Civil war greatest Marvel movie or greatest superhero movie of all time?

[Uzumaki Death god]

I mean the balance of this movie was just perfect! Believable plot, Story development, Action and the feels,"He's my friend","So was I" 10/10.

My overall favs would include
Dark night rises
First Avengers
Toby's Spider-Man franchise
X-Men: the last stand,Day's of future past & first class
Winter soldier
And all these don't even come close to Civil war.

What Do you think, greatest? and if not which is?

P.S Don't include the Very very old classics

 

[Cfighter]

Neither. I've explained my stance on this film on another thread in great detail, but essentially this film is damn near flawless on a technical level. But everything to do with the plot I thought was complete garbage - even worse, it was a giant middle finger to audiences.

Civil War was a very good action/superhero film, but it was not the best story told by Marvel by any means.

 

[Marin]

The whole DK triology beats CW to a pulp. DoFP is also better.

You could say its the best MCU movie tho.

 

[dark legion]

idk what you're saying but TDK is on top of them all.


Deadpool is better superhero movie than CW

 

[HashiraMadara]

The Dark Night and The Dark Knight Rises: soley because of Heath Ledger and Tom Hardy's Bane


In Marvel, The Winter Soldier Solos everything followed by The Avangers 1: How Marvel managed to pull out 6 heroes in 1 franchise with each one getting enough screen time and exploration

 

[Styles]

Civil war was great imo it'll be hard to top that unless xmen apocalypse have so much action a great plot and all but till then civil war hands down the best.

 

[HashiraMadara]

Civil war was great imo it'll be hard to top that unless xmen apocalypse have so much action a great plot and all but till then civil war hands down the best.

Watched X men apocalypse yesterday :| it was meh too cluttered screen with action everywhere...
They jump from slow building and talking about the war then jump into the war with no proper catalyst :|:|:|:|:|:|:|:|

 

[Styles]

Watched X men apocalypse yesterday :| it was meh too cluttered screen with action everywhere...
They jump from slow building and talking about the war then jump into the war with no proper catalyst :|:|:|:|:|:|:|:|

Come out on the 27th here I think.

 

[HashiraMadara]

Come out on the 27th here I think.

If you're a action head then you'll give it 100%.

In my case plot is way more important that's why Winter Soldier > Civil War to me who was a superhero wonderland like Batman V Superman with Antmans, Visions as passers by

 

[Uzumaki Death god]

The whole DK triology beats CW to a pulp. DoFP is also better.

You could say its the best MCU movie tho.

Dk was a bit anticlimactic for me.jokers plan was damn flawless and batman's ability to not only figure it out but also save everyone was some plot no jutsu for me and kinda ruined it for me, so it's just good.DK2 was epic though

Neither. I've explained my stance on this film on another thread in great detail, but essentially this film is damn near flawless on a technical level. But everything to do with the plot I thought was complete garbage - even worse, it was a giant middle finger to audiences.

Civil War was a very good action/superhero film, but it was not the best story told by Marvel by any means.

link me to your previous post. would like to better understand your stance

The Dark Night and The Dark Knight Rises: soley because of Heath Ledger and Tom Hardy's Bane


In Marvel, The Winter Soldier Solos everything followed by The Avangers 1: How Marvel managed to pull out 6 heroes in 1 franchise with each one getting enough screen time and exploration

Avengers was nice but for some reason am not crazy about the ending.I liked every second of CW and it also has good screen time distribution imo

 

[Uzumaki Death god]

idk what you're saying but TDK is on top of them all.


Deadpool is better superhero movie than CW

Deadpool was ayt but I wasn't emotionally pulled in like in CW cause it has heroes that we already love and are already biased towards.

 

[Uzumaki Death god]

Civil war was great imo it'll be hard to top that unless xmen apocalypse have so much action a great plot and all but till then civil war hands down the best.

My thoughts exactly.Spiderman had me like 'Woooaaaaah' lol

 

[Styles]

If you're a action head then you'll give it 100%.

In my case plot is way more important that's why Winter Soldier > Civil War to me who was a superhero wonderland like Batman V Superman with Antmans, Visions as passers by

Plot wise the only thing is didn't show was the other soldiers that was stronger than Bucky.

My thoughts exactly.Spiderman had me like 'Woooaaaaah' lol

Ikr and Antman had me like dammmnn. Lol

 

[Marin]

Dk was a bit anticlimactic for me.jokers plan was damn flawless and batman's ability to not only figure it out but also save everyone was some plot no jutsu for me and kinda ruined it for me, so it's just good.DK2 was epic though

Joker was leading Batman by his nose the whole movie (even at the end) and the only clues he left were left intentionally.

Also, he didn't save everyone. He couldn't save Rachel and he couldn't save Dent. Both being crucial for the movie. He didn't really save anyone important when you think about it.

And it's not DK2, it's DKR. (Since The Dark Knight is the second entry in the triology.)

 

[Uzumaki Death god]

Plot wise the only thing is didn't show was the other soldiers that was stronger than Bucky.

Ikr and Antman had me like dammmnn. Lol

Iron man thought that to and that's why he said "If anyone on our team is hiding any cool and powerful secret powers..." that made me lol

Joker was leading Batman by his nose the whole movie (even at the end) and the only clues he left were left intentionally.

Also, he didn't save everyone. He couldn't save Rachel and he couldn't save Dent. Both being crucial for the movie. He didn't really save anyone important when you think about it.

And it's not DK2, it's DKR. (Since The Dark Knight is the second entry in the triology.)

I wanted everyone to die though.am weird like that.
oh my bad.don't know why I even called it that

 

[Marin]

I wanted everyone to die though.am weird like that.
oh my bad.don't know why I even called it that

lol noone dies in Civil War tho. :sdo:

 

[Cfighter]

link me to your previous post. would like to better understand your stance

You must be registered for see links

My response is at like the bottom of the page

 

[~Naruto&Itachi~]

WS IMO is still the best comic book since I don't consider DK a comic book movie

 

[Uzumaki Death god]

lol noone dies in Civil War tho. :sdo:

:NO: Touché

 

[Uzumaki Death god]

You must be registered for see links

My response is at like the bottom of the page

Ok I've read it and makes a lot of sense.Am not comic book reader and so I only know bits and pieces about what civil Is about and how it but from what I read, I expected a really dark and consequential movie where extreme lines were going to be crossed.Did I expect Cap's death? not a chance but at least they could have given us something to hit us emotionally you know.Is there some sort of legal reason why Marvel didn't get some of the small scale heroes that are not owned by any major studio and include in the movie to add numbers and deaths to the movie.I mean even base introductions would have sufficed for such as they wouldn't be long term players in the grand scheme of things.And why wasn't the stark using villains aspect brought in?
All in all I think you're have a good point, this movie was way to mellow considering the title and what the original story says. But I think it's awesome if you think of it as a standalone movie but disappointing in the grand scheme of things.