Now that's where I believe you're wrong. Anime maybe, but not manga. Naruto was one of the first manga scanned into the mainstream. Saint Seiya is as big as Dragon Ball IN JAPAN. Why do you think Namco Bandai still has games of it even if it's finished already?
And if you think I'm lying, there have been some mangas that have been scanned WAAAYYYY before Naruto did. Ever heard of Whisper of the Heart? Hareluya Boy? I'm sure you've heard of Slam Dunk. None of them catapulted the manga industry in the US to new heights, but Naruto did.
DB moments are memorable since it's all we've been exposed with when we were kids. It doesn't take a literary genius to figure out that DB was written with only action in mind, and when you compare it to today's somewhat half-assed plot progression it looks like turd. Don't get me wrong, I like DB as much as the next DB-otaku, but you have to face the truth that sometimes nostalgia goggles can only get you this far.
I'm sure OP moments will be etched in the brain of Japan for the next 20 years. It's been Shounen Jump's flagship now for 13 years; why do you think Toriyama agreed to a cross over with Oda and not Kishimoto?
Although I concede that it's been popular for the longest time already.
Right, because in the A&M world only western opinion matters? Dragon Ball is that popular today since it received a VERY GOOD DUB before some other companies butchered the succeeding titles (Martian Successor Nadesico, Dai Guard, One Piece). Naruto also received very good reception in CN and Bleach in Adult Swim. Don't peg it on being the founder of the popularity kingdom, because as far as I'm concerned Touch is as popular as DB in the Land of the Rising Sun, where it really matters.
Well, I may have messed it up a little, by at times, stating anime and manga in the same boat. But still, even if I'll agree that Naruto hugely influenced the manga culture, I still think it's mainly due to DB - even if Dragon Ball mainly influenced the world via anime. Sure, it wasn't like that in Japan but in US and mainly European countries, mangas got a better recognition due to anime. Since, DB is kinda the pioneer of all animes, it definitely made the field much easier for mangas and animes to pierce. Even helped the catapult of Naruto mangas and all other manga. I know many friends and fans of DB in childhood that may not know Naruto or One Piece but still, if I ask any fan of Naruto or One Piece, it’s kinda impossible that that person never heard of Dragon ball.
I still think that it's mostly because anime/mangas were relatively unknown in Europe and US that DB made such huge impact. Yes, action helped but we were so less in touch with other mangas that the influence of it was highly intensified. See nowadays, in a single day, you can see several awesome moments in few instances - you see an Ichigo unleashing its Bankai, then you move on to see Naruto turning into Kyuubi mode and another awesome moments in another manga ect....The impact is diminished compared to DBZ; though they are better because we are over-exposed. Impact is intensified when target is less; there are fewer chances to get diversion in views. In that way, I think it’s pretty impossible to re-iterate the influential feat that DB once done.
Sure, the OP moments are great but I'll doubt it will stay for more than 10 years in people's mind like DB. Sure OP is more original but we must consider that there are so much more expostion towards other mangas nowadays that in the times of DBZ. Also, we don't know how many more awesome manga will be released in the next 10 years. The said flagship could change hands easily but the longevity won't be given for all. In fact, longevity and influence of DBZ is unique in my eyes.
Well, it's perhaps where our views and opinions differ - you consider that Japan is where it matters but for me, popularity and influence should be determined from a global and worldwide view while the real critics and sales ratings should come from where it's been originated (Japan). Both got their places but when I talk about popularity and influence attained, I’d like it to be in a global way. In this way, I think no manga can influence and gain same popularity as well as longevity in the world as DBZ did in current time. Sure, sales/stats may state other things but in the mind of people, DBZ etched something immortal that'll live while the other mangas might not get such longevity due to over-saturation of mangas.