[Discussion] How should Mafia Game Medals be awarded?

Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
22,725
Likes
3,089
Kin
3,163💸
Kumi
1,266💴
Thread starter #1
I have been getting a lot of messages from other members on how the mafia medals will be awarded. In this thread you can give your suggestions on how the medals should be awarded.

Discussion on suggestions posted is encouraged.

Keep in mind that there should be suggestions on both game host medals and game player medals.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Mar 15, 2014
Messages
9,965
Likes
312
Kin
199💸
Kumi
666💴
#2
I’ll go in detail later; but I wanted to say that the awards should have tiers. Hosting a mafia would get you a “cookie”, not literally mean an award that’s a cookie but rather a plain “thank you for hosting”. Now that’s tier 3 award. This would also include awards for participating, meaning if you played in any Maifa games amount to a total of three.

Tier two is where the players who won the game, get their cool awards. This also includes host’s activity in the game and how it was presented (unique).

Tier one is for a player who deducted the suspects with the most clear reason or the maifa who outstandingly killed the town with skill/ luck. For host who went beyond engaging in the interactions, and offered new experiences than before (becoming a Goat).
 
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
23,517
Likes
2,133
Kin
91💸
Kumi
137💴
Awards
#3
Ok when we talk about MVP, what is the definition of MVP? In football/soccer MVP is given to the player that contribute alot or is important for the team usually coming from the wining team. So if townie win the game the award should go to the player that contribute alot and vice versa. Thus it not meet the definition of MVP if serial killer win it as Serial Killer work alone. So if Serial Killer win the game they should receive the best player or the most outstanding medal and not MVP medal. What is Serial Killer value for either team because they is not part of any team.

So we need different kind of medal for different kind of winner.

For Serial Killer it should be the most outstanding medal.

For Townie/Mafia it should be MVO medal

For Host it should be The best game medal.

Game like Soulkiller's game and MadieV's game deserve their own Medal.
Post automatically merged:

I’ll go in detail later; but I wanted to say that the awards should have tiers. Hosting a mafia would get you a “cookie”, not literally mean an award that’s a cookie but rather a plain “thank you for hosting”. Now that’s tier 3 award. This would also include awards for participating, meaning if you played in any Maifa games amount to a total of three.

Tier two is where the players who won the game, get their cool awards. This also includes host’s activity in the game and how it was presented (unique).

Tier one is for a player who deducted the suspects with the most clear reason or the maifa who outstandingly killed the town with skill/ luck. For host who went beyond engaging in the interactions, and offered new experiences than before (becoming a Goat).
@bold, I like that idea.
 
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
22,725
Likes
3,089
Kin
3,163💸
Kumi
1,266💴
Thread starter #4
Here is my suggestion oh how a mafia award system could work.

Let there be two awards, a "Mafia Player" Award and a "Mafia Host" award. Both of these awards can be awarded to a user only once.

Mafia Player Award- Link x completed Normal Mafia Games you have played in.

Mafia Host Award- Link x completed Normal Mafia Games you have hosted.

Where x is the number.

Mafia Player Award Notes:-

Any games you substituted out of will not be counted as a full game.
Any games you were mod-killed in will not be counted as a full game.
Incomplete games (either stalled or called off) will not be counted as a full game.
If you substituted into a game, it will be counted as a full game.

Mafia Host Award Notes:-

Incomplete games (either stalled or called off) will not be counted as a full game.
If you Co-hosted a game it still counts for the number required to get the medal.

This can be done in a pinned thread where people link their games and get the awards.

For a player to finish one game it will take one month. For a host to finish hosting one game and host another will take two months. This is an approximate measure of a normal mafia game taking one month to finish.

With this in mind as an example,

Mafia Player Award- Link 10 completed Normal Mafia Games you have played in - This will take 10 months for a player to achieve.

Mafia Host Award- Link 3 completed Normal Mafia Games you have hosted - This will take 6 months for a host to achieve.
 

Michelle

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
5,572
Likes
1,105
Kin
3,107💸
Kumi
819💴
#5
There could be many options for this, indeed, and we need more than just one award. Awards should be given
1. To players:
- to the winning team or the last player standing.
- to the best player of the game no matter if he won or not.
- to the best player and the winning team/ last player standing.
2 To a host choosed between the last 3-5 games, by votes.
 

Dr.Strange

Active member
Elite
Joined
Oct 19, 2014
Messages
5,088
Likes
1,381
Kin
359💸
Kumi
113💴
Awards
#8
Also best players from each game will be awarded point so top 3 will be automatically gets spot to qualify for mafia universe championship nomination rounds.

@Rohan we need to have this one as well. I messaged Thingyman admin of MU to invite Animebase for the championship. He said he will send the invitation here in March.
Post automatically merged:

1st game i was host of the game

Overall MVP : Poison chan (played well as serial killer and had great deduction in fooling good veteran players as well )

Town MVP : @killthestory for rescuing the town back in the game. Also he correctly deducted all the mafia members in very first attempt as sub.

Mafia MVP: @Gister he played great leadership role and helping out new player like sixth hokage and Quatt to understand how to play as scum.
 
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
22,725
Likes
3,089
Kin
3,163💸
Kumi
1,266💴
Thread starter #11

Mr.Lonely

The friendly loner
Regular
Joined
Oct 29, 2018
Messages
506
Likes
368
Kin
377💸
Kumi
2,033💴
Awards
#13
I think there should be awards given to anyone who meets their win conditions that reflect the theme of the game. Also I feel there is a need for some game spirit so there should be an award where the players at the end of the game elect a mafia MVP.
 
Joined
Nov 25, 2018
Messages
23
Likes
14
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
#14
Nah I do t think just meeting the win con should be awarded there should be a criteria on the basis of participation too I mean those players who are consistent posting and making the game move instead of fluffing should be priotised.
 
Joined
Nov 9, 2018
Messages
408
Likes
334
Kin
79💸
Kumi
0💴
#15
I think mafia medals are a motivation for players/hosts. In my opinion they should fall under two categories:

Participation: Medal after participating in x amount of games so players get motivated to sign up for games. Their status could increase with the amount of games played. For example, bronze medal for 5 games. Silver medal for 10 games. Gold medal for 15 games. Platinum medal for 20 games.

Games won/best players: so players get motivated to give their all in games. They could increase just like the participation ones in proportion to your won games.

Hosts: best hosts, games, based on overall enjoyment and performance of hosts.

Every 2-6 months, an event can take place, like an academy awards where all of Odd's ideas for medals can come into play. :stars:
 

Minamoto Teh First

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
4,387
Likes
202
Kin
394💸
Kumi
173💴
Awards
#17
to winners with the focus of being sneaky, the least often suspected(whether they're it or not) throughout an amount of games with the focus of being trusted, and the sharpest guessers for their good senses.
 

Mr.Lonely

The friendly loner
Regular
Joined
Oct 29, 2018
Messages
506
Likes
368
Kin
377💸
Kumi
2,033💴
Awards
#18
Nah I do t think just meeting the win con should be awarded there should be a criteria on the basis of participation too I mean those players who are consistent posting and making the game move instead of fluffing should be priotised.
Very true, wouldn't be a game without those making it fun and interesting. You can sit around and win but doesn't make it more interesting.
 

Poison chan

Active member
Regular
Joined
Sep 27, 2018
Messages
759
Likes
639
Kin
364💸
Kumi
7,074💴
#19
-- individual game win
-- Medals with win count. I mean say for example, 5 wins, 10wins... (including fractional win)

-- Critic Medal, the host or the players choosing players who have been playing great. And on basis of that one player gets a medal. There could be three positions 12 and 3 may be.
Post automatically merged:

Also a participation medal.
 
Top Bottom