Battle Arena Rules Discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.

Lord of Kaos

Supreme
Joined
Apr 7, 2009
Messages
29,260
Kin
4,695💸
Kumi
92,153💴
Trait Points
25⚔️
I have a question about the new ''Stolen Sharingan Rules''

On the restrictions it's said that:
-the eyes cannot be stored anywhere.

So, where can we store them?
Can people stole Byakuugan eyes too?
And what about ppl who are Senju or Kaguya for example, and stole Sharingan eyes? Isnt that overpowered?
Or stole a byakuugan and a sharingan eye?
just to bring the questions back up to this page

:|
 

Typhon

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Apr 29, 2009
Messages
15,991
Kin
664💸
Kumi
6,684💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Not sure if this idea will be supported.....but why not limit it to 2 elements per bio, except in cases where the manga says otherwise (ie. Kakuza, Mizukage, KG etc.)? If you want to battles to be realistic, then ninja can't just use all the elements. By allowing any ninja to use all 5 of the elements it takes away from the authenticity of this being a Naruto RP forum as well as makes to fights boring. If you only have 2 elements then you have deal with the challenges of elements that are superior to yours. The way I see it now every character is OP. Everyone has 5 elements plus custom jutsu plus custom elements plus KG plus summons plus whatever. It just seems a little off. I mean whats the point of creating a bio for a character like Kakuza if everyone can use 5 elements? There is none, his threads are cool, but not that cool. His major advantage is all of the elements, and that advantage is nullified by the current rules.

I just think restricting the number of elements per character would greatly increase both competitiveness, strategy and overall enjoyment when RP battling. This is after all a Naruto forum, and I think we should RP with the rules of the Narutoverse, not the rules we think the Narutoverse should have.
 

Shig

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Aug 14, 2008
Messages
10,273
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Not sure if this idea will be supported.....but why not limit it to 2 elements per bio, except in cases where the manga says otherwise (ie. Kakuza, Mizukage, KG etc.)? If you want to battles to be realistic, then ninja can't just use all the elements. By allowing any ninja to use all 5 of the elements it takes away from the authenticity of this being a Naruto RP forum as well as makes to fights boring. If you only have 2 elements then you have deal with the challenges of elements that are superior to yours. The way I see it now every character is OP. Everyone has 5 elements plus custom jutsu plus custom elements plus KG plus summons plus whatever. It just seems a little off. I mean whats the point of creating a bio for a character like Kakuza if everyone can use 5 elements? There is none, his threads are cool, but not that cool. His major advantage is all of the elements, and that advantage is nullified by the current rules.

I just think restricting the number of elements per character would greatly increase both competitiveness, strategy and overall enjoyment when RP battling. This is after all a Naruto forum, and I think we should RP with the rules of the Narutoverse, not the rules we think the Narutoverse should have.
I agree, just a bit.
But yeah, it wouldn't be evolution if at Sannin rank you have 2-3 elements.
 

Deidara...

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jun 13, 2009
Messages
5,481
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Not sure if this idea will be supported.....but why not limit it to 2 elements per bio, except in cases where the manga says otherwise (ie. Kakuza, Mizukage, KG etc.)? If you want to battles to be realistic, then ninja can't just use all the elements. By allowing any ninja to use all 5 of the elements it takes away from the authenticity of this being a Naruto RP forum as well as makes to fights boring. If you only have 2 elements then you have deal with the challenges of elements that are superior to yours. The way I see it now every character is OP. Everyone has 5 elements plus custom jutsu plus custom elements plus KG plus summons plus whatever. It just seems a little off. I mean whats the point of creating a bio for a character like Kakuza if everyone can use 5 elements? There is none, his threads are cool, but not that cool. His major advantage is all of the elements, and that advantage is nullified by the current rules.

I just think restricting the number of elements per character would greatly increase both competitiveness, strategy and overall enjoyment when RP battling. This is after all a Naruto forum, and I think we should RP with the rules of the Narutoverse, not the rules we think the Narutoverse should have.
i like this idea, actually, its more realistic in terms of naruto. concidering there arent many ninja that use more than two elements w/ exception to kakashi, mizukage, kazuku, fu(filler girl who kills by kissing xD), etc.
 

Typhon

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Apr 29, 2009
Messages
15,991
Kin
664💸
Kumi
6,684💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
i like this idea, actually, its more realistic in terms of naruto. concidering there arent many ninja that use more than two elements w/ exception to kakashi, mizukage, kazuku, fu(filler girl who kills by kissing xD), etc.
Ya thats what I was saying. Chars like Kakuzu, Kakashi, Mizukage all can use more than 2 elements. Also chars like Haku who get elements by combining two elements would get for example Ice=Wind + Water. So Haku would get Ice, Wind and water.
 

Sharpism

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jan 4, 2010
Messages
1,005
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Nakai I agree to an extent. However, clans would then be limited, as we don't see them use any other jutsu then the specific hiden ones in their Clan. Shikamaru only uses Shadow Manipulation when he too posesses a Chakra Affinity.

You'd have to flesh out these sorts of things. Does a Nara/Shadow user bio only get Shadow, Shadow + 1 Affinity, Shadow + 2 Affinites?

Generally a Ninja only learns about 2 Element affinities in their life time, assuming they master or close to master one affinity and the other is incomplete at the time of death.
This also applies for things like Hyuuga's Hiden or Nara's Hiden Jutsu. They take a while to master such things, and would cut back on time that they are able to learn other Elements. However if you do this in a RP no one is going to play as a Hyuuga when they only get the Clan techniques and possible ONE Element type. Why? Because someone will have 2 or 3 thats 90% chance that your ONE element type is going to be a weaker one, and your clan jutsu is limited to -
 

Sharpism

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jan 4, 2010
Messages
1,005
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Close Range. Close range + weaker jutsu = no one playing as the clan.

The same would apply for a Sharingan user, your passage to adult hood is through a fire technique thus you automatically give up one jutsu type because you're forced to train in fire.

It COULD work, it'd just have to be fleshed out properly before actually doing something like this.

I'd also like to say that it'd cut down on Kage Bunshin. xD;
 

Typhon

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Apr 29, 2009
Messages
15,991
Kin
664💸
Kumi
6,684💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Close Range. Close range + weaker jutsu = no one playing as the clan.

The same would apply for a Sharingan user, your passage to adult hood is through a fire technique thus you automatically give up one jutsu type because you're forced to train in fire.

It COULD work, it'd just have to be fleshed out properly before actually doing something like this.

I'd also like to say that it'd cut down on Kage Bunshin. xD;

I see what you're saying and it would be difficult to do with the current set up of the battle system. I just think it would open up things that are lost with the current system. As you mentioned with clans such as Hyuuga or Uchiha I think that in a better system those type of characters would be playable. In our current system Taijutsu outside of the 8 gates is non-existent. Thats a huge portion of Naruto that just never gets used. Genjutsu is rarely used as well. Everyone just spams their 5 elements or custom jutsu until they kill their opponent. Its boring.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top