Definitely sharingan. Unless we are talking about 3 tamoe vs byakugan in which case I'd say byakugan. But MS and above sharingan is a lot more powerful than a byakugan
I am going to make this brief, am not going to elaborate on every single thing i say. Everything you just said has already been said either in my previous posts to you or in the main thread. I recommend you re-read then fully rather than just skimming through and making your own opinions.Huh sigh, Kakashi said "in terms of sight the Byuugan surpasses the Sharigan". He then goes on to talk about how he can't see the inner coils that connnect the chakra points. Seeing the inner coils is essiential for using the gentle fist style. It has nothing to do with sharigan users not training their eyes sights or vice versa. For all we know they don't see to train their eye sight to see chakra networks. When Obito first unlocked his sharigan he saw the chakra network of the ninja he was fighting perfectly. The only thing they train per se is to adjust to using the sharigan to their advantage and genjutsu.
Your last point still making no sense. Sharigan users use genjutsu, ninjutsu and tai. Byakugan users only use tai. Copying abilities is not their only way of fighting. I don't know where you came up with this assumption. If your opponent is a tai specialist why engage them in tai?
What are you trying to say here? Sharingen sees movements, and since gentle fist can't be perform without the fist movement, how on earth does it best Sharingen far-superior insight into enemy movements? Sharingen will simply see all the movements and allow the use to react according.Your first point is missunderstood, what I am saying is that on top of the byakugans ability to see really far they can also see the chakra network better than the sharingan user can, and that that fact is only exemplified by the fact that the byakugan user specifically train there eyes to be able to make better use of said ability while the sharingan users eye training does not focus on being able to see the chakra network rather it focuses on taijutsu genjutsu and MS/EMS abilities. So not only does the bykugan have an advantage but the gap is widened by the byakugan user trains in seeing the chakra network while the sharingan user does not.
Your 2nd point is completely false. The Seeing far has nothing to do with the gentle fist because the gentle fist is a taijutsu technique meaning you need to be close to your opponent to use it. Kakashi cannot see the coils because sharingan users cannot see the coils, distance has nothing to do with it. Or else kakashi would have said "it is too far for me to see" instead of "even my sharingan cannot see it". Also as said before, yes, the gentle fist is a technique that only the head family is taught, but then explain how neji who is a branch family learned it? he learned it merely by WATCHING hizashi show it to hinata while he was training her. The technique isnt complicated it just requires chakra control. So with that it should not be difficult for a sharingan user to learn the technique the same way neji did WHO WAS ONLY A GENNIN AT THE TIME.
And again your completely missed my last point was that even though the sharingan users can copy jutsu it doesnt matter because the byakugan user doesnt use jutsu and so they are left relying on jutsu they already know. All the premises I talk about lead to the fact that in a fight between a sharingan user and a byakugan user it will come down to taijutsu, which is the byakugan uesrs specialty.(that is ofcourse not counting MS or susano)
The statement was made that the Sharingan can see the chakra network just as good as the Byakugan. I then said if that was true we would see Sharingan users that used the Gentle Fist Technique as Sharingan users can learn any technique just by watching it performed. Case and point Kakashi's 1000 jutsu's.What are you trying to say here? Sharingen sees movements, and since gentle fist can't be perform without the fist movement, how on earth does it best Sharingen far-superior insight into enemy movements? Sharingen will simply see all the movements and allow the use to react according.
I realize that, if you noticed the post I qouted in the post your reffering to was Dante~'s. Above that post was the response I gave to you. x__x.^ I never made any point regarding Sharingan's ability to copy techniques, but ventured that gentle fist is useless against Sharingen as it enables the user to react against high speed attacks as exhibited by Tobi/Obito as soon as he got Sharingen. His reflexes improves exponentially. That was all I was trying to say.
He also dodged Bee's V1 speed and Raikages charged armour speed effortlessly with a 3T sharingen. Remember, this was when he was still getting accustomed to Sharingen's abilities.In regards to that I would bring up Sasuke's fight against Rock Lee, remember how he got stomped with Rock Lee saying it doesnt matter if your eyes can see me, if your body cant keep up its useless. And then proceeds in stomping Sasuke.
With that same token the Sharingan only lets the Sharingan user see the attacks coming, being able to dodge them and beat the opponents taijutsu is a completely different matter.
First off you say that he was still getting used to the sharingans abilities... He had 3T back when he beat Naruto and became a rogue ninja... In all that time naruto mastered the wind rasengan and sage mode while sasuke still couldn't become accustomed to his Sharingan abilities.He also dodged Bee's V1 speed and Raikages charged armour speed effortlessly with a 3T sharingen. Remember, this was when he was still getting accustomed to Sharingen's abilities.
I won't bring Bee's battle into debate. The scan you posted was when he put his under genjutsu and thought he did the job and he turned away. He doesn't have eyes on the back of his head. so that point is moot and pointless. That scan shows Bee at V1 and he even asserts that no one has dodged it other than his brother.
Your second point is really strange. Do you even bother to read the manga? You are clearly grasping at straws now. Nice try. When one is grabbed, he should dodge? Sasuke dodged the attack and lodged his chodri attack into Raikage's chest. A Grabbed him and this is what happened. Byakugan is laughable in this department. You have been proven wrong, henceforth, end this shenanigan.
Cannot edit the main thread for some reason, perhaps this thread has run its course?Definitely sharingan. Unless we are talking about 3 tamoe vs byakugan in which case I'd say byakugan. But MS and above sharingan is a lot more powerful than a byakugan
I disagree, for one reason. Naruto, Rock Lee, Ten Ten, Sakura, all of the main AND sub characters have made considerable progress through out the series and yet during Part2 the only sub character we know to have made it to jounin level is "Neji Hyuga", who has been refered to as a genuis several times throughout the manga, similar to itachi.Byakugan could be better than sharingan.. but it doesn't really matter because every Uchiha shown so far>any byakugan or hyuuga
After reading what I had bolded you became discredited to me atleast and I stopped right there... Fruit of a poisenous tree my friend, if one part of what you say is complete horsesh-t then I am going to hold your entire paragraph long reply accountable, including the part where you show me my own scan as if you got it from somewhere else.Wrong on a few things. 1st Sasukes genjutsu was never better than ITachi's. He was just able to see throught it because of his mastery of the sharigan. While I understand your point...you're under the assumption sharigan users don't use the full extent of their eye abilities which is false. Shelke already showed you the scans, why you deny this idk?
Secondly, Stopping chakra flow is not a Byakugan trait it's the Hyuuga iron first style technique. I thought you only wanted to compare dojutu's some the clans overall abilties and such. IF thats the case the Uchihas are light years ahead in the overall shinobi department while the Hyuugas only advance in 1 area of ninja expertise while Uchihas were advanced in all areas. However it is true the sharigan can't see inner coils because they are so small.
For your third point we've already established that the sharigan can see whats going on inside a person chakra network nearly as good enough as the Byakugan. The only difference that's manga stated is the term of far sight. Sharigan has reading abilities when it comes to moves because not only can it see chakra it has all of it's other movement reading abilities as well.