Uzumaki Macho
Active member
This chapter has eliminated Rebecca, Kyros, and Viola as potential SHs, so the only candidates left are Bellamy or Bartolomeo. Which one do you think is going to join?
[Discussion] Bellamy or Bartolomeo
- Thread starter Uzumaki Macho
- Start date
CrimsonReaper
Active member
Awards
LordRaikage
Active member
chopstickchakra
Active member
Neither but if one does I hope it's Bartolomeo. Him having a crew makes it the unlikely of the two though. Plus now Bellamy is Luffy's friend for some reason.
TenseiganFTW
Active member
Well it was Barto's dream to join them,I have big hopes Barto will join them xD.
His DF is cool ^^
Uzumaki Macho
Active member
Skylar Knight
Active member
Awards
WhistleBlower
Active member
Awards
Neither, one has a bounty of 150 million and the other 195 million beri. But i dont see them joining, only allying. If anyone will join jimbei will and apart from that later down the track we will find other candidates
Last edited:
Uzumaki Macho
Active member
Skylar Knight
Active member
Awards
I think Bartolomeo and/or Bellamy have small (or none) chances of joining, while Sugar's chances exceeds both of theirs combined. While it's okay that you disagree with this (like I disagree that Bartolomeo and Bellamy are the two last candidates to join the crew), replying with a 'wtf' or anything of the sort, is unnecessary.
Uzumaki Macho
Active member
She hates the SHs with a passion and was arrested. She will obviously not join.
Vandenre1ch
Active member
Neither. Both are bad choices. Bellamy may be the Mr2 of Dressrosa as he may save the DD members(minus top executives) like how Mr2 saved BW members.
sagemode07
Active member
If there even would anyone join, none of these two. I already made a few weeks ago a short analysis about who it's highly unlikely that Bellamy would join and concerning Bartolomeo, I love his character, but he is simply too much of a fanboy of the Strawhats to become seriously one of them. His character is more served with him aspiring to be like them rather than to be one of them. This became clear to me when he finished off Gladius with an attack inspired by Luffy.
I once had an argument a long time ago about this matter with someone. Wasn't that with you?
It was in an official chapter thread where a person claimed that it was nearly certain that Sugar would join, which I contested as there was absolutely nothing that pointed even remotely into that direction and the progression of the Dressrosa arc just made that that more obvious.
Both Bellamy and Bartolomeo have much higher chances than Sugar, and I don't believe that either of those two would join, simply because of their current state of affaires. Sugar has absolutely no connection whatsoever to any of the Strawhats other than having been enemies, Usopp in particular who she hates and is even traumatized by. There hasn't been a single moment during the entire arc she showed any kind of hesitation or sympathy towards the Strawhats nor of her doubting DD. Also currently she's supposed to be in the custody of the Marines and then you have the matter of her possibly holding the Strawhats responsible for the potential death of her sister, Monet. Heck even Señor Pink has a higher chance of joining the Strawhats just because he and Franky had a connection.
Sugar's chances are far below those of either Bellamy and Bartolomeo.
Skylar Knight
Active member
Awards
1. Look back at Nami's relationship with the Strawhats. Did she like them when she initially joined the Strawhats? No. She joined the crew to get her hands on money (in order to buy back her hometown). Robin goes by the same example. Despite the crew's protests, she joined before the readers could comprehend what just happened. Not just that, Robin had no connection whatsoever to the other Strawhats, except for Luffy, who saved her life.
2. Sugar swore to get revenge on the Strawhat crew and turn them into toys. If she happened to do a Robin and appear on the Strawhats' ship, it would (probably) be for this reason. After failing, she joins the crew to wait for the perfect moment to get her revenge, but ends up becoming a Strawhat, through and through.
The above is just an example of what could happen. It doesn't necessarily have to happen, but it could.
3. All the members of the Donquixote Family has had their pasts revealed (or bits and parts at least) - that is, all but one. Sugar is the only one who hasn't had her past revealed. Nothing. Nada. I don't think Oda would leave out something like that, unless Sugar has a bigger role than most people believe.
4. Did we see her get cuffed? Does she have sea stone chains around her arms and legs? Are there panels of this? No. She could've turned herself into a toy before the Marines could bat an eye - that is, if she has that ability. With something like that, they, the Marines, would instantly forget her and her existence.
5. Sugar has also expressed what seems to be regret. In chapter 741, Leo of the Tontatta Tribe made a speech about Dressrosa's suffering.
"The toys that are forced to work here every day. Our friends who're treated like slaves in the factory. The toys that look like they're having fun, but are suffering on the inside. The sad, big humans who don't even realize that they lost their loved ones. Usoland will save them all!"
Sugar looked somewhat off after the dwarves' cries. She even sighed.
You must be registered for see images
That would be me, yes, and, as you might expect, I still stand by what I said. I still think her chances of joining are far above anyone else's. That is just my opinion about it, though. If she actually ends up joining, I don't know.
I made some points in my reply to Uzumaki Macho, in case you'd like to take a look.
ultraChalk
Active member
Awards
Neither of them. Bart would be okay but still neither.
The one I wanted most is Voila and even that was a pipedream. Now I know neither of them are joining.
The one I wanted most is Voila and even that was a pipedream. Now I know neither of them are joining.