Ay was a terrible shinobi
- Thread starter Mellanoma
- Start date
Rikudo Madara
Member
Again, you've resorted to ego and just being stupid? How do you think you've won this argument? If you were sucking Sasuke's **** any harder you'd rip it off. You're literally running away from a discussion the moment your go to facts get disproven and shit on
Rikudo Madara
Member
Rikudo Madara
Member
And here we see a Sasuke fanboy retreating into his cave of body pillows and waifus because he's lost an argument
Naruto X Hunter
Active member
Awards
The Raikage did have intel. He knew Sasuke was an Uchiha Sharingan user who wields the Fire & Lightning element.
^Earlier he sent Samui, Darui, & Karui to Konoha to gain intel. They told him at the summit.
Furthermore, although underestimating the Tomoe Sharingan, he immediately powered up to Biju levels to significantly enhance his speed, strength, & power when he saw Sasuke's Mangekyo. This/the next page.
& based on his reaction, he clearly knew of Amaterasu which is even more evident based on Shee using it's actual name & comparing Sasuke's skill with it to Itachi's. The Raikage specifically timed his movements with Amaterasu's activation time so he could evade it. This/the next two pages.
& when he fought Minato he took note of the position of all his Kunais' to predict where he would teleport.
SM Naruto can easily be defeated by Genjutsu alone without the Kyuubi's assistance.
MS Sasuke>SM Naruto. Gaara, Temari, & Kankuro, who seen Amaterasu, Enton, & Imperfect Susano'o (chapter 464), told Naruto what happened at the summit, & after facing Sasuke himself, Naruto stated that he needed the Kyuubi's power to fight him. Obviously feeling/knowing SM isn't enough. This/the next page.
You must be registered for see links
^Earlier he sent Samui, Darui, & Karui to Konoha to gain intel. They told him at the summit.
Furthermore, although underestimating the Tomoe Sharingan, he immediately powered up to Biju levels to significantly enhance his speed, strength, & power when he saw Sasuke's Mangekyo. This/the next page.
You must be registered for see links
& based on his reaction, he clearly knew of Amaterasu which is even more evident based on Shee using it's actual name & comparing Sasuke's skill with it to Itachi's. The Raikage specifically timed his movements with Amaterasu's activation time so he could evade it. This/the next two pages.
You must be registered for see links
& when he fought Minato he took note of the position of all his Kunais' to predict where he would teleport.
Lol, ofcourse you would respond to the Naruto comments rather than the main topic.
SM Naruto can easily be defeated by Genjutsu alone without the Kyuubi's assistance.
MS Sasuke>SM Naruto. Gaara, Temari, & Kankuro, who seen Amaterasu, Enton, & Imperfect Susano'o (chapter 464), told Naruto what happened at the summit, & after facing Sasuke himself, Naruto stated that he needed the Kyuubi's power to fight him. Obviously feeling/knowing SM isn't enough. This/the next page.
You must be registered for see links
You must be registered for see links
Last edited:
Rikudo Madara
Member
The bold statement is a contradiction of what a great shinobi should be so yes he was a bad shinobi
Also you can't equate a Kage's strength to the village success
Tsunade was hokage at the time Konoha was the strongest village. That doesn't mean she powerful it just means she was lucky to be apart of it
Bee is a perfect Jin and most of the cloud ninjas have OP abilities. That has nothing to do with the Kage
Onoki and Mei both have extremely OP jutsu but their villages were super weak
Itachi Minato
Active member
If that fight continued sasuke would have been dead. A at the time thought sasuke had killed Bee he was motivated by revenge.
This is why in the OP i put
No intel or refusing to use intel.
The fact that he had intel and still was wreckless further intensifies my point
Both would have died. If Ay would not die the cost of revenge permanently cripple himself AND destabilize your country?
Point intensifies
Last edited:
Naruto X Hunter
Active member
Awards
When you said this, "You're not special, there's loads of fanboys out there buddy and a lot of them actually have facts to support their claims, unlike some"
I thought you were partially referring to me in regards to my Sasuke>Naruto threads.
That's an assumption. You're assuming he would have gotten past Sasuke's defences and harmed him enough to kill him. Sasuke clearly enhanced his defense after the Raikage's first strike, hence forming multiple spikes. During Naruto's RasenShuriken training, Yamato stated that changing the form of a nature element significantly enhances it.
You must be registered for see links
That's somewhat true.
He knew Sasuke was a Sharingan user and underestimated his Genjutsu skill, even looking directly into his eyes at one point (Sasuke could have easily casted Genjutsu, but Kishimoto didn't have him do so), but seeing as how he told Darui & Shee to come with him, & specifically fought in unison with them, he clearly kept the other intel in mind. Darui has water to counter Sasuke's Fire, and Lightning to counter his Lightning whilst Shee is a medic Ninja who can heal their wounds, but they were certainly underestimating him despite having intel considering apart of their strategy was for Shee too use Genjutsu to distract Sasuke so they (the Raikage & Darui) could get close and land the finishing blows.
Last edited:
Umari Senju
Active member
XD. Deidara was not stronger than Gaara. He simply out strategized him. Gaara had to defend his village and people in addition to fighting Deidara. Had they been away from the village Deidara would have died.
It's still Deidara's win of course. But he wasn't stronger than Gaara.
OT: sure I can roll with what the OP is saying. I don't think he was a terrible Raikage, just not the brightest fighter.
Rikudo Madara
Member
If you can back those up wi facts then I'm completely fine with it
Rikudo Madara
Member
No it's not a contradiction, emotion and intelligence are different.The bold statement is a contradiction of what a great shinobi should be so yes he was a bad shinobi
Also you can't equate a Kage's strength to the village success
Tsunade was hokage at the time Konoha was the strongest village. That doesn't mean she powerful it just means she was lucky to be apart of it
Bee is a perfect Jin and most of the cloud ninjas have OP abilities. That has nothing to do with the Kage
Onoki and Mei both have extremely OP jutsu but their villages were super weak
Naruto is a great Shinobi yet he is rash and emotional.
Many people are rash, emotional and very head strong people, doesn't mean they're a bad Shinobi.
I wasn't equating his strength to the villages success, I was equating his skill as a Shinobi and a Kage is what the OP is about. Oh and yes while you cannot correlate a Kage's strength to the strength of their village, that is not what I said. I said their skills as a Kage and Shinobi in which you can correlate to the success of their village. Tsunade was a great Kage, not because of her strength but her leadership qualities, decisiveness, intelligence etc. etc.
Every Itachi and Hiruzen fan
I back my claims with manga facts and if i dont provide scans I at least speak on subjects I know. This is why in my OP i covered every aspect that could potentially bite me in the ass
Rikudo Madara
Member
You have backed it up with facts but there still remains the fact that he just is a good Shinobi. If he was not then he wouldn't of made it to where he is. There has been multiple cases where he has shown his skills and abilities. When he has been provided with intel he has assessed the best way to go about it and come up with the best answer he can in the time frame. Something shown with his tactics against Minato and his fight against Sasuke by using Shee and Darui to counter and distract Sasuke.Every Itachi and Hiruzen fan
I back my claims with manga facts and if i dont provide scans I at least speak on subjects I know. This is why in my OP i covered every aspect that could potentially bite me in the ass
I will admit that Ay was still acting risky and putting himself, Shee and Darui at risk but remember that Ay is a very emotional person and at that moment in time he was passed beyond belief because of what Sasuke had done to B. Ay wouldn't be thinking straight and he would've been enraged.
He was a good Kage, assessing the threat, finding a solution, not charging head in if it was stupid or if it could leave him vulnerable. This was shown briefly when Naruto and B left to the front lines which Ay vehemently protested against because of he knew that it was in the Allied Shinobi Forces best interest to keep Naruto and B safe. Only when he was spcertain of Naruto's strength did he let them leave and even then you could see he was reluctant
He only became Kage due to his Father.
Resorting to violence during a World leadership meeting:
Punching through Amaterasu
Blitzing a S/T user who would've killed him had he not had back up
Fighting a sharingan user ALL WRONG because he felt his abilities were better.
As I told the other guy. Having intel and refusing to use it properly is stupider than not having intel at all.
Irrational, wreckless and short tempered. Terrible traits for a shinobi and even worst for a Leader
As for your feats you spoke of I suggest you re-read them in the manga and you will see just how wreckless Ay really is
His father had the ultimate offense and defense and he even knew how to tactfully attack