How much Enton/Amatersu is needed?

[WalksInShadows]

2. You are saying ama is like normal fire except a little hotter which is complete contradiction with manga itself

that is not what i said at all. That's how you interpreted it. You aren't really in a position to accuse me of contradicting the manga, because i've used whole pages from the story itself to illustrate how Amaterasu is more hype than it is substance. Since you say i'm contradicting the manga, then where is the evidence that backs up your claim?

 

[TrollKing]

I just gave you an example

Give me a scan where it stated ama failed to do so

 

[ComplexCity]

Give me a scan where it stated ama failed to do so

I don't need to when it's already been shown lol

 

[TrollKing]

that is not what i said at all. That's how you interpreted it. You aren't really in a position to accuse me of contradicting the manga, because i've used whole pages from the story itself to illustrate how Amaterasu is more hype than it is substance. Since you say i'm contradicting the manga, then where is the evidence that backs up your claim?

There's only one ability of ama which makes it different than fire. If you call it hype or not true, then you are saying its basically normal fire. If you accept the only one ability that ama has, then that confirms my point

 

[TrollKing]

I don't need to when it's already been shown lol

Shown where?! You mean in gaiden? Sasuke obviously turned those two metals into nothingness

 

[WalksInShadows]

There's only one ability if ama which makes it different than fire. If you call it hype or not true, then you are saying its basically normal fire. If you accept the only one ability that ama has, then that confirms my point

how could you possibly come to the conclusion that i called Amaterasu normal fire by saying its ability to burn was inconsistent?

 

[ComplexCity]

Shown where?! You mean in gaiden? Sasuke obviously turned those two metals into nothingness

Said the armour buddy

 

[TrollKing]

how could you possibly come to the conclusion that i called Amaterasu normal fire by saying its ability to burn was inconsistent?

The ability of ama is "burn l things". The inconsistency is the speed of burning

And why the inconsistency? It's due to "effect" of what the author trying to emphasize during particular moment while putting far less importance of the physic or "common sense" part

 

[TrollKing]

Said the armour buddy

If the armor didn't burn all the way, whoever wearing it didn't have toss it away like there's a rat on it or something. It did burnt all the way

 

[WalksInShadows]

The ability of ama is "burn l things". The inconsistency is the speed of burning

And why the inconsistency? It's due to "effect" of what the author trying to emphasize during particular moment while putting far less importance of the physic or "common sense" part

i still didn't call it normal fire. The closest thing i even came to calling it normal fire was saying the thread should've pitted normal Katon against TTH instead of Amaterasu because they basically had similar failure rates.

 

[TrollKing]

i still didn't call it normal fire. The closest thing i even came to calling it normal fire was saying the thread should've pitted normal Katon against TTH instead of Amaterasu because they basically had similar failure rates.

The failure rates are always gonna be consistent considering kishimoto hardly let anyone die except white zetsu. So for any "one hit kill jutsu", it would have almost zero successful hit.

And when it hits, don't expect anyone to die. Even a sharp sword or a kunai look like harmless toys.