DBZ vs Naruto?

Which is Greater?


  • Total voters
    38

VongolaX

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 28, 2012
Messages
17,132
Reaction score
630
whats blowing up a planet got to do with anything and who really gives a crap in the end of the day there is barely a story to dbz and each arc is a reboot of the previous arc as everyone dies then wish them back and start all over again

well look at it this way, without dbz, most OP naruto chararcters would not exist. In fact the fighting style would be horrible and the s06p techniques some wouldn't exist like CT moon creator= powerball vegeta's tech to turn to great ape and shinra tensei= weaker form of kiai cannon attack etc.
 

Kurama2012

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jan 8, 2012
Messages
4,736
Reaction score
205
well look at it this way, without dbz, most OP naruto chararcters would not exist. In fact the fighting style would be horrible and the s06p techniques some wouldn't exist like CT moon creator= powerball vegeta's tech to turn to great ape and shinra tensei= weaker form of kiai cannon attack etc.

my god naruto is not only influenced from dbz you need to get this out of your head yes kishi is influenced by toriyama as well many others like yu yu hakusho and akira and you can not know for sure the stuff you say is true

also the only argument you have for dbz being the greatest anime/manga ever is the fact that its a big influence but that alone does not make it the best manga/anime ever as there are a many series out there that are better

ask yourself this what makes dbz's plot development, character development superior to every manga/anime series huh and im not saying narutos is the best but it is better then dbz
 

Saiyan Kammy

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Dec 30, 2008
Messages
26,602
Reaction score
162
Dragon Ball/Z will always be the greatest Anime and Manga of all time. Naruto should not even be compared to the Legendary franchise.
 

CrimsonFire

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
4,512
Reaction score
76
Dbz----->Naruto

Shoot, Yamcha can solo the Naruto universe.
 

7th Biggest OP Fan

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Dec 21, 2012
Messages
1,370
Reaction score
189
Awwww, I missed a great thread like this. Stupid sleep. Seriously though, it is peoples opinion of what is better. That's it. My opinion, it's like comparing turd sandwich with barf soup. They are both "food" but one you use your hands, one you use silverware. They are different types of "food", but in reality, they are both horrible (ok maybe I'm being a bit harsh). I can name at least half a dozen animes that are better then both of them though(again my opinion which many would agree with).

So why are they being compared if they are so different?

Idk really. People like them for different reasons. DBZ had the best market opportunity however. I was in 3rd grade when Toonami came on the air and showing DBZ. It was new, it was different, and it was bad ass. It was up there with video games being awesome. I would come home from school and watch it every day. I thought nothing could ever beat it. It even had the stats to back it up being great. This was because it was one of the first animes that got introduced world wide and the marketing people knew how to make it great. Yes, advertising was the biggest thing for DBZ's popularity. I bet when people first watched DBZ, it wasn't because they thought the first part was so good they had to watch the 2nd part. Hell, people never even knew the 1st part even existed until later. It was because they had awesome powers and blew up sh!t. This was what attracted kids to watch the show. Nothing else on tv was doing that. Anime back then wasn't about having a good story line or character development, or romance. It was about making things go boom, and DBZ was great at it. We got chills from when they powered up and finally beat the crap out of their enemy. It wasn't because Goku died episode 3 or Krillin died to help Goku fuel his rage to become a SSJ. Deaths weren't the main focus in DBZ as to why people liked it. Comparing deaths in DBZ to Naruto is meaningless. Naruto, they have a meaning. It is to help the story line. DBZ, it doesn't matter because they will get revived. That's not what the story is about, and why DBZ is good.

Of course DBZ became a pioneer for other animes to go global. Other mangaka's were influenced by DBZ. NOTE: DBZ is not the only thing that influences other mangaka. They get their influence from other places as well. DBZ got it's influence from earlier animes that didn't get much influence as DBZ. Even One Piece got its influence from other places. The character Franky was based off of a character Jim Carry played in Ace Ventura. Naruto got some of its influence from Japanese folk tales. Goku was based off of a chineese monkey named Sun Wukong. Who cares where the influence came from. What matters is how much you like the mangaka's work.

How did Naruto become so popular? After DBZ finished, people were waiting for the next biggest thing. Ninjas! People were always interested in ninjas and Naruto fit into the slot of filling our ninja craving. Everyone interested in anime wanted to get into Naruto because of the ninja theme. When I first watched it I was like, this is awesome. Blowing up sh!t wasn't that big of a deal then. It was finding out if Naruto would become Hokage and us "believing it!" The story became the main focus in anime. This became the new trend for anime. Of course other animes not as popular were doing this also, but Naruto got the recognition because it was the most popular at its time. Now Naruto has a half way decent story line and blowing up stuff. Deaths are becoming less meaningful, minus meaningful deaths that were to enhance the story line where people weren't revived, but it was all to make the story great.

As you can see, they both became popular for different reasons and had different opportunities for that popularity. Switch the roles around and neither would have been as popular. Of course most people here think popularity is everything and whichever is more popular is the better anime. The truth is, popularity means ****. Let me name a few things that are popular here in the U.S. Ready? Justin Bieber, One Direction, Lady Gaga, Nicki Minaj, and *shivers* Ke$ha. Back in the 90's we had Insync, Backstreet Boys, Britney Spears, and a bunch of other stuff. Guess what, people like this stuff. They liked it back then too. It sells, specially to tween girls who fall in love with them and are easily influenced. Others hate it. Even with such a split in opinions, it is still popular regardless of what you think. Want to know a secret? what they sing about worked in the 60's too. We got boy bands back then talking about how they "Want to hold your hand." Later they changed their image singing about LSD (Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds). Justin Bieber is doing the same thing (changing his image that is). It's not just coincidence, its what sells.

Now what about quality? Quality is something everyone likes and all think its great. How great is what quality is. Anyone who has read One Piece, FMAB, Code Geass, Samurai Champloo, Death Note, Eureka 7, etc, etc... They are not as Popular as DBZ and Naruto world wide, but they are SOOOOOO much better in quality. If all you have read is Naruto and DBZ, it is sad. There is so much better stuff out there you are missing out on, and they don't defend how great it is because it is popular. They defend it on the quality that it produces. Of course some animes listed above have both which shows how truly amazing they are. Me personally, I care about character development and the story more then who can make a bigger explosion. This is because I have grown up and want more then explosions. Peoples opinions can change. They might like DBZ now and Naruto later. It could be the opposite. They could like something completely different later. Arguing about opinions is dumb, specially when why the opinions of the anime they like are for different reasons. Trying to prove who's opinion is more right is even more dumb. I can say they are both bad and go watch something else, doesn't mean you have to. You may like to just watch what is popular only.


Now for my opinion on which is better. stfu and just enjoy both.
/thread
 

Miles vi Britannia

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Dec 31, 2012
Messages
543
Reaction score
52
Dragonball and DBZ for sure ..... Dragonball series is much better than anyother series i've ever read...

and people who say DBZ didn't have character depth, story was predictable etc.... are you f**king kidding me

Dragonball started as a martial arts manga with magic fantasy -> Aliens with radits,vegeta,freeza then -> Android Si-Fi with cell -> back to magic fantasy Buu ........are you guys saying you were able to predict all these things the first time you read it when the series was still coming :|

name me any other manga which combines 3 or 4 separate main genre into a single manga and made it epic beyond imagination

now DBZ may seem predictable bcos you have already seen the entire series or know the outcome for every battle..... also reading other mangas influenced by Dragonball first and reading/seeing DBZ afterward skews your perception....making you think DZB plot is predictable

is the plot of DragonBall complex-NO but that is the main plus point of DB.... anyone from 10yr old kid to 30yr old adult can understand and enjoy the manga/anime to the core .....thats why it has such an influence

another epic thing about DB is it influenced an entire generation of manga writers...
even naruto's character influenced by Goku character design

Goku and Naruto - wears orange and blue outfit ,protects their friend, goofy ,eats a lot , but when it comes to fights they knows what to do, doesnt start the fight and always held back in some training/injury so the friends buy them time then they comes and beat the sh!t out of main villan in the arc/saga, but isn't ruthless with the power and doesn't try kill everyone he fights

Vegeta and Sasuke- wears white and violet outfit, arrogant, both everyone in their clan/planet killed off except a select few,proud of their lineage, rivel to the main character, but main character tried to treats them as friends ,ruthless, kills even their comrade.

so bear this in mind before saying DB is bad/inferior to naruto
without Dragonball there wont be naruto

Sure the elements and focuses of the story changed over time, but that doesn't change the point. In the end, all the villains were pretty much just jerks who had a bone to pick with Earth or the good guys FROM Earth and thus had some obsession with blowing up the planet. Except for I guess Buu, who was a mindless berserker who, well, wanted to destroy the planet as well. If you wanna talk about evolving stories then JoJo's Bizarre Adventure is a MUCH greater example. From part 1 to part 6 the only way you could see the connections is through the art style (which even then developed dramatically) and through Dio's existence. Dragon Ball Z, yeah sure the species/types of enemies changed but in terms of story and the villains themselves nothing ever changed. Frieza was a pretty shallow villain, Cell was a pretty shallow villain, and to be frank Buu was even worse than those. You could always, always predict how things would go in the end because that's the type of manga it is. You could say the same about Naruto in a way but at least Naruto has more variety in the long run with its plot.

3/4 more genres that made things epic beyond imagination? Um, 20th Century Boys? Fullmetal Alchemist? How about Future Diary which has action, drama, horror, psychological, romance, AND thriller genres all as pretty important factors of the story? Dragon Ball Z's genres are pretty much restricted to the action/adventure and MAYBE comedy if you account for part 1 and a little bit of Z. But that's about it. DBZ is not bursting with many genres if that's honestly what you're claiming.

And yeah DBZ is a very accessible series and that's its appeal. But that's also the reason why it's not really THAT great plotwise. You can jump in anywhere BECAUSE it's a very repetitive, simplistic story that's pretty much solely about the action. It doesn't offer much character development or story depth because then people would have to follow from episode 1 and let's face it: People are lazy and that's why it's so easy to get into Z. Does that make it a top tier series? I can't say so.

It's obvious that Naruto takes elements from DBZ. And? Overall it takes what's good about it and makes it better. Characters, story, emotional value, everything about it is just better in the long run. Saying that something's better BECAUSE it's original is a bad, bad argument. Kanon and Air preceded Clannad yet a vast majority of the Key fanbase would agree that Clannad is superior to both of those. It's a matter of development and taking what works along with new ideas.

Dragon Ball Z is the GREATEST CREATION OF MANKIND!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I wouldn't go that far. DBZ is overshadowed by oh so many animes in terms of quality as far as I can tell.

that is ur opinion. I love DBZ but its old. For naruto, i love to watch it but too much filler.. and too much flashback it getting me tired of it.. yes dbz always keep people back to life because its what "dragon ball" is about.. when i watch it made me exciting and so colourful also so dreamful like when u dead u go to other world.. naruto sort of boring like on the planet earth that all.. naruto is just stop the enemies, save sasuke and some of funny.. not many plot same for dbz.. dbz have many characters who are not came back.. they are too differemt to compare.. i will go for dbz because their filler is great and not much of flash back that all

one peice is the crappest ever i have seen..

It is my opinion but the problem is that most people seem to ride on nostalgia to claim that DBZ is "the best anime ever." Again, filler doesn't concern me because I read the manga for both of them. And flashbacks can get excessive with Naruto but that's where character development is, something that DBZ is very lacking in. And it's not bad that DBZ brings people back to life, it's that they find loopholes to do this for characters who become completely unimportant in the next arc. It's pointless and they go the extra mile to break the established rules to bring people back because it's a Shounen and Shounen are happy rainbow and bunny stories where good guys always win. And I hope you aren't honestly claiming Naruto's plot is as repetitive as DBZ's "Enemy comes to Earth, good guys fight them off, some people die and they get the Dragon Balls to bring them back. Rinse and repeat" plot.

One Piece is the crappiest you have ever seen? I bet you have never even taken the time to watch/read One Piece. As a story? One Piece utterly CRAPS on either Naruto or DBZ. The adventure element is much more compelling, EVERY important character gets great development, the action doesn't feel so cliche, and overall it's just a damn good series. It IS true that One Piece rarely kills important characters. But when it does? Oh you can feel it. The climax of One Piece is superior to Naruto or DB in practically every way and the deaths that took place hit me much harder than ANY event in either Naruto or DBZ.

DBZ started blowing up planets since episode 0, while where close to the end of naruto and all we seen is someone blowing up a country with the worlds strongest beast. dbz>>>onepiece>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>naruto

Well strengthwise that's true but I don't think that's the topic at hand here.

Otherwise Gurren Lagann solos all of those.

well look at it this way, without dbz, most OP naruto chararcters would not exist. In fact the fighting style would be horrible and the s06p techniques some wouldn't exist like CT moon creator= powerball vegeta's tech to turn to great ape and shinra tensei= weaker form of kiai cannon attack etc.

I hope you realize that the examples you gave hardly correspond at all. Chibaku Tensei is a giant gravitational ball that takes in everything around it. Vegeta's powerball was a glowing energy orb (or something of the sort) that was meant to be a makeshift moon so he could transform, nothing alike.

Shinra Tensei is only similar to that at face value. And if you wanna get into specifics then DBZ did not make that original, attacks of that sort have been around for a while now.

Dragon Ball/Z will always be the greatest Anime and Manga of all time. Naruto should not even be compared to the Legendary franchise.

Greater than 20th Century Boys? Greater than Gurren Lagann? Greater than Fullmetal Alchemist? Greater than Code Geass? Greater than Clannad? Greater than Future Diary?

Sorry but I can't agree on that at all. As a plot even Naruto is superior, DBZ is far below even more series out there. I know people have their opinions but objectively speaking DBZ is by no means "the greatest anime/manga of all time." It's just not amazing enough to deserve such a great title.
 

Saiyan Kammy

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Dec 30, 2008
Messages
26,602
Reaction score
162
[/QUOTE]Greater than 20th Century Boys? Greater than Gurren Lagann? Greater than Fullmetal Alchemist? Greater than Code Geass? Greater than Clannad? Greater than Future Diary?

Sorry but I can't agree on that at all. As a plot even Naruto is superior, DBZ is far below even more series out there. I know people have their opinions but objectively speaking DBZ is by no means "the greatest anime/manga of all time." It's just not amazing enough to deserve such a great title.[/QUOTE]

Like you said everyone has there own opinions. I strongly disagree with you. Don't explain nothing to me as you will never change my opinion. It's pointless explaining because it all comes down to opinion and preference. Don't waste your time.
 
Last edited:

Miles vi Britannia

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Dec 31, 2012
Messages
543
Reaction score
52
Like you said everyone has there own opinions. I strongly disagree with you. Don't explain nothing to me as you will never change my opinion. It's pointless explaining because it all comes down to opinion and preference. Don't waste your time.

Opinions will be opinions but throwing out "greatest anime ever" is seriously jumping the gun. It's one thing if DBZ is your favorite but it is impossible to declare ANYTHING the "greatest anime ever" by virtue of the fact that, for one, you could not possibly have seen every anime that has been created to this day, and secondly you cannot account for anime of the future. The phrase bugs me to no end because it's not only completely opinionated but can never, ever be true. Nothing can be "the greatest anime ever," though it can be debated how good a series is through its overall quality such as plot, characters, emotional impact, etc.

And sadly to say there are many other series I've encountered that surpass DBZ in all of those. DBZ is good fun but as a story there isn't much objectively fantastic about it. If you like its style that's your thing but unless you can explain why DBZ is truly a masterpiece, I'd suggest you don't throw around the notion that it's "the greatest anime ever."
 

Narutoboss222

Banned
Regular
Joined
Dec 28, 2012
Messages
986
Reaction score
13
DBZ is the greatest anime and manga of all time. You are stupid Miles!
 

Miles vi Britannia

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Dec 31, 2012
Messages
543
Reaction score
52
DBZ is the greatest anime and manga of all time. You are stupid Miles!

So I'm stupid for having a different opinion than you, as well as actually rationalizing and explaining why I have this opinion. Meanwhile you fail to properly explain to me how you can claim that DBZ, a pretty average anime in my eyes, is the greatest anime OR manga of all time when you could not possibly have seen them all. To be frank, I'd say most people who have WOULDN'T say it's the "greatest," but in any case it's nigh impossible for anyone to see every anime made to this day. And the fact that you don't account for future anime, again, means that your claim is already invalidated.

And I suppose you probably haven't seen Fate/Zero, or Neon Genesis Evangelion, or Darker than Black, or Anohana. All of which I deem to be far superior to DBZ as stories, but at the same time none of which are even in my favorites. They're great anime no doubt, but there are others I'd deem even higher, and yet these alone provide a much more meaningful story than DBZ in probably every way, as well as having utterly fantastic character development through different aspects and methods.
 

Narutoboss222

Banned
Regular
Joined
Dec 28, 2012
Messages
986
Reaction score
13
So I'm stupid for having a different opinion than you, as well as actually rationalizing and explaining why I have this opinion. Meanwhile you fail to properly explain to me how you can claim that DBZ, a pretty average anime in my eyes, is the greatest anime OR manga of all time when you could not possibly have seen them all. To be frank, I'd say most people who have WOULDN'T say it's the "greatest," but in any case it's nigh impossible for anyone to see every anime made to this day. And the fact that you don't account for future anime, again, means that your claim is already invalidated.

And I suppose you probably haven't seen Fate/Zero, or Neon Genesis Evangelion, or Darker than Black, or Anohana. All of which I deem to be far superior to DBZ as stories, but at the same time none of which are even in my favorites. They're great anime no doubt, but there are others I'd deem even higher, and yet these alone provide a much more meaningful story than DBZ in probably every way, as well as having utterly fantastic character development through different aspects and methods.

You are just biased. You are a fanboy that prefers other Anime to the Father of all Anime. You only care about the story line in Anime and you know that DBZ story line isn't the best. The feats that DBZ has achieved has made it unsurpassable in the Anime world. You have lost this debate for the second time.
 
Joined
Jan 28, 2013
Messages
47
Reaction score
0
honestly id have to say naruto, over the years dragon ball z has become very repetitive, and the very last season GT, was an epic disappointment
 

Miles vi Britannia

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Dec 31, 2012
Messages
543
Reaction score
52
You are just biased. You are a fanboy that prefers other Anime to the Father of all Anime. You only care about the story line in Anime and you know that DBZ story line isn't the best. The feats that DBZ has achieved has made it unsurpassable in the Anime world. You have lost this debate for the second time.

So I'm a fanboy even though you can't explain what makes DBZ a good story? The father of all anime is not true at all, there are a number of other series that have come before DB. It just so happens that it's such a simplistic children's story that it happened to get popular. Your argument is like saying that Twilight is better than a number of anime series just because it has more worldwide popularity.

And yes of course I care about the storyline. Plot, character development, emotional value, are all what make something quality. Influence alone doesn't really mean in terms of a story. Children's fairy tales written long ago have influence, though it may not seem like much to the average person, and many spin-offs and alternate versions are made for them. Sure, they have had an impact on stories, and when it comes to those I'd certainly wager it's more so than Dragon Ball. But does that alone make them masterpieces? Are they thus top tier stories just because they're older, famous, and simple enough that the themes are easy to pick up on? That's a terrible, terrible argument.

Your argument is based on the idea that because a lot of people like a story, it is therefore the best. So if someone was a terrible singer, but for some reason people around the world really loved them, does that make them a revolutionary singer that's the best in the world? That's the most flawed notion I have ever seen.

Saying that DBZ has influence is one thing. But that it's "The greatest anime/manga of all time"? That is the stupidest idea by virtue of the fact that your knowledge of anime is obviously lacking. You probably have not seen any of the anime I have listed, but blindly go by the idea that because you like DBZ most, it must be the best and close your ears because you don't want to be proven wrong. And let's suppose that an anime comes along that's even more popular, but it has an even more simplistic story than DB did. Would you then say that THAT is the best anime of all time?

The fact that you're insistent on saying that I have "lost this debate" when your argument is void of any rational thought and you insist on one very one-sided notion without knowing anything about the vast anime world proves how childish you are. Someone who focuses on how they've "won the debate" is clearly not competent enough to be considered part of a debate to begin with.
 

Morgiana

Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2013
Messages
222
Reaction score
51
Gonna have to go with Naruto because it does have a better story than DBZ, that's just my opinion though. I only believe this because both One Piece and Naruto were inspired from DBZ so it's only natural that they surpass it in most aspects. Not to mention Dragon ball was created in 1984 so for a shonen of it's time I think it deserves to be considered a classic/father of all anime since it is what got me into anime.
 

Great Sage of Uchiha

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
1,653
Reaction score
124
YALL MADE ME DO THIS....Which anime is overall greater?

i think that DBZ is the greatest anime of all time and people have the audacity to argue that Naruto is better (In my opinion naruto would barely make my top 5)... WHAT!!!!

I know DBZ is an older anime and most of the kids on this Forum are to young to have watched DBZ back in its Hay day (which is truly sad). though i believe Naruto Anime was single handedly ruined by its filler arcs... i brought some collection dvds of Naruto at Wal-Mart and they were all Fillers to my surprise smh... they sucked so bad that i wanted to take a couple of the disks and rub them face down against the concrete outside... SMH

.Hack// > Zoids > DBZ [ only cause of Kid Buu] > Naruto

These is my personal opinion
 
Top