[Discussion] In terms of raw phyiscal strength Luffy is unmatched

[NarutoBmx33]

This is also why in part 1 Sanji was stronger than Enel, I mean Enel has a DF and that surely doesn't count as part of a characters power, you know I hear Kizaru is actually not Admiral tier at all

Ohh stop it youuu

 

[Love Cook]

Nope Jozu's feat was more more impressive he basically threw a mountain at the marines back a Marineford U_U.

I just explained why it isn't you can't just 'nope' science and math.

Only if that mountain is 7.5 times as big as the cannonball that Garp threw it would've been more impressive, it all has to do with the density. That is why you can't fill the bath to the rim and step in without overflowing.

And judging from the scans it might've been 2-3 times as big, but certainly not bigger than that.

Imagine what a kilo of feathers look like and what a kilo of lead looks like.

 

[NarutoBmx33]

You guys are implying scientific measurements to an anime, which includes magical fruits.

 

[Tomato God]

You guys are implying scientific measurements to an anime, which includes magical fruits.

So? Unless mathimatics is shown in manga as to be different than ours why would we acept that they change?
1 + 1 = 2 in the one piece world as well so why does't gold weight the same?

 

[NarutoBmx33]

So? Unless mathimatics is shown in manga as to be different than ours why would we acept that they change?
1 + 1 = 2 in the one piece world as well so why does't gold weight the same?

So can you answer these?

When Sanji kicks down, scientifically speaking, his body should go up in the air due to the pressure bouncing back. He's a human who's able to bend huge metal doors by kicking them. What calculations allow him to do that?

When Zoro fights with his sword in his mouth, Garp lifting huge cannonballs.
Its true that 1+1=2 still implies, but the weight and strength ratio isn't like it is in real life.

 

[Olorin]

So can you answer these?

When Sanji kicks down, scientifically speaking, his body should go up in the air due to the pressure bouncing back. He's a human who's able to bend huge metal doors by kicking them. What calculations allow him to do that?

When Zoro fights with his sword in his mouth, Garp lifting huge cannonballs.
Its true that 1+1=2 still implies, but the weight and strength ratio isn't like it is in real life.

none of what you said changes the fact that Luffy is still the physically the strongest and most endurable Strawhat

 

[NarutoBmx33]

none of what you said changes the fact that Luffy is still the physically the strongest and most endurable Strawhat

Not trying to be rude here but I wasn't talking about Luffy's strength. I was just talking about the general math interpretation in One Piece compared to real life.

 

[Olorin]

Not trying to be rude here but I wasn't talking about Luffy's strength. I was just talking about the general math interpretation in One Piece compared to real life.

yes and I posted how that is irrelevant to the final point the OP was about, which was about Luffy

 

[NarutoBmx33]

yes and I posted how that is irrelevant to the final point the OP was about, which was about Luffy

I don't care if it's irrelevant to the post, I was just putting my 2 cents in lol

 

[A v i]

Flying slash determines ones

You must be registered for see links

.


What Luffy did with his most powerful attack that we have seen. [

You must be registered for see links

]

What Zoro did with his most powerful attack that we have seen. [

You must be registered for see links

]

Do the math and remember that we don't even know if Zoros attack has haki or not.

 

[Olorin]

Flying slash determines ones

You must be registered for see links

.


What Luffy did with his most powerful attack that we have seen. [

You must be registered for see links

]

What Zoro did with his most powerful attack that we have seen. [

You must be registered for see links

]

Do the math and remember that we don't even know if Zoros attack has haki or not.

Yea that has nothing on elephant gatling

 

[Bogard]

To determine attack strength you take one hit attacks and Luffy's strongest one hit attack preskip was giant bazooka which became grizzly magnum postskip. Elephant Gatling is a repetitive move with Luffy launching continuous elephant gun during a certain period of time

 

[Tomato God]

So can you answer these?

When Sanji kicks down, scientifically speaking, his body should go up in the air due to the pressure bouncing back. He's a human who's able to bend huge metal doors by kicking them. What calculations allow him to do that?

When Zoro fights with his sword in his mouth, Garp lifting huge cannonballs.
Its true that 1+1=2 still implies, but the weight and strength ratio isn't like it is in real life.

What normally keeps people from flying backwards. Friction and Inertia. We just have to assume he is firmly on the ground. And we have to assume his bones are more durable than they normally are.

Unless OP has some different type of gold or A different amount of gravity on their planet My answer to your idiotic question remains.

 

[Tomato God]

Flying slash determines ones

You must be registered for see links

.


What Luffy did with his most powerful attack that we have seen. [

You must be registered for see links

]

What Zoro did with his most powerful attack that we have seen. [

You must be registered for see links

]

Do the math and remember that we don't even know if Zoros attack has haki or not.

How is a flying slash more impressive than moving a 700 ton ball so fast that a guy who can travel at the speed of light can't avoid it knowing the exact time and location of it?

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

All that calculation does is prove that it is foolish to try and apply real world logic to manga.

 

[Punk Hazard]

All that calculation does is prove that it is foolish to try and apply real world logic to manga.

Foolish is the mind that calls the mind doing work foolish.

I guess simple math and conversion is just too much not stupid for people to handle.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Foolish is the mind that calls the mind doing work foolish.

I guess simple math and conversion is just too much not stupid for people to handle.

Do you seriously think Oda tried to figure out how much that gold ball would weigh in the real world and then add it to One Piece?

 

[Punk Hazard]

Do you seriously think Oda tried to figure out how much that gold ball would weigh in the real world and then add it to One Piece?

No, I do not think so. And with this comment, it's clear that you do not understand how this works. Oda did not draw the ball with the idea of conveying it as 646 tons in mind. He did not do calculations and measurements with the density and weight of gold in mind to make sure the ball was 646 tons.

The way it really works is that the way Oda drew it, and with the mathematic rules and weight of gold, it coincidentally comes to 646. Oda may not have intended for it to be 646, but that's the way it is. Oda did not draw it the way he did to make sure it was 646 tons, the way he drew it just so happens to come out to 646 tons.

 

[NarutoBmx33]

No, I do not think so. And with this comment, it's clear that you do not understand how this works. Oda did not draw the ball with the idea of conveying it as 646 tons in mind. He did not do calculations and measurements with the density and weight of gold in mind to make sure the ball was 646 tons.

The way it really works is that the way Oda drew it, and with the mathematic rules and weight of gold, it coincidentally comes to 646. Oda may not have intended for it to be 646, but that's the way it is. Oda did not draw it the way he did to make sure it was 646 tons, the way he drew it just so happens to come out to 646 tons.

Coincidentially or just your opinion?
Saying that "real life calculations do not apply to the manga" doesn't mean you're lazy or foolish. It just means you're wasting your time on something the writer didn't deem important enough to be mentioned in his work.

 

[Punk Hazard]

Coincidentially or just your opinion?
Saying that "real life calculations do not apply to the manga" doesn't mean you're lazy or foolish. It just means you're wasting your time on something the writer didn't deem important enough to be mentioned in his work.

No it's lazy. And to dismiss it because "real-life calculations don't apply to manga" Is foolish.

You mean like which Strawhat is the most durable and which is the physically strongest? By your logic, the whole forum shouldn't really exist.