How is "One piece" manga?should I read it?
- Thread starter Brucewen001
- Start date
Amanwithnoplan
Active member
Brucewen001
Active member
ok ok ,after reading all ,and i mean ALL , of your comments, it's time to do mine...
fact number 1) judjing from the anime fans i ve talked to, Anyone who ve told me that one piece sucks, haven't finished it all , there has NEVER been someone that will tell me that one piece sucks after watching all episodes
fact number 2) tell me what is so big about naruto story line and so surprisingly unexpected , except
I mean , in op **there are some spoils here for the ones that haven't finished one piece anime** you get to see so many characters in the next episodes, you get surprised so much, for example who could expect that what shanks did in episode 4 was haki and it's one of the main abilities that all strong guys in OP have...or that ace met luffy in alabasta arc cause he was chasing some guy, then 100 episodes after you get to see shanks talking to whitebeard about ace and blackbeard and then 100 episodes after ace and blackbeards battle which would lead to another 100 episodes after to the best arc of OP , That's what serious plot means, the plot is what makes OP to me so huge, i could mention so many other things like laboon and brook or even sanjis failed bounty poster that leads to duval or cobby and how he will get to be luffys rival as marine and much more , also what about the characters in OP? there are so many characters with potential like the supernovas or the marine characters, the warlords, blackbeard and the 3 yonkou even sabo...
naruto is just about sasuke and him and how he gets to save sasuke and becoming a hokage
and also
WTF!! OP LACKS COMEDY?? seriously, now SERIOUSLY?? that's not something based on someones opinion, but it's a fact
Also i find it rididulous to even mention and compare bleach to naruto or one piece, even if the story/plot was so good as one piece, just by mentioning 170 filler episodes in 350 episodes should be just the end of conversation
i also like naruto and bleach , but NO! the plot in one piece is so clever and perfect that i can't like it as much as the other 2
I almost forgot... it was a pain for me too to click on "Must read!just like Naruto, bleach." you should have an option "best anime/manga ever"
sorry if my english were bad
fact number 1) judjing from the anime fans i ve talked to, Anyone who ve told me that one piece sucks, haven't finished it all , there has NEVER been someone that will tell me that one piece sucks after watching all episodes
fact number 2) tell me what is so big about naruto story line and so surprisingly unexpected , except
the thing about madara and tobi
naruto is just about sasuke and him and how he gets to save sasuke and becoming a hokage
and also
WTF!! OP LACKS COMEDY?? seriously, now SERIOUSLY?? that's not something based on someones opinion, but it's a fact
Also i find it rididulous to even mention and compare bleach to naruto or one piece, even if the story/plot was so good as one piece, just by mentioning 170 filler episodes in 350 episodes should be just the end of conversation
i also like naruto and bleach , but NO! the plot in one piece is so clever and perfect that i can't like it as much as the other 2
I almost forgot... it was a pain for me too to click on "Must read!just like Naruto, bleach." you should have an option "best anime/manga ever"
sorry if my english were bad
Last edited:
Awards
I couldn't resist posting. To be honest, I could never understand the fixation with Bleach. 2 years ago we even had to make a Bleach arena by demand of so many people in love with it. For me it is a combination of things we have seen before within a context of extreme elitism. I mean this, I have never seen a more profound elitist approach in contemporary media.
I also cannot understand the praise on Bleach's art style. I have read a fair amount of mangas, not much just a decent number of 10-15, but I have never encountered a manga harder for me to read in terms of design than Bleach. I seriously cannot understand what is going on, all I see is a bunch of combined smooth and hard lines and a quote.
Example:
Maybe it's just me though; I am not very artistic myself.
I have just started watching One Piece. I'm on episode 105 and it is good. A bit boring sometimes, but I acknowledge that I am only in the beginning of it. I think it's worth a shot, but up to this point, I like Naruto more.
I also cannot understand the praise on Bleach's art style. I have read a fair amount of mangas, not much just a decent number of 10-15, but I have never encountered a manga harder for me to read in terms of design than Bleach. I seriously cannot understand what is going on, all I see is a bunch of combined smooth and hard lines and a quote.
Example:
You must be registered for see images
Maybe it's just me though; I am not very artistic myself.
I have just started watching One Piece. I'm on episode 105 and it is good. A bit boring sometimes, but I acknowledge that I am only in the beginning of it. I think it's worth a shot, but up to this point, I like Naruto more.
IMO One Piece is the best manga/anime out there
The first 20/30 episodes were hard for me but once I got to 30 I literally got addicted to it
Note: I recommend watching it instead of reading it, watching is alot funnier
The first 20/30 episodes were hard for me but once I got to 30 I literally got addicted to it
Note: I recommend watching it instead of reading it, watching is alot funnier
Well, I have to say, the Bleach art style is simply brilliant.
Apart from the fact that you need to read a page 2 times to figure out what is what, the art is simply gorgeous in terms of anime. I would even go as far as to say that it is in Par with Hellsing art style, which is...flawless and divine.
About One Piece, I take it you are around the Arabasta arc?
The Anime really takes off starting from Skypia, so patience, in a little while, you will be seeing OP in your dreams.
Whoever is still doubting One Piece after reading all these positive comments and looking at the poll, should stick their head in the ground and not come up for air for the next 48hrs. must be too in love with Naruto to give the better anime a chance.
"Did he just go there?" He went there ~_~
"Did he just go there?" He went there ~_~
Boa Hancock
Active member
I'm going to clear some things up about OP art being crap. The general anime fan's view on One Piece is that, it's art is shit. It sucks donkey balls since they don't look human.
They're referring to this.
It's the early part of the series, and mangakas that start their first manga usually haven't finalized their drawings. Also this series was made in 1997, and with Oda's decision to go "dot eye" with the art, made it more unlikeable to new fans. Of course, young boys of those years didn't have a problem with it, it's only in this decade where these young boys have a problem.
Now I'm gonna compare OP's art in action scenes with fellow WSJ works, Naruto and Bleach respectively, since Toriko isn't considered part of the original "Big 3" and Fairy Tail isn't even in WSJ. These pages are from the latest chapters of their respective series.
In the Naruto page, we see Madara getting held by Gaara's sand tentacle, then a panel showing Gaara's thoughts, Naruto presumably throwing the Rasenshuriken (I said presumably since we don't see him actually throwing it even though we already know he did) and the Rasenshuriken right on target for Madara to eat.
Yet we get three panels of Bleach-esque exposition of Madara's face after that.
In the Bleach page, we see Riruka taunting Rukia, then Riruka releasing a stuffed toy. Rukia avoids it, Riruka gets irritated and opens a vial. The panel after that is only clear after extended scrutiny. I for one think it's a finger on the gun trigger. Am I right? On the next page, top panel, I'm not clear on Riruka's arms. It doesn't look right to me, makes me feel I'm watching three arms at once.
On the One Piece page, we see Zeo mocking Brook while Brook is talking and taking out his sword. He unleashes a technique, Zeo avoids it, Brook becomes a badass, the effect of the technique on the ground is shown and Zeo's reaction to Soul Sword is also shown. Pretty clear sequence of events.
Oh and did you notice similarities between Naruto and Bleach? Their fight locales aren't as detailed as One Piece's, and most of the time dimensions are skewed.
Now with all this evidence backing me up, someone offer a counter-argument why One Piece art is not on-par, if not better than, Naruto or Bleach's.
They're referring to this.
You must be registered for see images
It's the early part of the series, and mangakas that start their first manga usually haven't finalized their drawings. Also this series was made in 1997, and with Oda's decision to go "dot eye" with the art, made it more unlikeable to new fans. Of course, young boys of those years didn't have a problem with it, it's only in this decade where these young boys have a problem.
Now I'm gonna compare OP's art in action scenes with fellow WSJ works, Naruto and Bleach respectively, since Toriko isn't considered part of the original "Big 3" and Fairy Tail isn't even in WSJ. These pages are from the latest chapters of their respective series.
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
In the Naruto page, we see Madara getting held by Gaara's sand tentacle, then a panel showing Gaara's thoughts, Naruto presumably throwing the Rasenshuriken (I said presumably since we don't see him actually throwing it even though we already know he did) and the Rasenshuriken right on target for Madara to eat.
Yet we get three panels of Bleach-esque exposition of Madara's face after that.
In the Bleach page, we see Riruka taunting Rukia, then Riruka releasing a stuffed toy. Rukia avoids it, Riruka gets irritated and opens a vial. The panel after that is only clear after extended scrutiny. I for one think it's a finger on the gun trigger. Am I right? On the next page, top panel, I'm not clear on Riruka's arms. It doesn't look right to me, makes me feel I'm watching three arms at once.
On the One Piece page, we see Zeo mocking Brook while Brook is talking and taking out his sword. He unleashes a technique, Zeo avoids it, Brook becomes a badass, the effect of the technique on the ground is shown and Zeo's reaction to Soul Sword is also shown. Pretty clear sequence of events.
Oh and did you notice similarities between Naruto and Bleach? Their fight locales aren't as detailed as One Piece's, and most of the time dimensions are skewed.
Now with all this evidence backing me up, someone offer a counter-argument why One Piece art is not on-par, if not better than, Naruto or Bleach's.