Edo Madara(with Rinnegan) Vs Edo Itachi

[-Jiraiya-]

I have been wondering who would win. I know the fight may proceed infinitely, since both are edo tensei's but also each have their unique sealing techs eg: Itachi's sealing sword (Totsuka no Tsurugi) & Edo Madara has rinnegan through which he can use naraka path to steal Itachi's soul. But these things aside,
*Both are Uchiha's-they can predict each other movements using their Sharingan
*Both have completed form of susanoo
*Edo Madara has rinnegan & sharingan
*Itachi has Amaterasu (presumably Madara may have)
*Single pierce from Itachi's susanoo's sword can seal Madara away whereas Madara's Naraka path might have to pull the soul out into it to seal Itachi (like we saw with Pain)
*I think Itachi has high base speed...
*Madara is a ninja who fought in par with 1st Hokage...
*Almost like life or death situation since one will be sealed by other.
So who would win Edo Itachi or Edo Madara(with Rinnegan).

Pls post your views.
Keep it clean.

 

[shaii010]

edo madara !!!!

 

[ChocolateBear]

edo madara because itachi could NOT take on 5 kages

 

[Bijuu13]

itachi seems like hed have a less challenging time sealing bcuz of his sword but madara is better with combat. ima go with itachi

 

[Killer B]

Only thing edo Itachi has on edo madara are legendary weapons.....

Madara can counter anything Itachi has has easy......

can that one path tech that absorbs ninjutsu protect from Amatarasu?

overall this would be an epic fight but I thing there is a reason why Edo Madara was the trump card...even though Kabuto said Itachi is on another level of the others.

Main reason for Madara win is Wood Style can pull itachi out of his susanoo....

40% chance Itachi wins......60% chance Madara wins

 

[-Jiraiya-]

edo madara because itachi could NOT take on 5 kages

As far now none of Kages are shown to possess sealing tech, further as Itachi is an edo summon he can use Tsukuyomi/Susanoo/Amaterasu to its full extent. So I think Itachi may win with difficuly esp against Raikage, Tsuchikage..:shrug:

 

[JirayiaRIPforever]

the results of this fight are this

 

[-Jiraiya-]

Only thing edo Itachi has on edo madara are legendary weapons.....

Madara can counter anything Itachi has has easy......

can that one path tech that absorbs ninjutsu protect from Amatarasu?

overall this would be an epic fight but I thing there is a reason why Edo Madara was the trump card...even though Kabuto said Itachi is on another level of the others.

Main reason for Madara win is Wood Style can pull itachi out of his susanoo....

40% chance Itachi wins......60% chance Madara wins

I agree but Edo Madara has no seperate dead bodies as paths but he himself has all 6paths which means he can use only one path's power at a time. For example if he uses one path to absorb amaterasu, Susanoo's sword may still do its cutting as it is a physical attack... But still wood style possess great advantage in addition to rinnegan so only I left it out of discussion.