How do you rate Madara's villainy out of 5?

[Sageflash]

On a scale from 1-5, from Madara's first appearance against the Gokage til his present dust-up with Gai, how would you rate his viability and progression as a villain?

BQ: Do you prefer Madara or Obito's look as the Juubi jinchuuriki?

 

[The Ramen Guy]

Obito all day son. Madara ain't got nothin on em

 

[Itαchi Uchihα]

5 compared to the other "villains."

I like how Obito looked though!

 

[A Zealot]

I'll say 3 because in a way he is trying to bring world peace.

I'll still choose Madara

 

[Goetia]

Madara for me is 3/5. His cause is justified. No idea what he wants to do in the Infinite Tsukuyomi. I like Obito's look better as Juubi Jin. It has a complicated design compared to Madara's.

 

[a banned cartoon]

I say three, because although his reasons are selfish, he's not like a villain who wants to destroy everyone. He just wants peace, but in a bad way that nobody agrees with. If he were just wanting to kill everyone, and obtain all jutsu's like Orochimaru, then I'd give him a 4-5.

 

[-Spoiler-]

3.5/5 He gots the right stuff and all but he's a tad too preachy and lacking the Megalomaniac complex i love in villains ( thats why Orochimaru will always be number 1 in my book).

About the look Obito for me its more Sinister, Madara seems to be trying to make a fashion statement.

 

[Denzel Washington]

4.

He's a pretty damn entertaining villain. He, Kakuzu, and Hidan are the only ones that struck me as "evil".

I'd give him a 5, but I'm waiting for TNJ... Although I doubt it will happen.

 

[Dannie]

Orochimaru was the best villain this story ever had. Period. Madara is too lazy and couldn't even successfully kill the Gokage. Obito is the worst villain to ever exist in Shounen. The dude is the laughing stock of the ninja academy.

 

[Uchiha420]

3/5... Hes a badass and gets things done but he wouldn't be my choice for a Final Villain in this Manga
Obito was a psycopath and was so Anti-Naruto that he really had me sold that he was going to be the final villain and was a better fit IMO. But Kishi is on Madara's d.
Obito Jin looked way better and more villain like.

 

[assface3]

Badassery: 5/5 easily
Ideals: 3/5, due to being forced, yet justified as well

Honestly, I like him over Oro.

BQ: Madara all day.

 

[Your Creepy Stalker]

4. Cool, but Motive is the same as everyone else, and the main character met him 1 day ago.
Obito looks better as juubi jin, and gets a 6/5

 

[Uchiha420]

Orochimaru was the best villain this story ever had. Period. Madara is too lazy and couldn't even successfully kill the Gokage. Obito is the worst villain to ever exist in Shounen. The dude is the laughing stock of the ninja academy.

Obito is the reason 90% of the things in Naruto happened and hes the worst villain ever?

 

[Dannie]

Obito is the reason 90% of the things in Naruto happened and hes the worst villain ever?

You are missing the whole picture. The reason he did all this was because of a girl crush.

 

[Denzel Washington]

Orochimaru was the best villain this story ever had. Period. Madara is too lazy and couldn't even successfully kill the Gokage. Obito is the worst villain to ever exist in Shounen. The dude is the laughing stock of the ninja academy.

This post is a laughing stock.

 

[Your Creepy Stalker]

You are missing the whole picture. The reason he did all this was because of a girl crush.

You are missing the whole picture. The reason everyone does everything in the manga is that hashirama is Terrible at making villages.

 

[Dannie]

This post is a laughing stock.

You mad bro?

 

[Sageflash]

Orochimaru was the best villain this story ever had. Period. Madara is too lazy and couldn't even successfully kill the Gokage. Obito is the worst villain to ever exist in Shounen. The dude is the laughing stock of the ninja academy.

Well it's not that he couldn't, just that he chose not to finish the job for whatever reason. They all should have died right there except for Gaara imo. It would have made Madara much more intimidating and created a sense of urgency and loss within the Alliance. It could've been a great oppurtunity for Naruto and Sasuke to show some leadership skills and really drive their points home with defending what you love and reshaping the world.

That's my biggest pet peeve about the War Arc. But I personally think Obito looks much better as the Juubi jinchuriki, Madara seems like he's wearing a robe or something.

 

[Shalev]

Madara is too friendly when he fights.

 

[Conspirator.]

Obito is the reason 90% of the things in Naruto happened and hes the worst villain ever?

Yes, obito was a shit villain.

OT:Madara gets a 3.5/5, the only thing setting him back is that he inexplicably holds back, and he loves battle too much. He literally stopped carrying out the moon eye plan when he sensed hashirama's chakra...