In kishi's defense
- Thread starter Andy Bogard
- Start date
Ah, those that go with the flow, no matter what shit is thrown at them.
To criticize, one doesn't have to do better, one must have arguments and evidences to suport an idea. One must have knowledge about the subject. A criticism is based on an analysis of what is being criticized. With the analysis, the arguments can be based on facts, on the very characteristics of the object. Then, they will be used in order to suport or disprove an idea. This is how criticism works. If something is bad, it is bad, no matter who made it, no matter who is saying it.
Now, If one dislikes something in a series or in anything, he/she has the right to criticize it. Criticism is a right, don't forget this. The only thing that can't be done is to disrespect. Criticizing doesn't mean one has to stop watching/reading what he/she is criticizing. Disliking 1 characteristic doesn't mean disliking everything of the subject. This only means that the person won't accept any sh*t thrown at him/her, and he/she will actually criticize it to show what might be even a mistake, not only a personal taste.
With this, I show that such affirmatives are a childish mistake of people who don't understand criticism, people who have 0 knowledge on criticism.
So, let's grow up and stop these stupid comments.
To criticize, one doesn't have to do better, one must have arguments and evidences to suport an idea. One must have knowledge about the subject. A criticism is based on an analysis of what is being criticized. With the analysis, the arguments can be based on facts, on the very characteristics of the object. Then, they will be used in order to suport or disprove an idea. This is how criticism works. If something is bad, it is bad, no matter who made it, no matter who is saying it.
Now, If one dislikes something in a series or in anything, he/she has the right to criticize it. Criticism is a right, don't forget this. The only thing that can't be done is to disrespect. Criticizing doesn't mean one has to stop watching/reading what he/she is criticizing. Disliking 1 characteristic doesn't mean disliking everything of the subject. This only means that the person won't accept any sh*t thrown at him/her, and he/she will actually criticize it to show what might be even a mistake, not only a personal taste.
With this, I show that such affirmatives are a childish mistake of people who don't understand criticism, people who have 0 knowledge on criticism.
So, let's grow up and stop these stupid comments.
Kaneki Kun
Active member
So to sum it all up unless were holding Kishi at gun point who cares what we have to say because regardless were going to read his manga anyway.
Yeal, we'll read it, and most likely, kishi won't care for what we wrote. That's not the point, however. Criticism is still a right, and it is still meant to be used in order to show a potential, possible flaw of someone's work. If the person will see it, change it or not, that's up to the person. But criticism doesn't mean I dislike that work. I don't need to stop reading it just because I criticized a part of it.
Criticism is okay but what would you say to the people who outright bash the manga every week because it doesn't go their way. These people should indeed stop reading the manga or at the very least quit the site dedicated to it's fans.
Faceplant911
Member
Criticising a manga in a non-you suck way is actually helpful for the author to see what to fix.
Not all that upset about you posting this. Apart of criticizing something constructively is pointing and discussing the faults of it. But there are way too many people with the mindset of if it's something they personally don't like, it's a fault in Kishi's story. Like those who are mad Sasuke got the Rinnegan. I've seen many have the "argument" of "I didn't want Sasuke to get the Rinnegan, and he got it, so it was bad writing on Kishi's part and an error that he shouldn't have made". People have used that logic for many topics.
Everyone is entitled to share their opinion in a respectful manner, but I don't know I do sometimes wish people would chill out a bit and take their personal opinion as that, their personal opinion and move on. I think that was more so what you were getting at and if so, I agree. Have a good night
Everyone is entitled to share their opinion in a respectful manner, but I don't know I do sometimes wish people would chill out a bit and take their personal opinion as that, their personal opinion and move on. I think that was more so what you were getting at and if so, I agree. Have a good night
ReverseZero12
Active member
We can criticize something we want. That's what many readers are allowed to do and have the right to do.
To bash and to criticize, those are very different things. If a person just says "this manga is crap, shit, I hate it", and they don't pull one single argument, then I agree.
Six paths of Sasuke
Banned
Goddess Tsunade
Active member
yeah, regardless of what anybody says... Kishi will make his chapters and he'll earn lots of money from it..
toviasrepier
Active member
Exactly why this manga is going down the toilet it's just all about money now. Kishi makes up as the story goes on & he makes up all these ass pull op jutsus ability etc. w/c makes this mange full of sh********t!!!!!!
Andy Bogard
Active member
This comment here sums up my response. I don't care that you have an opinion. To each is own. This is Manga; not religion, so no one is expected to criticize like this really happened lol.
