Byakugan vs. Sharingan

[JTjutsumaster]

I know but against a Byakugan User, not a basic ninja. eg. Sasuke is about to use chidori; by gathering chakra into his hand, a Byakugan can already see the gathering of chakra into the hand... Same with a genjutsu, (this I'm not sure about) the Sharingan user gathers his chakra into his sharingan eyes before launching a genjutsu, a Byakugan user can see the chakra moving to the eyes, and will know when the genjutsu is in play

 

[BlackDude]

I know but against a Byakugan User, not a basic ninja. eg. Sasuke is about to use chidori; by gathering chakra into his hand, a Byakugan can already see the gathering of chakra into the hand... Same with a genjutsu, (this I'm not sure about) the Sharingan user gathers his chakra into his sharingan eyes before launching a genjutsu, a Byakugan user can see the chakra moving to the eyes, and will know when the genjutsu is in play

even so if their not fast enough to evaded it i think they are ****d
I dont think Byakugan are genjustu resistance

 

[Uchiha Riyo]

Sharingan is much more useful in a Taijutsu fight. Byakuugan lets you use moves, not see them and punch them their face in after ninja evading it.

 

[Watatsumi]

I can make 10 points or more

1. They can see chakra

The sharingan can also do that.

2. Know when jutsu's are being made because they can see the chakra gathering

Maybe, but has anyone ever done this before?

3. An almost 360 Degree view

True

4. Able to know when genjutsu's are made (I think. They are able to see the chakra in the genjutsu) Not sure about that one <---

Nope.

5. Only has a Tiny blind spot
6. 50 Meter ratio view

True, it helps in stuff like long distance vision and such.

7. Talanted at Taijutsu

Sharingan is much better at this, see points 5 and 6 that I made.

8. Ability to Block Chakra points

I agree

9. Able to Stop 8 Gate Users

The sharingan can copy their movements, and can also predict them.This means that Sharingan is more efficient in this regard.

10. Created a jutsu that blocks all jutsus (Chou Hakkeshou Kaiten) - 8 Trigrams Giant Rotation)

Kakashi used the sharingan to copy 1000 jutsus.

And because I wasnt sure about the Genjutsu one (4.) Ill put in 11

11. They created a jutsu that can push enemies far away. (Which would be pretty bad-ass if you were fighting on the edge of a cliff)

Did they use the byakugan to do that? Even if they did, sharingan has many more techniques.

The Sharingan user can Copy all but Bloodline jutsus. So you cannot copy a Hyuga technique, Rain, Crystals, Sand or any other Doujutsus

You're right.


Abilities of the sharingan:
1. The sharingan can see through chakra flow, and can distinguish chakra based on color.

2.The sharingan can see if a person is under genjutsu as the person's chakra flow would be irregular if that is the case.

3.The sharingan can read lip movements and pencil movements.

4.The sharingan can go up to it's 3 tomoe version. This is very useful, as it gives the user the ability to track movements of the opponent.

5.The attacker's next movement can be predicted accurately, and the sharingan user can dodge his attack.

6.The sharingan allows the user to copy ninjutsu, genjutsu and taijutsu with near perfect accuracy, except for Kekkei Genkai. This includes all 5 elements.

Check this out:

You must be registered for see links

7. The sharingan can be used to control beings like Kurama and Manda (through genjutsu).If you observe carefully, you'll see that their eyes took the form of the 3 tomoe sharingan, thus implying that it is an ability that is unique to the sharingan.

8. The sharingan can see through genjutsu, meaning that genjutsu won't work on the sharingan user.

9. If senju DNA is available, Izanagi can be performed with the sharingan.

10. The sharingan can evolve into MS, EMS and Rinnegan ( It may need senju DNA, or may not).

11. The sharingan increases the user's genjutsu prowess.

Please correct me if I'm wrong anywhere.

 

[Lt Iceman]

The sharingan is better in combat than the byakugan,no contest.

If i were to judge by the looks then i would still go for the Wheel eye,as crimson is my fav color.

 

[mishu90]

sharingan

 

[home]

byakugan imo

 

[sulanis]

First things first, if the creators of Naruto decided to make the Hyuga clan into the main clan against the Senju, then we would know for sure what else the byakugan can do. However, they chose the Uchiha which is cool, because we all can't deny that the Uchiha are epic. This doesn't mean the Hyuga are crap, we just haven't seen enough of them to make an informed decision like we have for the Uchiha.

I saw a post once that gave a good way of looking at it.
Byakugan = taijutsu
Sharingan = genjutsu (especially MS)
Rinne'gan = ninjutsu.

Even though Sharingan can copy ninjutsu, it’s still main focus is its illusion techniques.
With the Power of MS user can use susanoo, while ByaKugan users skilled enough can use 8 trigrams, rotation. Yes, i know that 8 trigrams was beaten, but so was susanoo by the 5 kages.

Both eyes can see and detect chakra, however in this case byakugan has the advantage because it can see chakra coming at or around the user because of the 360 degree vision. The byakugan can also detect chakra points on the body which can immobolize any if they contact the point directly. IF a hyugan strikes we see that he/she can hit 64 times almost instantly.

Byakugan Also has insight that allows the user to predict how the user is going to attack, but they have to be skilled at reading the chakra they see. Sharigan has a natural ability to do this. Kakashi states this "In terms of the ability of INSIGHT, it surpasses the sharingan." However, Sharingan can mimic and learn any ability they see (except enhanced blood line techniques) gives the Sharingan user a major advantage in any fight. (However, this was beaten by Naruto/Ninetails, when he went into one tailed beast mode and Sasuke couldn't read the movement because the nine tails chakra was moving in the opposite direction.

With the Byakugan the user wants can see through walls, and genjutsu attacks (depending on the level of the genjutsu). It also has the ability to see miles away (regardless of what you see online. All Byakugan users can do that, not just Hinata).

I also know that if it was a hand to hand fight it would be in Neji's advantage. Sasuke is hand to hand and mid-range fighter, and let’s face it, he's good at both. So in the end Sasuke would win, but it would be one hell of a fight that a lot of Naruto Fans would of love to see.

There is a lot more we can say about this because both eyes are really well thought out, because most of us would love to have either of the abilities, and I know most people would pick Sharingan, but I'm a true Byakugan user fan, But I still love the idea and evolution of Sharingan.

 

[fastrthnwind]

i pick byakugan.

 

[Turson]

Sharingan is far better than Byakugan. If Sasuke and Neji fought each other, Neji would be destroyed.

 

[Blaze Release]

Sharingan is far better than Byakugan. If Sasuke and Neji fought each other, Neji would be destroyed.

I believe the op said sharigan vs byakugan, meaning sasuke would be in base, no ems. If thats the case this fight can go either way and i might actually give the advantage to neji

 

[Turson]

I believe the op said sharigan vs byakugan, meaning sasuke would be in base, no ems. If thats the case this fight can go either way and i might actually give the advantage to neji

If we are talking about current Sasuke, I wouldnt give Neji any chance, whether with kaleidoscope techniques or not.

 

[Blaze Release]

If we are talking about current Sasuke, I wouldnt give Neji any chance, whether with kaleidoscope techniques or not.

Current base sasuke hasnt improved in base, whilst neji has.
I do believe neji > sharigan sasuke

 

[Turson]

Current base sasuke hasnt improved in base, whilst neji has.
I do believe neji > sharigan sasuke

Sasuke is faster, not to mention that he can predict Nejis movements with Sharingan. He has whole arsenal of strong Ninjutsus, and summon that give him aerial advantage. Overall, I dont see how Neji would be able to win against him.

 

[Nikohru]

Sharingan... only because the Hyugas are being continuously trolled U_U

 

[fastrthnwind]

Sasuke is faster, not to mention that he can predict Nejis movements with Sharingan. He has whole arsenal of strong Ninjutsus, and summon that give him aerial advantage. Overall, I dont see how Neji would be able to win against him.

Sasuke isn't faster. He is about the same according to databooks. Plus Neji has rotation to defend against sasukes jutsu and has vacuum palm to attack him at long range.

 

[Blaze Release]

Sasuke is faster, not to mention that he can predict Nejis movements with Sharingan. He has whole arsenal of strong Ninjutsus, and summon that give him aerial advantage. Overall, I dont see how Neji would be able to win against him.

Sasuke is faster?. Shame the data book gives him a 4.5/5 equal to sasuke.

Predict neji's movement?, i very much doubt. He does boast a pretty impressive reflex, but i see neji's handspeed being on par with bee's kenjutsu which sasuke couldnt exactly cope with.

Areal advantage?. Firstly sasuke is a close to mid range fighter, he hardly has any long range attacks to use his summoning as an advantage. Secondly neji has Hakke Kusho, which could come in hardy against areal attacks;

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Also note that there is no such thing as an ariel advantage when you have a near 360% view

 

[Princeton]

Sasuke wins his Sharingan would track all of neji moves

 

[Turson]

Sasuke is faster?. Shame the data book gives him a 4.5/5 equal to sasuke.

I dont consider Databooks in threads like this, since they are inaccurate. Neji never displayed Shunshin that would be comparable to Sasukes. Sasuke was able to outmaneuver and land a hit on Raikage with Raiton armor lvl 1 activated, I dont see how Neji would be threat to him. Not to mention that if he use Chidori Nagashi during close range combat, Neji will be screwed. That technique dont need any hand seals and works instanlty.

Predict neji's movement?

If he did that with Raikage and Bee... yeah, surely.

Areal advantage?. Firstly sasuke is a close to mid range fighter

His Dragon fire techniques can be used as ranged jutsus.

Secondly neji has Hakke Kusho, which could come in hardy against areal attacks;

Well, that is true.

 

[Blaze Release]

I dont consider Databooks in threads like this, since they are inaccurate. Neji never displayed Shunshin that would be comparable to Sasukes.

Thats because we have hardly seen neji in part 2 therefore we can go by what kishi says and thats 4.5/5 for neji, equal to sasuke

Sasuke was able to outmaneuver and land a hit on Raikage with Raiton armor lvl 1 activated, I dont see how Neji would be threat to him.

Sasuke never outmanoeuvred anyone. Secondly neji's genjle fist is very hard to predict and avoid and just 1 hit alone and you are done for. Infact one hit and im certain the rest will land on you.

Not to mention that if he use Chidori Nagashi during close range combat, Neji will be screwed. That technique dont need any hand seals and works instanlty.

Neji's Hakkesho Kaiten is a far superior technique than the nagashi

His Dragon fire techniques can be used as ranged jutsus.

Make it sound as if neji doesnt have a counter