Falsity of Rinne Tensei.

[Legendary Broly]

This is another limitation to it. Edos cant use it. I think the reason that is is because the jutsu also requires the lifeforce or soul of the one who needs to be revived (in this case madara) but thats impossible as his soul is already in a body

This makes sense ! rep :y

​

Living body. Otherwise Madara would have just summoned Nagato via Rinne Tensei release himself from Edo Tensei, and be revived by the newly revived Nagato. ​

Maybe But Nagato is sealed. Can sealed people be boght back via Rinne Tensei ?

 

[Varrah]

I disagree with one thing:

"The technique literally has no restrictions or limitations. "

If this was so, Madara would've revived himself already. Also Based on the properties of R-Tensei, if the above statement is true and he did use R-Tensei on himself either:

1) His current body would be disintegrated and replaced with the original.
2) His soul would be removed from the Dead ninja's body and returned to the original.

The implication from the Manga is that it's restricted from use to "the dead"/ "Edo's". Also, it's confusing as to why Obito's life would have to be sacrificed to revived Madara based on Konona's implication that "Sufficient chakra" would've kept nagato alive even after he used the technique. Personally, i think her judgement was erroneous and Nagato would've still died even if his chakra was replenished on using the technique, else obito would be wrong which is near impossible.

Implicating that the body has be living in a similar to become Jinchūriki, but in my hastiness I forgot to include this, thanks for bringing it to my attention.

Remember, Obito does not have mastery over the Rinnegan like Nagato did, so it stands to reasons that he would be subjugated to such faults.​

 

[Waltz]

​

Implicating that the body has be living in a similar to become Jinchūriki, but in my hastiness I forgot to include this, thanks for bringing it to my attention.

Remember, Obito does not have mastery over the Rinnegan like Nagato did, so it stands to reasons that he would be subjugated to such faults.​

Mastery and Knowledge are vastly different things.

 

[Transcendence]

And that's why its perfect for Naruto Already massive Chakra reserves and in Bjiuu mode can use it without faltering.

 

[Varrah]

Mastery and Knowledge are vastly different things.

Yes, the applications of them are as well. ​

 

[Waltz]

​

Yes, the applications of them are as well. ​

Hence why i would trust Obito's un-refuted word over Konan's assumption on the technique.

 

[Varrah]

Hence why i would trust Obito's un-refuted word over Konan's assumption on the technique.

Sensible. ​