Attack on the Leaf

[blazekev90]

We all know about the attack on the leaf, which is what ultimately gave Minato more credibilty as this was no easy task for an average shinobi. But I was wondering, who else could have done the job just as good or better? Was this accomplish that superb?

I persoanlly feel that this def wasn't an easy task, but I also feel that there are a few others that could have done the job better.

Nagato-obvious reasons
Itachi- He's boss, genjutsu and mirror (forgot the name)
Muu- He's just BA
Orochimaru- use the 1st Hokage #boom
3rd Raikage (maybe)- he took on the 8-tails, and wasnt defeated
Jman- Sage Mode and Toads
Danzo
Garra (maybe)

These are all the ppl I can think of right now wat yall think???

(Btw this isnt trying to take away from Minato's accomplishment)

 

[kaka96]

I don't get the question, Minato wasn't in the attack on the leaf :| he died 12-13 years prior

 

[-Vegeta-]

Nobody would've been able to do it any better than Minato for the simple fact that it wasn't just the kyuubi there, Tobi was also there and to beat him you pretty much need s/t jutsu which none of the shinobi you listed possess.

 

[Kianto]

you mean when the nine tails attacked? if so... i only think that Nagato could handle it though... but only in hes prime.

 

[OWanime]

yeah I agree but the best for the job is minato

 

[blazekev90]

you mean when the nine tails attacked? if so... i only think that Nagato could handle it though... but only in hes prime.

yes, that attack with Tobi and 9-tails. But I think these guys could have done just as well.

 

[kaka96]

Hiruzen knew Dead reaper seal so maybe he could have handled it :|
Actually maybe not , only someone as fast as Minato could have handled Tobi and if they can't handled Tobi, they can't do crap about Kyubi
or someone with stuff like KA

I can't see Nagato doing it, he has now way of hurting Tobi >.>

 

[Zoro..]

We all know about the attack on the leaf, which is what ultimately gave Minato more credibilty as this was no easy task for an average shinobi. But I was wondering, who else could have done the job just as good or better? Was this accomplish that superb?

I persoanlly feel that this def wasn't an easy task, but I also feel that there are a few others that could have done the job better.

Nagato-obvious reasons
Itachi- He's boss, genjutsu and mirror (forgot the name) No
Muu- He's just BA
Orochimaru- use the 1st Hokage #boomNo
3rd Raikage (maybe)- he took on the 8-tails, and wasnt defeated Maybe
Jman- Sage Mode and Toads No
Danzo No
Garra (maybe) No

These are all the ppl I can think of right now wat yall think???

(Btw this isnt trying to take away from Minato's accomplishment)

I dont think anyone could do what Minato did for a few reasons. I just took a few people off the list because
1. Cant wound Tobi
2. Cant move fast enough to save Naruto
3. Dont have a chance against the 9 tails in general
4. They dont have the sealing techs

If you want me to go more in depth I will later because I am currently busy ^^

 

[Wind..]

Nah Minato did it very well, if not the best

 

[blazekev90]

Nagato would have handled that with ease IMO. Itachi could use genjutsu Kyubi, Oro could summon the 1st to handle the Kyubi as well. Muu dust release might be big enuff to handle the Kyubi and Tobi would be outta sight. Jman is SM is fast and all his toads would rock the Kyubi. Garra airbound and would turn the whole villiage into a sand grave (lol)

 

[-Vegeta-]

Nagato would have handled that with ease IMO. Itachi could use genjutsu Kyubi, Oro could summon the 1st to handle the Kyubi as well. Muu dust release might be big enuff to handle the Kyubi and Tobi would be outta sight. Jman is SM is fast and all his toads would rock the Kyubi

Some of them may have the skills to fight the kyuubi, but none of them can do anything against Tobi hence why none of them can do as well or better than Minato did that night.

 

[Darth Atlas]

Minato did the best because he saved the village from the tailed beast bomb none of those people you listed could block that attack or redirect it

 

[blazekev90]

Some of them may have the skills to fight the kyuubi, but none of them can do anything against Tobi hence why none of them can do as well or better than Minato did that night.

Tobi is so bluh IMO, he has no good offense and all you been to do is have good defense. Oro has 2nd who knows S/T and many other summons. Garra is protected 99.9% of the time lol, Muu would be flying so Tobi cant touch him. Nagato would destory them both!

 

[Rike Senju]

Minato's speed and s/t jutsu made him one of the few if not the only shinobi able to have succesfully defended the village that night

 

[-Vegeta-]

Tobi is so bluh IMO, he has no good offense and all you been to do is have good defense. Oro has 2nd who knows S/T and many other summons. Garra is protected 99.9% of the time lol, Muu would be flying so Tobi cant touch him. Nagato would destory them both!

They can't defeat Tobi unless they can touch him and none of them can. Minato could only accomplish this due to his ftg and he had to time it perfectly just to land one hit on him.

 

[blazekev90]

They can't defeat Tobi unless they can touch him and none of them can. Minato could only accomplish this due to his ftg and he had to time it perfectly just to land one hit on him.

what was Tobi without the Kyubi tho?

 

[Zoro..]

Nagato would have handled that with ease IMO. Itachi could use genjutsu Kyubi, Oro could summon the 1st to handle the Kyubi as well. Muu dust release might be big enuff to handle the Kyubi and Tobi would be outta sight. Jman is SM is fast and all his toads would rock the Kyubi. Garra airbound and would turn the whole villiage into a sand grave (lol)

Hmm lets see...
Nagato would lose to Tobi IMO
Itachi wouldnt be able to use genjutsu cause of Tobi and the Kyuubi combined
Oro+the first would lose to Tobi+Kyuubi cause Oro has poor control
Jman in SM would lose to Tobi because Tobi could warp him and Minato had all the Toads too...
And we havent seen enough of Muu
And Garra would just lose straight up

 

[-Vegeta-]

what was Tobi without the Kyubi tho?

Why does that matter?

 

[blazekev90]

Hmm lets see...
Nagato would lose to Tobi IMO
Itachi wouldnt be able to use genjutsu cause of Tobi and the Kyuubi combined
Oro+the first would lose to Tobi+Kyuubi cause Oro has poor controlJman in SM would lose to Tobi because Tobi could warp him and Minato had all the Toads too...
And we havent seen enough of Muu
And Garra would just lose straight up

Nagato lose to Tobi how??
Itachi was better at genjutst, cant his control overpower Tobi'S?????
Oro+1st Hokage+2nd Hokage+summons>Tobi+Kyuubi IMO lol

 

[blazekev90]

Why does that matter?

u said they could hanlde the 9-tails, but wouldnt be able to do anything about Tobi. But what is without the Kyubi