[Discussion] Fairy Tail is poorly written.

[LUMOS ULTIMATUM]

- Okay for first picture, that would make for now only 2, for OP's 700+ chapters and FT's 300+ chapters. That's not rip off.

- The manga is called Fairy Tail. In some mythologies, Fairies are water beings that lives in the see. Some of them are similar to mermais, while some are exactly what Mavis is. Rip off? No!.




Really. I always found odd these posts like "I won't waste my time". If you don't want to waste, than why did you came here, you though you will come to FT's section leave a couple of "rip off picture" and go... no..

Obviously, because I put these 'rip off picture' as you say and expect decent arguments which was my mistake. These similarities are not as subtle as you point them out to be and from an objective point of view, this is way more than an inspiration. You can copy fighting styles and inspire yourselves from myths, legends or other popular personalities but just copy and pasting from other mangas is what is called a cheap rip off. However you try to justify it, there are things that are plain obvious.

 

[Memento Mori]

Obviously, because I put these 'rip off picture' as you say and expect decent arguments which was my mistake.

Those pictures were a decent to begin with.?

These similarities are not as subtle as you point them out to be and from an objective point of view, this is way more than an inspiration. You can copy fighting styles and inspire yourselves from myths, legends or other popular personalities but just copy and pasting from other mangas is what is called a cheap rip off. However you try to justify it, there are things that are plain obvious.

Who said you that is an rip off ?.Both Underline and bold parts contradict with bothselves.So copying is not a rip off but a Copy and paste is a rip off ?.So one copied it but didn't pasted it but we can still see the paste in the work ?.

 

[LUMOS ULTIMATUM]

Those pictures were a decent to begin with.



Who said you that is an rip off ?.Both Underline and bold parts contradict with bothselves.So copying is not a rip off but a Copy and paste is a rip off ?.So one copied it but didn't pasted it but we can still see the paste in the work ?.

Tale and You always come with "good arguments". LolLolLolLol

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Obviously, because I put these 'rip off picture' as you say and expect decent arguments which was my mistake. These similarities are not as subtle as you point them out to be and from an objective point of view, this is way more than an inspiration. You can copy fighting styles and inspire yourselves from myths, legends or other popular personalities but just copy and pasting from other mangas is what is called a cheap rip off. However you try to justify it, there are things that are plain obvious.

Could you actually show me similarity between Racer and Hoteye, but in words not picture, because I must be blind for pictures. If you are going to continue with rip off thing than there is no thing as "original" everything is rip off.

Please, would you mind wasting little more time in explaning plain obvious things, because for some of us it's not plain obvious. I already gave you arguments for more than half pictures you posted, you didn't do anything after that except that you said "it's plain obvious" which is not an argument.

 

[LUMOS ULTIMATUM]

Could you actually show me similarity between Racer and Hoteye, but in words not picture, because I must be blind for pictures. If you are going to continue with rip off thing than there is no thing as "original" everything is rip off.

If you say so, it must be a fact. :bye::bye:

 

[bajram]

Anything more or is that all ?
I will make my move.I will show you how Naruto is a rip off......????One Piece is a rip off of......????etc....,.Stealing Ideas ?Jinchuriki?Dragons ?Yeah all are a rip off from Dragon Ball Z.

Edit - And again is that all [email protected] you just call Tale a fanboy ?Ofcourse he is a boy and a fan.XD

Is that all u have to say? As I said the characters design may not be considered a rip off but the jinchuriki-Dragon relation of being sealed in the body of someone is the same shit, and for me that's stealing or however u like to call it, if u want to prove me wrong then do it.

 

[Memento Mori]

Tale and You always come with "good arguments". LolLolLolLol

And so then ? Lol Lol

 

[Memento Mori]

Is that all u have to say? As I said the characters design may not be considered a rip off but the jinchuriki-Dragon relation of being sealed in the body of someone is the same shit, and for me that's stealing or however u like to call it, if u want to prove me wrong then do it.

Is that all you can post either ?.Naruto-Jinchuriki is a rip off from DBZ and Dragon - Natsu is a rip off from DBZ too.How is that ??

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Tale and You always come with "good arguments". LolLolLolLol

Thank you, very kind of you.

If you say so, it must be a fact. :bye::bye:

For some unknown reason you are still not giving me any arguments.

End argument, or don't start it in the first place.

 

[LUMOS ULTIMATUM]

And so then ? Lol Lol

Just saying.

 

[bajram]

Is that all you can post either ?.Naruto-Jinchuriki is a rip off from DBZ and Dragon - Natsu is a rip off from DBZ too.How is that ??

Yes, that is all I can post since I never said FT is a huge rip off from other mangas, ur not even reading properly at all, how is naruto-Jinchuriki a rip off from DBZ? even if that is my point still stands, mashima just stole that idea instead of making his own, ur not proving wrong anything just posting nonsense and shit.

 

[Memento Mori]

Yes, that is all I can post since I never said FT is a huge rip off from other mangas, ur not even reading properly at all, how is naruto-Jinchuriki a rip off from DBZ? even if that is my point still stands, mashima just stole that idea instead of making his own, ur not proving wrong anything just posting nonsense and shit.

Then there is no need to.So basically if kishi does that,it is not a rip off but when Hiro does that it is.Cool story.

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Yes, that is all I can post since I never said FT is a huge rip off from other mangas, ur not even reading properly at all, how is naruto-Jinchuriki a rip off from DBZ? even if that is my point still stands, mashima just stole that idea instead of making his own, ur not proving wrong anything just posting nonsense and shit.

This is fallacy.

 

[bajram]

Then there is no need to.So basically if kishi does that,it is not a rip off but when Hiro does that it is.Cool story.

When I ever said that I was saying kishi never did an rip off from dbz, whether kishi stole DBZ ides or not idc, my point still stands the dragon-natsu thing is a rip off.

This is fallacy.

Why is that, as I said if u can prove me that the dragon-natsu thing is not a rip off that state it.

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Actually no. When debating any issue, there is an implicit burden of proof on the person asserting a claim. I'm not the one who said "Dragons are rip off Jinchuuriki", so burden of proof is not on me, but you.

 

[Memento Mori]

When I ever said that I was saying kishi never did an rip off from dbz, whether kishi stole DBZ ides or not idc, my point still stands the dragon-natsu thing is a rip off.



Why is that, as I said if u can prove me that the dragon-natsu thing is not a rip off that state it.

Rip off is how you view it and I don't.That is more like it is a inspiration both of them taken from DBZ or ideas they have taken from DBZ for their own work.So you only care about FT is a rip off but don't care about any other manga of being such ?.

There is no such a thing for me to prove.If any post how Natsu-dragon is rip off/

 

[bajram]

Rip off is how you view it and I don't.That is more like it is a inspiration both of them taken from DBZ or ideas they have taken from DBZ for their own work.So you only care about FT is a rip off but don't care about any other manga of being such ?.

If making the exact same thing is an inspiration then anything can be considered an inspiration these day's then anything is an inspiration and nothing is a rip off...Oh and no idc about neither naruto or FT at all, both have a shitton of flaws but I was just stating my opinion on the discussion in hand.

 

[Memento Mori]

If making the exact same thing is an inspiration then anything can be considered an inspiration these day's then anything is an inspiration and nothing is a rip off...Oh and no idc about neither naruto or FT at all, both have a shitton of flaws but I was just stating my opinion on the discussion in hand.

Does mangaka calls themselves to each like that japan ?.How come stating something is a rip off an opinion ?.Where is the proof for the rip off ?

That is nice to know!.

 

[bajram]

Does mangaka calls themselves to each like that japan ?.How come stating something is a rip off an opinion ?.Where is the proof for the rip off ?

That is nice to know!.

Does mangaka tell each other that this arc actually is shit or the flaws in ur manga are too much? Oh now ur acting stubborn, I cant believe u actually want proof for something obvious...

 

[Memento Mori]

Does mangaka tell each other that this arc actually is shit or the flaws in ur manga are too much? Oh now ur acting stubborn, I cant believe u actually want proof for something obvious...

Stubborn ? Pitiful claims.
Then don't try to claim something.