[Discussion] Current One Piece top 10 list?

[xcoyote]

He's Shanks' rival in swordsmanship, not their full strength. I feel like the story has made that obvious so far.

Amen.
Someone gets it.

 

[Hexuze]

He's Shanks' rival in swordsmanship, not their full strength. I feel like the story has made that obvious so far.

Thanks for the post

 

[Fireplay]

He's Shanks' rival in swordsmanship, not their full strength. I feel like the story has made that obvious so far.

Wise man...Wise man indeed. I still think Mihawk>admirals and is on par with Shanks though. Being only slightly weaker.

 

[Hijey]

He's Shanks' rival in swordsmanship, not their full strength. I feel like the story has made that obvious so far.

Which is what exactly? Beating a man in the fighting style he is strongest at using a supplement means the said strongest man at that fighting style is actually not the strongest, which is wrong.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

He's Shanks' rival in swordsmanship, not their full strength. I feel like the story has made that obvious so far.

Shanks has only fought using a sword. So Mihawk basically rivals Shanks true strength (going by your logic. So yes... you're correct). I believe he would use his true strength in order to save Coby/Stop Sakazuki (strongest Marine) or to survive a hostile encounter with Whitebeard. And he used a sword in both cases. You can't say Shanks hasn't shown his strongest fighting style (which is obviously Swordsmanship based upon my latter examples), if he used any weaker fighting style he would lose to Mihawk right away. Mihawks title means that he is regarded to be stronger than Shanks on a global scale.

 

[Lay]

My fav isn't in top 2

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

My fav isn't in top 2

Ermahgurd! "What a shame"...

 

[bajram]

It's based upon hype,logic and non Sakazuki fanboying.

I doubt Sakazuki would have fans, i think he is mostly hated he doesnt have any fanboy as far as im concerned, if the list is based on hype okay then how in the world does benn beckman is above marco and marco is on the same level of lucky roo,ur fanboyism is way beyond my understanding's.

 

[Skylar Knight]

Shanks has only fought using a sword. So Mihawk basically rivals Shanks true strength (going by your logic. So yes... you're correct). I believe he would use his true strength in order to save Coby/Stop Sakazuki (strongest Marine) or to survive a hostile encounter with Whitebeard. And he used a sword in both cases. You can't say Shanks hasn't shown his strongest fighting style (which is obviously Swordsmanship based upon my latter examples), if he used any weaker fighting style he would lose to Mihawk right away. Mihawks title means that he is regarded to be stronger than Shanks on a global scale.

If you challenge someone in arm wrestling, you only use one hand.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

I doubt Sakazuki would have fans, i think he is mostly hated he doesnt have any fanboy as far as im concerned, if the list is based on hype okay then how in the world does benn beckman is above marco and marco is on the same level of lucky roo,ur fanboyism is way beyond my understanding's.

*Looks at Bajrams avatar*
*Looks at screen*
*Chuckles*

If you challenge someone in arm wrestling, you only use one hand.

What's arm wrestling got to do with this? If you're talking about Sword vs Sword and nothing else it's still not making a difference. You clearly didn't understand my point did you? Let me go through it with you:

Shanks has only fought using a sword.

This indicates that he likes his sword and is clearly a Swordsman due to his persistent usage and dedication of said combat style, he has never been shown to use any other weapon. Meaning that Swordsmanship is most certainly how he fights. Just like Mihawk. Since Mihawk holds the title as worlds strongest swordsman, since Shanks appears to be nothing but a swordsman this hints towards Mihawks superiority in strength.

So Mihawk basically rivals Shanks true strength (going by your logic. So yes... you're correct).

Basically stop making things up and crossing your fingers and praying that Shanks can use something other than a sword. Regardless of if he can, a sword is his strongest way of fighting. So using anything weaker will obviously make him a walkover for Mihawk.

I believe he would use his true strength in order to save Coby/Stop Sakazuki (strongest Marine) or to survive a hostile encounter with Whitebeard.

We can clearly see based upon these examples that Shanks depends on swordsmanship more than anything else during combat, just like Zoro,Mihawk,Vista,Momonga... They're all swordsmen and nothing else. Stop hoping Shanks can do stuff other than Swordsmanship to such a high caliber.

And he used a sword in both cases. You can't say Shanks hasn't shown his strongest fighting style (which is obviously Swordsmanship based upon my latter examples),

Basically by this point you had been proven wrong...

if he used any weaker fighting style he would lose to Mihawk right away. Mihawks title means that he is regarded to be stronger than Shanks on a global scale.

This logic is obvious and easy to grasp. If Luffy picked up a sword and fought with it he would be weakened, because it is a weaker fighting style. Shanks is a swordsman. Simple. If he does anything else he is weaker. Mihawk holds the title of strongest so he is hyped to be stronger than Shanks.

Shanks also has a JR with two swords:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

 

[crono0929]

another one who thinks that mihawk>shanks lol.

shanks is probably the strongest person at the moment, and mihawk is not the second.

 

[bajram]

Me having an akainu avatar does not mean that i like him hes not even in my top 5 liking character's but the avatar itself i thought looked badass since my favourite one is dofla but im just saying that there is no proof for akainu to be weaker then the ppl u mentioned and is totally stupid to rank the strongest crew in the world first mate in the same rank or weaker than another normal yonko's 3rd in command that doesnt make sense.

 

[Skylar Knight]

@Rinnemaki - You're the one who don't see my point. Who is stronger between a naked man with a sword, and an armored knight with both a sword and a shield? If the naked man challenges this knight to a duel, then the latter has to throw away everything except the sword for it to be a fair fight. He doesn't attack enemies with his armor, nor does he use his shield as a weapon, but that doesn't mean they're not there when he's fighting.

 

[Hexuze]

@Rinnemaki - You're the one who don't see my point. Who is stronger between a naked man with a sword, and an armored knight with both a sword and a shield? If the naked man challenges this knight to a duel, then the latter has to throw away everything except the sword for it to be a fair fight. He doesn't attack enemies with his armor, nor does he use his shield as a weapon, but that doesn't mean they're not there when he's fighting.

Just wait till the manga debunks his theory of "Mihawk > Shanks", arguing with him will get you no where.

 

[crono0929]

Just wait till the manga debunks his theory of "Mihawk > Shanks", arguing with him will get you no where.

im waiting for the manga to debunk a lot of illogical theories as well....

BTW, Brilliant sig..

 

[Itachi4days]

We have barely seen shanks fight, yet alone go all out. To assume his swordsmanship is his only strength is ridiculous. While mihawk is only known for his swordsmanship, shanks is recognized for his incredible haki, for which we havent even seen his full Strength in yet. Therefore shanks>mihawk

Ps. Mihawk has one of the strongest swords in "Yoru" while shanks has some random sabre. Although the sword doesn't implicate strength I'm sure it factors in somewhere.

 

[David1996]

Do a top 10 of all time by the EOS.

 

[Hijey]

We have barely seen shanks fight, yet alone go all out. To assume his swordsmanship is his only strength is ridiculous. While mihawk is only known for his swordsmanship, shanks is recognized for his incredible haki, for which we havent even seen his full Strength in yet. Therefore shanks>mihawk

Ps. Mihawk has one of the strongest swords in "Yoru" while shanks has some random sabre. Although the sword doesn't implicate strength I'm sure it factors in somewhere.

Haki is not a fighting style, it's a supplement. If Shanks has no other fighting style that are better than his swordsmanship, he will be weaker than Mihawk. Therefore Mihawk>Shanks.

 

[Mephew D Kensei]

I knew this wld b another Mihawk and Shanks debate. I will just wait for when Oda reveals all but for now I think Shanks(slimly)>Mihawk.

 

[BlueToweR12]

Akainu will fist Mihawk to death. You will see... =D