Why waiting, ok
In our previous debate I never considered Boruto filler anime as part of canon story. But I changed my stance over anime after reading and understand many informations and explanation given by people.
To my understanding All Boruto Novels are the adaptation of anime story and not starting as stand alone novel first.
Light Novels
Novels in the
Boruto: Naruto Next Generations
Parts of the Boruto: Naruto Next Generations anime have been been adapted into a novel series titled Boruto: Naruto Next Generations Novel (BORUTO -ボルト- -NARUTO NEXT GENERATIONS- NOVEL, Boruto: Naruto Nekusuto Jenerēshonzu Noberu). The first novel was released on May 2, 2017 and covers episodes 1 to 6.
So they are clearly in different position compared to Naruto era Novels and Retsudens.
I accepted Sarada feat in Sasuke Shinden because manga finally addressed it and my acceptance of Anime story.
Only Novel I'm opposed now except the confirmed one.
It because I've read the Retsuden that's why I know when it happened.
My previous post already mentioned it;
I just read until 7 chapters of that novel. Nothing interesting. Just a journey to find a cure of illness that feels like a fanfiction.
An example of simple conversation that you can have in the manga talking about this illness and at the same time inform the reader.
~~~~
Naruto:"Thanks again Sasuke for finding the cure of my illness that time"
Sasuke:"It's not a big deal. You're my best friend afterall"
~~~~~
Of course you can be more dramatic than that. But the idea here, this simple conversation is enough to canonized Sasuke Retsuden.
No more excuses.
Do you have imagination Rasta?
Yeah I'M waiting for the Retsuden to be animated or addressed in manga first, whatever is first. Until then its non canon. Simple
If manga addressed it or Anime animated the Novel that's my entire point.
The problem is, you don't understand me.
I can't say that Ferrari car in the showroom is yours when you not yet buying it. Until you buy the car.
The novel is not an adaptation of Naruto manga story in between the story progression like Boruto Novels. Its all happened after the main story has ended. Blank period is technically is like a great fanfiction section. Made matter worse there's no follow up by Boruto: the next generation. Most of the Novels were left standing alone. Not part of continued story.
It came from the established fictional series but the medium of writing is not. Manga, novel. Coming from same series not mean much when there's no real connection between the two story from two different medium of writing. Do you already forgot that Naruto entire story is not a planned out story like OP for example. A disconnected story will exist.
There's couple of points from Sakura's hiden that can be use to establish the connection with Boruto storyline;
1) Sasuke imposter(Kaido)
2) Kaido
The manga idea is that Sakura tells Sasuke the brief story how she confronted with Sasuke imposter(Kido) and defeat him and Sasuke compliment her. If not in the manga, do it in anime.
And your examples here are mostly coming from Boruto era Novels hahaha...
You couldn't say I'm contradicting myself when I already accepting anime canonity.
In our previous debate I'm still not open to the idea of canon Boruto Anime story.
It needs to be selected because not all novels are canon.Yes I’m generalizing based on the fact of them being canon and how each of them connect to the manga/overall plot. You selectively read a lot, I never just referenced one novel but instead more then one.
In our previous debate I never considered Boruto filler anime as part of canon story. But I changed my stance over anime after reading and understand many informations and explanation given by people.
To my understanding All Boruto Novels are the adaptation of anime story and not starting as stand alone novel first.
You must be registered for see links
Light Novels
Novels in the
You must be registered for see links
and
You must be registered for see links
series are officially published short stories either by the author
You must be registered for see links
or a third party, with Kishimoto's supervision.Boruto: Naruto Next Generations
Parts of the Boruto: Naruto Next Generations anime have been been adapted into a novel series titled Boruto: Naruto Next Generations Novel (BORUTO -ボルト- -NARUTO NEXT GENERATIONS- NOVEL, Boruto: Naruto Nekusuto Jenerēshonzu Noberu). The first novel was released on May 2, 2017 and covers episodes 1 to 6.
You must be registered for see links
The second novel was released on July 4, a third novel was released on September 4,
You must be registered for see links
and a fourth novel in November 2017. The fifth novel was released on January 4, 2018.So they are clearly in different position compared to Naruto era Novels and Retsudens.
Please understand my point and line of thinking first Rasta. This is where you always failed. You don't understand my subject, objective and line of thought. I understand you but can't say the same for you.But your questions about the validity of the novels doesn’t reflect you having gathered information about them. Your very much all over the place honestly, you’ve dead ass said that you would accepted Sarada’s novel development but not Sakura’s when both are written in the same pretense.
I accepted Sarada feat in Sasuke Shinden because manga finally addressed it and my acceptance of Anime story.
Only Novel I'm opposed now except the confirmed one.
Already touched and addressed that Retsuden. I see you didn't addressed the whole post hahaha...No.. Sasuke Retsuden takes place during two time periods, after the 4th shinobi war and during The Brouto Generations eras. The book jumps between time periods and you would know that if actually read the novels instead of relying on second hand information.
It because I've read the Retsuden that's why I know when it happened.
My previous post already mentioned it;
And then we have Retsuden. 2 Novels. Taking place long after the ending of 4th Shinobi World war. The strange one's Sasuke Retsuden.
SASUKE RETSUDEN
Why? It because it all happened in Boruto era. Sarada was already born at that time(Iruka watched over her) which means Boruto also. The strange part is when the story told us that Naruto get an illness that not even Kurama can cured. But there is no where in Boruto manga they talked about this illness. Like it never existed at all. And this is the same Novel that talked about Sakura's new sensory ability lol, chapter 3.
SASUKE RETSUDEN
Why? It because it all happened in Boruto era. Sarada was already born at that time(Iruka watched over her) which means Boruto also. The strange part is when the story told us that Naruto get an illness that not even Kurama can cured. But there is no where in Boruto manga they talked about this illness. Like it never existed at all. And this is the same Novel that talked about Sakura's new sensory ability lol, chapter 3.
I just read until 7 chapters of that novel. Nothing interesting. Just a journey to find a cure of illness that feels like a fanfiction.
Because manga never talked about it even a simple flashback or simple body of statement that talking about Naruto's past illness in the Novel. I guess Naruto suffered this illness before Momoshiki arcHow’s that strange?
An example of simple conversation that you can have in the manga talking about this illness and at the same time inform the reader.
~~~~
Naruto:"Thanks again Sasuke for finding the cure of my illness that time"
Sasuke:"It's not a big deal. You're my best friend afterall"
~~~~~
Of course you can be more dramatic than that. But the idea here, this simple conversation is enough to canonized Sasuke Retsuden.
No more excuses.
Do you have imagination Rasta?
READ ABOVE POST YOUNGLING.Naruto’s illness not being a topic on the manga because it has to reason to be referenced doesn’t mean it’s not cannon. The Boruto manga doesn’t have to squeeze entire cononized events into 40 picture panels for them to be actuality.
And rn Kodachi is in charge of writing Boruto m8. Don't be dumb. Kishimoto was focusing on S8. Novel canonicity to manga + anime story is in the hand of Kodachi.How can I say that? Because they were both written by the same an author who’s work was approved by Kishi just as the previous novels. That’s the suggestion your looking for and you know Sasuke Retsuden is possibly being animated right?
You must be registered for see images
What’s going to be your excuse then? Lol
Yeah I'M waiting for the Retsuden to be animated or addressed in manga first, whatever is first. Until then its non canon. Simple
If manga addressed it or Anime animated the Novel that's my entire point.
The problem is, you don't understand me.
I can't say that Ferrari car in the showroom is yours when you not yet buying it. Until you buy the car.
Because Sakura's novel is yet to establish any connection with Boruto manga or Anime. One stayed in the blank period, not moving forward. The other one technically all about her feat stuck inside not yet canon Sasuke Retsuden.Because the novel in which it takes place is conon.. are you serious right now? Or just blowing hot air? Sasuke teaching Sarada Katon in the novel is cannon; right? Why is that conon and not Sakura’s novel not?
The novel is not an adaptation of Naruto manga story in between the story progression like Boruto Novels. Its all happened after the main story has ended. Blank period is technically is like a great fanfiction section. Made matter worse there's no follow up by Boruto: the next generation. Most of the Novels were left standing alone. Not part of continued story.
You sure need to work your brain. Less putting non sense words.No your not being ration or logical.. you just said that you’ll count Sarada’s novel feats but not Sakura’s when both belong to the same series and approved identically.
It came from the established fictional series but the medium of writing is not. Manga, novel. Coming from same series not mean much when there's no real connection between the two story from two different medium of writing. Do you already forgot that Naruto entire story is not a planned out story like OP for example. A disconnected story will exist.
There's couple of points from Sakura's hiden that can be use to establish the connection with Boruto storyline;
1) Sasuke imposter(Kaido)
2) Kaido
The manga idea is that Sakura tells Sasuke the brief story how she confronted with Sasuke imposter(Kido) and defeat him and Sasuke compliment her. If not in the manga, do it in anime.
As I said before I have started to accept anime as Canon. So why I should feel embarrass. LolStop embarrassing yourself. The manga or anime isn’t aware of the novels story telling?
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
ALL OF THOSE THINGS IN THE SERIES OF NOVELS HAVE BEEN CONTINGENT WITH THE ANIME.. SO YES, THE ANIME IS AWARE OF THE NOVELS PLOT! ,
And your examples here are mostly coming from Boruto era Novels hahaha...
Post automatically merged:
That was before, in that thread but not today, in this thread.This is cherry picking.
You must be registered for see images
But what’s more laughable is how your contradicting yourself and trying to walk back the things you said before lol.. the novels weren’t canon remember?
You must be registered for see images
But their canon now just for Sarada right?
You couldn't say I'm contradicting myself when I already accepting anime canonity.
In our previous debate I'm still not open to the idea of canon Boruto Anime story.
I know what I'm talking about. Sakura hiden and Sasuke Retsuden are not yet canon. Majority of blank period Novels.The connection isn’t lost, you would know that if you read the novels or at least knew what your talking about.
All this just a body of Words that had no meaning.Your inability to comprehend the pretext of the novels and validate the novels connected CONSISTENCIES to the manga/anime YOURSELF is what doesn’t make sense. I just gave you over 5 examples above...
Last edited: