FMA Brotherhood vs FMA

[ZetaWar]

the better one is :|
my opinion
FMA Brotherhood

Spoiler

for every reader
Full Metal Alchemist
if u havent watched it then watch them awesome

 

[LolaxXx]

Brotherhood is waaay better.
I watched the 1st Fullmetal on adultswim a few years back, while it was interesting, the lack of action sequences eventually made me bored.

But brotherhood was a whole nother thing. Not only was it interesting, made more sense and was more in-depth, the action was awesome.

FMA: Brotherhood is the best to go, to any new FMA watchers, watch FMA: BH, THEEEEEN the original anime version if you want to.

 

[Hyperion]

FMA Brotherhood is wack.

 

[Zawar]

FMA Brotherhood
FMA has a bad ending

 

[Baldy]

Brotherhood FTW

 

[marvinkid]

i like both

 

[Serpent]

I like them the same, and they both are really good.

FMA (2003) is basically it's own story with the same basic characters. almost like a Fan Fic. It's a lot longer (almost 3 times as long as brotherhood) and last "Episode" is a full length movie.

FMA Brotherhood (2010) sticks with the Manga, but is short but just as good as the 2003 series.. IMO

 

[ronus]

so there really were two version of full metal alchemist... I am now watching Brotherhood i guess and its quite nice..

 

[15pathsofchaos]

Their both good
brotherhood is better for 2 reasons closer to the manga and more action.
FMA aleast human transmutaion could work
Thought brotherhood was going to be lame at first,Should've shown it at 2003

 

[WinterMute]

They are both good. But while, FMA wigged out the closer the series go to the end....FMA Brotherhood remained strong.

FMA Brotherhood for the win.

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

brotherhood all the way its has more action and better ending and the father BADASSS

 

[Roy]

I watched both and Brotherhood as ALOT better..

The fights got alot more action, alot more character development and a way better plot, especially the final arc, that was just soo epic.. everything in Brotherhood just made alot more sense.

 

[Mortal]

I liked fma cuz ed died at the end but I liked fma brotherhood wen flame killed envy

 

[Roy]

I liked fma cuz ed died at the end but I liked fma brotherhood wen flame killed envy

Ed didn't die in FMA, he was sent to another dimension, there's an FMA movie where Ed is in that other dimension and returns to his own world at the end.. pretty much a movie to close the open ending FMA left.

And yeah, Roy is ALOT more awesome in Brotherhood.

 

[Alphonse Elric]

I love them both, they are my favorite anime and manga. Though I prefer brotherhood over just normal FMA. It just seems much better at most parts then the normal one.

 

[Mortal]

Ed didn't die in FMA, he was sent to another dimension, there's an FMA movie where Ed is in that other dimension and returns to his own world at the end.. pretty much a movie to close the open ending FMA left.

And yeah, Roy is ALOT more awesome in Brotherhood.

So on fma envy didnt stab ed thru da chest

 

[Roy]

So on fma envy didnt stab ed thru da chest

Oh, forgot about that.. since Alphonse healed him anyway o.o

 

[HiiTMAN]

i like both equally

 

[YoItsJo]

While Brotherhood(2009) is probably the better series, I love the original(2003) more. It was the first thing about Fullmetal Alchemist I saw, even before I read the manga, and those characters just grew on me so fast. I think the biggest thing that hinders me personally from liking Brotherhood more is the fact that the Homunculi weren't created from failed attempts at human transmutation in Brotherhood. My favorite character is Envy in the original and each and every time he came onto the screen my first thought was, "He hates them." because he clearly hated Ed and Al. That was a hatred I wish they would have gone on more in the original... You don't leave something like that under the surface of a plot until the last two or three episodes. Naaawww. Of course Brotherhood is still, in my opinion, technically the better one. It's the one that follows the offical manga, anyway.

 

[PandaMan.]

I just finished watching both of them and I liked brotherhood a bit better