~Declined~ Gaara (我愛羅)

[Ragnaroc]

Re: Gaara (我愛羅)

Dr Musa is correct in his response as to why mud can not be controlled the same way as sand can be controlled.

plus imo Gaara's ability to use sand like he can is almost like a KG, whether its because of him having a bijuu or not, it has been shown in the manga that he can use sand without his bijuu thus imo sand should be treated as a Gaara only KG.

plus unless its stated that the Mud CE can be used like Sand, it can not be used as sand and should not be allowed to be used like Sand and its abilities.

and Eddy, if i see another out burst like earlier, there will be consequences, Emp is in charge of the Bijuus and the Bios and while debate is accepted, outburst like that are not allowed and will not be tolerated inside the Naruto RP.

 

[Ragnaroc]

Re: Gaara (我愛羅)

I only use it once after someone has try to use a water jutsu to destroy my sand which create mud.

last i checked, mud is a combination of earth and water, not sand and water...water and sand would make a different CE

 

[Shig]

Re: Gaara (我愛羅)

last i checked, mud is a combination of earth and water, not sand and water...water and sand would make a different CE

Water and sand ain't mud, I'll give you that. U_U

Eddy-kun, did you ever go seaside? :| You kinda see "mud" there.

 

[Deidara...]

Re: Gaara (我愛羅)

1 : a slimy sticky mixture of solid material with a liquid and especially water; especially : soft wet earth

thats Merriam Websters definition of mud.

sand = a solid and a type of earth as it is a sediment

so its only logical that when you add water you get a type of mud.

common soil and water is not the only kind of mud

clay and water make mud as well, along with any granular sediment and water.

even cement is considered a kind of mud

 

[Shig]

Re: Gaara (我愛羅)

1 : a slimy sticky mixture of solid material with a liquid and especially water; especially : soft wet earth

thats Merriam Websters definition of mud.

sand = a solid and a type of earth as it is a sediment

so its only logical that when you add water you get a type of mud.

common soil and water is not the only kind of mud

clay and water make mud as well, along with any granular sediment and water.

even cement is considered a kind of mud

Dude. :| It turns the sand into a weird "mud" that doesn't have sand granules anymore. Emp specified that it's okay if it's a CE, but GAARA could not control wet sand, fact, period.

 

[Xylon]

Re: Gaara (我愛羅)

Go to the nearest kinder garden, and splash a bucket of water over the sand box O_O
see if you can find mud?
Sand;

You must be registered for see links

clearly they aren't earth particles just a collection of minute minerals, where as mud is would generally require dirt, dust, or soil. Mix up sand an water and you can see that sand particles would settle down after a while

 

[Ragnaroc]

Re: Gaara (我愛羅)

1 : a slimy sticky mixture of solid material with a liquid and especially water; especially : soft wet earth

thats Merriam Websters definition of mud.

sand = a solid and a type of earth as it is a sediment

so its only logical that when you add water you get a type of mud.

common soil and water is not the only kind of mud

clay and water make mud as well, along with any granular sediment and water.

even cement is considered a kind of mud

thats the websters dictionary, but for the CE that Eddy wants to use is parts earth and water, not sand and water which negates the example that eddy used to show that he can control the mud like the sand.

as far as I'm concerned this discussion is closed and shall only be posted in my Eddy, and the RP mods.

 

[Emperor]

Re: Gaara (我愛羅)

thats the websters dictionary, but for the CE that Eddy wants to use is parts earth and water, not sand and water which negates the example that eddy used to show that he can control the mud like the sand.

as far as I'm concerned this discussion is closed and shall only be posted in my Eddy, and the RP mods.

Let me edit that, Raggy.

This discussion is closed.
Eddy-kun has one chance to remove the Mud control from his bio. If he argues, or refuses to, this bio will be declined.

Anyone else posting about this issue, unless it is a mod, will be infracted.

 

[Emperor]

Re: Gaara (我愛羅)

Btw, eddy, could you do so quickly, please ?
Otherwise this will remain pending and no one else will be able to apply for the One Tails, which will be unfair.

I understand you may be busy with RL, so I'll give you two weeks from the time I first asked you to remove it. If you will be busy for more time, please tell me so I can extend the time limit. :|

 

[Emperor]

Re: Gaara (我愛羅)

Thank you eddy, for being reasonable.
I will make the fight thread now.