[Question] Gol D Roger ?

[Olorin]

Akainu vs WB is a different case. Whitebeard was stronger than Akainu and 2 quakes was enough to put him to sleep.

Whereas Prime WB and Prime Roger were eually matched and their fights lasted much longer. They were most likely fighting for days since it was said that WB tied with Roger, which means that Roger was eating plenty of those quakes that WB gave to Akainu yet Roger lived through them.

Prime WB was faster, stronger, more durable, not sick etc.

Everything about Prime WB was>old WB.

so that's why after their fight WB died due to gun fire and Akainu pushed back all the pirates including the Commanders?

you make it sound like WB was way above Akainu which simply wan't the case

I know ppl love the booms and cracks at MF but all that makes the think that WB could just solo any admiral for dinner when clearly he would have to go to extreme dif to defeat one and might even lose

WB has his equals, Roger was one of them, Garp was another, and after them came Dragon (son of someone equal to Roger and father of the future PK) and Shanks

I'm not saying WB wasn't extremely powerful, I'm simply saying he isn't the only one

 

[Black Mamba]

And? So was WB and he was able to beast while outnumbered out of his prime. If it was prime WB, he would have merked and survived at MF, so Roger has no excuse.

what? it was WB pirates and like 40 allied pirates vs WG.....

Roger and his crew(one ship) had to fight this:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

roger vs shiki 1v1, roger wins.

 

[VongolaX]

Does Luffy destroy Shiki in one of the movies, also it is canon

His weakness was specifically storm, that's why he needed a navigator as good as nami.

The guy is able to toss ships, move 8 mountains and created 3-4 floating islands.

He was no push over, but a storm mixed with Luffy's amazing brute strength just knocked him out cold.

Sengoku and garp kicked his @ss too.

 

[Fireplay]

so that's why after their fight WB died due to gun fire and Akainu pushed back all the pirates including the Commanders?

you make it sound like WB was way above Akainu which simply wan't the case

I know ppl love the booms and cracks at MF but all that makes the think that WB could just solo any admiral for dinner when clearly he would have to go to extreme dif to defeat one and might even lose

WB has his equals, Roger was one of them, Garp was another, and after them came Dragon (son of someone equal to Roger and father of the future PK) and Shanks

I'm not saying WB wasn't extremely powerful, I'm simply saying he isn't the only one

What happened after the fight has no meaning when estimating the gap between Akainu and Whitebeard. What you're saying is that WB was only admiral level...since you said that he'd have to go extreme-diff to beat an admiral and he'd probaby lose. Admiral vs Admiral is having to go extreme-diff and either one could lose. Your saying WB could lose or extreme-diff an admiral even though he was hyped to be the strongest man in the world and was the stronger of the four Yonko...Your indirectly claiming that Akainu and the admirals>Shanks and the Yonko.

WB defeated Akainu in 2 quakes. WB went into the fight already heavily injured, old and sick yet he made short work of Akainu. The winner was Whitebeard, yes, Akainu's attacks contributed to WB's eventual defeat like the rest of the attacks he took but he still lost.

Theres no proof that Shanks and Dragon can tie with Prime Roger, Garp and Whitebeard. Even in hype, they still aren't equal to the trio.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Nobody will surpass him imo U_U

 

[Cruciatus]

Nobody will surpass him imo U_U

Enel already has.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Enel already has.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Cruciatus]

You must be registered for see images

Raigo destroys Oro Jackson gg Roger.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Raigo destroys Oro Jackson gg Roger.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Cruciatus]

You must be registered for see images

Enel comes down from the Moon with his arc. Sees Roger. Creates storm clouds. Has lightning rain down everywhere on the ocean Roger is on. Constant electrocution of water. Country-sized Raigo comes down. Roger can't stop it. Destroys Oro Jackson while Enel stays out of Roger's range on Arc Maxim. Roger falls into electrified water. Body is paralyzed. Drowns if he somehow survives all of that.

Legit arguments you can't counter, so gifs are posted. GG Roger. GG Mr. Outside. Yahahahaha

 

[Peace Maker]

Ofcourse the next generation would surpass the previous one.

 

[Tomato God]

Who knows. Luffy will eventually surpass him. Sabo might aswell (if he survives that long) since he's basically Post-skip Ace and if Ace had lived he would've eventually surpassed Roger.

Luffy
Law
Kid
Teach
Smoker
Sabo (maybe if he lives long enough)

will all surpass WB, Garp, Roger, Shiki etc.

What i want to know is how the hell did Roger live for so long. I mean it was said that WB and Roger were rivals and tied which means that there's been alot of bloody fights between those two WHICH means that Roger has taken a quake to the face plenty of times. How the hell does someone take a WB's quakes so many times and live on to tell a story?

My bets wouldn't have been on smokey
More on Coby

Luffy - Roger
Law - White beard
Kid - Shiki
Coby - Garp
BB - ???
Smokey might be the new generations version of Kong though.

 

[Tomato God]

Enel comes down from the Moon with his arc. Sees Roger. Creates storm clouds. Has lightning rain down everywhere on the ocean Roger is on. Constant electrocution of water. Country-sized Raigo comes down. Roger can't stop it. Destroys Oro Jackson while Enel stays out of Roger's range on Arc Maxim. Roger falls into electrified water. Body is paralyzed. Drowns if he somehow survives all of that.

Legit arguments you can't counter, so gifs are posted. GG Roger. GG Mr. Outside. Yahahahaha

He could just be a haki beast. Tanking electrocution wasnt hard for wiper or anyone for that matter. Enel like legit killed three people. Even the old man that was conis's father tanked that shit. Pre Skip sanji and Pre skip usopp tanks that shit.
And raigo?
Remember when Shanks and WB clashed and split the clouds with their kings haki.
Imagine roger splitting the clouds and punching enel in the face.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Enel comes down from the Moon with his arc. Sees Roger. Creates storm clouds. Has lightning rain down everywhere on the ocean Roger is on. Constant electrocution of water. Country-sized Raigo comes down. Roger can't stop it. Destroys Oro Jackson while Enel stays out of Roger's range on Arc Maxim. Roger falls into electrified water. Body is paralyzed. Drowns if he somehow survives all of that.

Legit arguments you can't counter, so gifs are posted. GG Roger. GG Mr. Outside. Yahahahaha

You must be registered for see images

 

[crono0929]

did i just read enel, the one who got his a$$ beat by pre-gear luffy can beat roger??