arbitrarily decided to become "good" due to Hashi's history lecture. Orochimaru has stopped being selfish and the main symbol of corruption and evil?

Either Kishi is a genius that's waiting with a huge plot twist... Or this series is dead.

We can't assume Orochimaru being a villiain because we don't know his true intentions (even in part 1 he only had shown the tree but not the forest). The same thing goes for Madara.

You're right about Obito though... and about the Juubi, meh, I would wait a bit longer. Bijuus can't die after all, they only can be sealed.

 

[YellowFang]

Kishi is genius writer but sometimes fanboyism overcomes his genius plot-making abilities...

 

[Blaze Release]

he has taken most of his ideas from the japanese mythlogogies.

Yes and so have many other manga's.
However the way he implements them and some of the characters/scenario's he creates is nice.

I believe his ideas in the end overwhelmed him

 

[rollin]

He is a genius writer

 

[Thorium]

You must be registered for see links

You said you were dropping the manga. You are a liar, and thus have 0 credibility.

 

[ShadowBandit]

I'm pretty sure the OP, is a Naruhina lover or Hinatard, so I think Sakura having all these epic moments has just made him sick of the manga.

Sorry the manga didn't turn out the way you wanted with Sakura being the fodder loser u want her to be.

You must be registered for see links

You said you were dropping the manga. You are a liar, and thus have 0 credibility.

Ha ha, I remember that thread. He was whining about Sakura.

 

[Jako98146]

But oro might be evil
Sasuke turning good so quickly after hashi's talk no jutsu was bullshit
Juubi's not even in full form yet
Madara's just chillin'

 

[NarutoB]

Genius. He doesn't plan shit years ahead like Oda? Maybe not. But his foreshadowing is excellent.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

That was like like a 400 chapter gap, and that's not all. There are little hints like that all throughout the manga.