In kishi's defense

[Wolfus]

This comment here sums up my response. I don't care that you have an opinion. To each is own. This is Manga; not religion, so no one is expected to criticize like this really happened lol.

What a stupid comment. "I don't care that you habe an opinion". That is irrelevant. That doesn't change the fact that people still have their opinions, and they are still allowed to say them outloud. Of course, as I said, opinions alone are useless to a debate, but criticism itself is very important. When made by good debaters, and countered by good debaters, it becomes a good and profiting discussion.

It doesn't matter what this is. Everything, including a manga, is subject to criticism. Criticism, not desrespect(bashing).
It's about time you people learned this. It's not so hard to understand.

 

[Andy Bogard]

What a stupid comment. "I don't care that you habe an opinion". That is irrelevant. That doesn't change the fact that people still have their opinions, and they are still allowed to say them outloud. Of course, as I said, opinions alone are useless to a debate, but criticism itself is very important. When made by good debaters, and countered by good debaters, it becomes a good and profiting discussion.

It doesn't matter what this is. Everything, including a manga, is subject to criticism. Criticism, not desrespect(bashing).
It's about time you people learned this. It's not so hard to understand.

Omg you're so cute. Marry me, you beautiful Stark you

 

[cptenn94]

I love how mad and insecure people get over opinion.

I agree. People get so upset if someone thinks differently, or if someone thinks they are wrong(disagrees).

Good criticism takes into the account the good and bad of whatever is being criticized. It goes into the whole picture.
Everyone has their own opinion. And I dont mind them expressing it, as long as they back it up with their reasons and some examples.

Going "OMG kishi is the worst mangaka ever!" I do not like(as it is just bashing.) A statement like that is just a waste of my time. It leaves no room for discussion and diologue, and does not give me any insight into what that person thinks.

 

[Shadow Phantasm]

People have the right to criticize and express their opinions on the manga.Some people seem to have a intolerance for different opinions around here and all I have to say to that is:Deal with it.