[VS] Big mom vs akainu

[Lord Tywin]

No they're not. In a world of Devil Fruits and magical abilities ?

He had one of the most destructive powers and a weak heart.

Just imagine if Whitebeard was younger and in better shape. His devil fruit abilities wouldn't be that much different. However he would be able to give Akainu a much better fight. That would make him stronger, not more destructive.

A younger WB would have better durability and that’s it. His DC was stated to be as wild as ever. But then again Akainu survived WB’s strongest attack and was shitting on his commanders like nothing.

 

[Tyrance sasuke]

A younger WB would have better durability and that’s it. His DC was stated to be as wild as ever. But then again Akainu survived WB’s strongest attack and was shitting on his commanders like nothing.

No . That analogy is wrong , a devil fruit ability's power depends on the current state of the user . Its like telling a tired luffy would have the same power in his gatling gun as a fresh luffy . Akainu isnt tanking a direct quake bubble in his prime without a mortal injury , no way .

And he wasnt "shitting" on his commanders , a tired marco was still capable of holding him back for a considerable amount of time , and I wonder how magma would fare against Diamond .

 

[Love Cook]

A younger WB would have better durability and that’s it. His DC was stated to be as wild as ever. But then again Akainu survived WB’s strongest attack and was shitting on his commanders like nothing.

Yes, so that is exactly what I was saying. His destructive capabilities didn't change yet he was stronger at a younger age.

That means strength and destructive powers are NOT interchangeable.

You can't measure someone's strength based on the destruction they do. Like Big Mom's destruction is not really on the scale of some big shots we've seen so far. However her strength feats are probably some of the most impressive up till now.

 

[MickNerks]

Aside from heart attacks(leaving himself open to injury), all that was diminished from whitebeard was his armament haki and too be fair that part of haki hadn't really been emphasized on of till after the time skip, his attack power was still full force and he has still shown the strongest attacks in all of one piece. No matter what big mom or anyone so far has done is any feat belonging to defense, there offense is still lower than whitebeard, and Akainu tanked two haki enhanced (haki powerful enough to match shanks and split the skies) and two of the most powerful punches in all of one piece. That being said, no matter what yonko it is, the result at mf would always be the same.

He was suffering from a sickness as well as the heart attacks, which could take a HUGE toll on his stamina, defense, speed and attack. His power was not at its peak, which both akainu and sengoku mentioned during the fight. In WB peak he had the attack potenial to destroy the world, even if we dont take that at face value I think it would be fair to say that he could at least destory an entire island by himself (since garp was a mountain buster and Chinjo could split an island in half), Yet WB in his sick state couldnt even completely destroy Marineford.

Don't see anyway possible big mom can hurt Akainu enough to ko him. And I doubt she's out lasting him with his onslaught. Even if she can tank a lot of it, she's not standing on a volcanic island for 11 days

Edit: but yes, whitebeard matched Roger but we haven't seen it so yes all together their feats out way whitebeards. But to be fair, if even old sick wb didn't have a heart attack he'd steam roll big mom and kaido and akainu

Yet, Im sure there are more people who cant see how Akainu would hurt or KO Big Mom. She literally has been shown to be immune to damage (even powerful Haki based attacks). So any way you imagine Akainu hurting her is probably contradictory to the manga. Im not going to reiterate on how BM is basically the incredible hulk combined with the avatar, but basically she has more ways to take down Akainu than he has to take her down, plus she has an aerial advantage.

And to your point of her not being able to stay on a volcanic island, I would imaine a yonko capable of having the stamina for a long battle considering we have seen people of lesser strength accomplish similar feats. Also, that island would be controlled by Big Mom by the end of the 1st day which would be a major disadvantage to akainu. The rocks, the ground, the water around the island, the sky, the volcanoe itself.... She would give life to all of it to serve her. This feat has already been shown in Manga.

 

[Sakazuki]

He was suffering from a sickness as well as the heart attacks, which could take a HUGE toll on his stamina, defense, speed and attack. His power was not at its peak, which both akainu and sengoku mentioned during the fight. In WB peak he had the attack potenial to destroy the world, even if we dont take that at face value I think it would be fair to say that he could at least destory an entire island by himself (since garp was a mountain buster and Chinjo could split an island in half), Yet WB in his sick state couldnt even completely destroy Marineford.



Yet, Im sure there are more people who cant see how Akainu would hurt or KO Big Mom. She literally has been shown to be immune to damage (even powerful Haki based attacks). So any way you imagine Akainu hurting her is probably contradictory to the manga. Im not going to reiterate on how BM is basically the incredible hulk combined with the avatar, but basically she has more ways to take down Akainu than he has to take her down, plus she has an aerial advantage.

And to your point of her not being able to stay on a volcanic island, I would imaine a yonko capable of having the stamina for a long battle considering we have seen people of lesser strength accomplish similar feats. Also, that island would be controlled by Big Mom by the end of the 1st day which would be a major disadvantage to akainu. The rocks, the ground, the water around the island, the sky, the volcanoe itself.... She would give life to all of it to serve her. This feat has already been shown in Manga.

The more we talk about it the more I want too see it.

 

[MickNerks]

The more we talk about it the more I want too see it.

Because Big Mom wont be defeated this arc, I think Oda will allow her to return and fully showcase her abilities in the future against either a current yonko (blackbeard/shanks) or against a marine admiral. Hopefully it will be epic!!

 

[arv993]

Shanks does not have better hype than Akainu.

WB's, Roger's, and Garp's best hype is that they were unparalleled in their time, but their time was their time. The other Emperors, Mihawk, Dragon, the Admirals, none of them were active at the time, so the hype means nothing in relation to the new generation.

In the DB it states that shanks and Kaido clashed and Kaido retreated. Along with his haven splitting haki clash with fresh old Wb. this is all hype that suggests he is slightly above akainu. Also the reference to the older gen is because they have otherworldly hype especially Wb, roger and Garp. In the current gen Kaido has received it and even big mom gets a bit as she has said to be never injured along with her Op skill set, her feats as a child but mainly Kaido has gotten that level of hype. This is not something akainu has received yet.

 

[Sakazuki]

In the DB it states that shanks and Kaido clashed and Kaido retreated. Along with his haven splitting haki clash with fresh old Wb. this is all hype that suggests he is slightly above akainu. Also the reference to the older gen is because they have otherworldly hype especially Wb, roger and Garp. In the current gen Kaido has received it and even big mom gets a bit as she has said to be never injured along with her Op skill set, her feats as a child but mainly Kaido has gotten that level of hype. This is not something akainu has received yet.

Oda making Akainu the first fleet admiral to EVER move the marine hq to the new world, just to show the Yonkos he isn't scared of them is petty bad ass, like I said previously. Oda LOVES Akainu.

 

[bajram]

Either way extreme diff, but if I had to choose I'd say Akainu.

Despite the hype I still think that Big Mom is the weakest among the yonko, admittedly the difference in power is way too small to point out but still.

 

[Sakazuki]

Either way extreme diff, but if I had to choose I'd say Akainu.

Despite the hype I still think that Big Mom is the weakest among the yonko, admittedly the difference in power is way too small to point out but still.

I'd say despite the hype kaido is the weakest. Simply because luffy admitted to big mom he's got to wait till after he can beat kaido to beat her, and shanks is shanks, and blackboard is final villain potential along with Akainu

 

[Fireplay]

Mama is OP but imo Akainu will be final villain so Akainu.

BM also seems to be the weakest yonko.