Does Byakugan have Precog? Does 1T Sharingan have Precog?

[Magnolius]

If they both do, which is superior? If not, which one is more capable of predicting movement in CQC? I know Neji has no blind spot, so he must be able to predict an enemies movements very well in CQC. I also know from the Sasuke vs Lee fight that his sharingan could keep up with Lee's fast taijutsu trained movements. Who predicts (keeps up with movements) better?

 

[Uchiha boii]

Bykugan has no pre cog according to the manga the bykugan visually can see chakara points and has zero blind spots sharingan has shown pre cog even at the 1 tomoe stage ie sarada against the many shins
Sharingan has pre cog byakugan does not

 

[House]

Byakugan has no precognition. Meaning it can't tell what your movement will be like Sharingan. You can, however, deduce the movement (without metagaming) like for example: If you see the enemy running towards you with his right arm brought back, you can deduce that he might be throwing a right strike at you. You don't need pre-cog but the ability of deduction. Arrive at a reason and draw a conclusion.

 

[chopstickchakra]

Neither of them have pre-cog. Sharingan allows reactions based on the most minute movements but it's not pre cog. Pre cog by definition means knowing before it happens, Sharingan needs to have the motion start before it can begin tracking the trajectory or motion therefore by definition it is not pre cog.

 

[BlacLord™]

Byakugan has no precognition. Meaning it can't tell what your movement will be like Sharingan. You can, however, deduce the movement (without metagaming) like for example: If you see the enemy running towards you with his right arm brought back, you can deduce that he might be throwing a right strike at you. You don't need pre-cog but the ability of deduction. Arrive at a reason and draw a conclusion.

But you need pre-cog to dodge if you're not fast enough. Especially in H2H.

 

[BlacLord™]

Neither of them have pre-cog. Sharingan allows reactions based on the most minute movements but it's not pre cog. Pre cog by definition means knowing before it happens, Sharingan needs to have the motion start before it can begin tracking the trajectory or motion therefore by definition it is not pre cog.

"knowledge of a future event or situation, especially through extrasensory means."

The Sharingan does exactly this. It shows the user the opponent's next move before it's took place.

 

[House]

But you need pre-cog to dodge if you're not fast enough. Especially in H2H.

But that doesn't mean he has pre-cog. He's just not fast enough.

 

[Seventh Sama]

iirc byakugan can track a targets movement or something like that.

 

[chopstickchakra]

"knowledge of a future event or situation, especially through extrasensory means."

The Sharingan does exactly this. It shows the user the opponent's next move before it's took place.

No it doesn't. Keyword is future. Sharingan can't know where an attack will end until it begins. There is not a single panel that shows prediction of an attack before it's started, there is only reaction to a motion. extra-sensory means beyond the senses, sharingan uses it's acute sight to predict where the attack will end once it begins.

If a sharingan user walks into a fight he doesn't know what the first throw is going to be until the second it starts, if it had pre cog he would know the attack before he ever set foot on the battle field.

 

[The Demon Hawk]

If they both do, which is superior?

Neither the Byakugan nor 1T Sharingan have precognition.

If not, which one is more capable of predicting movement in CQC?

1T Sharingan.

I know Neji has no blind spot, so he must be able to predict an enemies movements very well in CQC. I also know from the Sasuke vs Lee fight that his sharingan could keep up with Lee's fast taijutsu trained movements. Who predicts (keeps up with movements) better?

Definitely Sasuke. Sasuke could see Lee's moves ahead. Neji only had the advantage due to broadened vision.

 

[Nick01]

Byakugan>>>>>>>>1 Tomoe.

 

[Magnolius]

Neither the Byakugan nor 1T Sharingan have precognition.



1T Sharingan.



Definitely Sasuke. Sasuke could see Lee's moves ahead. Neji only had the advantage due to broadened vision.

Thank you :sdo:

 

[BenjerminGaye]

If they both do, which is superior? If not, which one is more capable of predicting movement in CQC? I know Neji has no blind spot, so he must be able to predict an enemies movements very well in CQC. I also know from the Sasuke vs Lee fight that his sharingan could keep up with Lee's fast taijutsu trained movements. Who predicts (keeps up with movements) better?

Neither have precognition. You dont get precog until the 3rd tome.

 

[unknownvillain1254]

If they both do, which is superior? If not, which one is more capable of predicting movement in CQC? I know Neji has no blind spot, so he must be able to predict an enemies movements very well in CQC. I also know from the Sasuke vs Lee fight that his sharingan could keep up with Lee's fast taijutsu trained movements. Who predicts (keeps up with movements) better?

The byakugan have high speed tracking no pre cog but sharingan can be thrown for a loop by doing faints in battle


It dose have this

combat, this allows them to see fast-moving objects and, once fully developed, offers some amount of predictive capabilities: they can anticipate an opponent's next move based on the slightest muscle tension in their body and act accordingly to dodge

 

[The Demon Hawk]

Thank you :sdo:

Any time.

 

[BenjerminGaye]

The byakugan have high speed tracking no pre cog but sharingan can be thrown for a loop by doing faints in battle


It dose have this

combat, this allows them to see fast-moving objects and, once fully developed, offers some amount of predictive capabilities: they can anticipate an opponent's next move based on the slightest muscle tension in their body and act accordingly to dodge

Scans of byakugan actually doing that. Cuz there's a difference between the user making a logical assumption of what's going to happen next and the eyes themselves showing you what's going to happen next.

 

[Silent Hero]

Byakugan has no pre-cog at all, and Sharingan stomps in combat prediction. Byakugan might have a broader range but it doesn't at all help the user predict movements.

Also, Sharingan doesn't allow the user to see into the future and see what is going to happen next. The eyes merely catch every single detail, like the slightest twitch of a muscle, which allows the user to make a logical outcome of what the next move might be. While fairly accurate, it isn't going to show them exactly what is happening next; they just catch the most finite of details... not see into the future.

 

[super yang]

byakugan- has manual ''precognition'' of ninjutsu & genjutsu

3-tomoe sharingan- has automatic ''precognition'' of ninjutsu, genjutsu, taijutsu, handseals, optic perception & locomotion of tangible/physical objects

3-tomoe sharingan- can see the external aura of chakra, chakra color & chakra flow thru the eyes when detecting genjutsu

byakugan- can see the external aura of chakra, infrared, x-ray, telescopic, binocular/360, microscopic, internal chakra flow, chakra color & genjutsu tangibly

 

[BlacLord™]

No it doesn't. Keyword is future. Sharingan can't know where an attack will end until it begins. There is not a single panel that shows prediction of an attack before it's started, there is only reaction to a motion. extra-sensory means beyond the senses, sharingan uses it's acute sight to predict where the attack will end once it begins.

If a sharingan user walks into a fight he doesn't know what the first throw is going to be until the second it starts, if it had pre cog he would know the attack before he ever set foot on the battle field.

You can't just change the definition of a word to suit you. Precognition is knowing the opponent's next move before he's made it, whether that be 1, 5 or 10 moves.

That's exactly what the Sharingan does.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Scooby Doo]

I know Neji has no blind spot,

Neji does have a blindspot though ( ._.)

You can't just change the definition of a word to suit you. Precognition is knowing the opponent's next move before he's made it, whether that be 1, 5 or 10 moves.

That's exactly what the Sharingan does.

You must be registered for see images

I think both of you are right xd Yes Sasuke could see Naruto's next move so you can call it precog, but it's also true that the sharingan can foresee the next move only based on a previous move (in this case, Naruto was already in motion). So if Naruto just stood in one place, without moving an inch, I guess especially in sage mode preparation of which requires stillness, the sharingan could see the chakra building up, but it wouldn't be able to predict the specific movement...as there is no motion at all. But yeah once in motion, the sharingan foresees the next movement and I guess that can be called precog.