[Game] AnimeBase Mafia Players Game!!! #29

[Ansatsuken]

He has. Again it goes back to Alice's game.
Its still going to be an amazing coincidence that SK and TSQ randed scum together.

Also think of this way Ansa. Until SK's superkill, the scum team was pretty much coasting. None of their members were dead.
And we found out that SK had a lynch immunity. As scum don't you think you would want to save it for as long as possible. Ted intervenes to save SK coz it literally gives them 2 extra night phases to reduce town's number.
One from getting Toujo lynched instead of SK. 2nd night phase coz lynch immunity would kick in and save SK.
And then he would have another day phase to manipulate.

This is how I see things.

You do really have a point there. "Save it at all costs whenever it possible" kind of mentality.

 

[Ansatsuken]

Hm, the way I understood it was that Rej voted X to get more information.
I don't see Rej as mafia, serial killer maybe who knows. (I mean after X last game who was helping town a lot I could see it possible ) but it's not in my focus for today.
Culling the mafia team is more important I think.
We can discuss the idea, but it's more important to focus on discussing the best lynch for today also.

Is your best bet Sagebee?
Why better than Poison?

Because Sagebee look more suspicious currently. He also looks like what PK describe about Ted in recent comment..

 

[Ryu Kishi]

vote Lynch tsq

 

[Tigerrr in the woods]

He has. Again it goes back to Alice's game.
Its still going to be an amazing coincidence that SK and TSQ randed scum together.

Also think of this way Ansa. Until SK's superkill, the scum team was pretty much coasting. None of their members were dead.
And we found out that SK had a lynch immunity. As scum don't you think you would want to save it for as long as possible. Ted intervenes to save SK coz it literally gives them 2 extra night phases to reduce town's number.
One from getting Toujo lynched instead of SK. 2nd night phase coz lynch immunity would kick in and save SK.
And then he would have another day phase to manipulate.

This is how I see things.

YEs
And also the reason we have, or I personally have been slow at really just slamming the door on them, because them being randed together again is like some very slim chances. It would be the third game here they rand together. o - o

But if we forget about the past randed games , it makes sense.

What is your opinion of X rn and your theory about them after we saw Sk's flip?

 

[Ansatsuken]

For me it between Sagebee and TSQ

 

[Ansatsuken]

Seriously? even when sk was like ending dp early was a town ability?

I missed that part. I'm too busy m8 at that time

 

[-PK-]

YEs
And also the reason we have, or I personally have been slow at really just slamming the door on them, because them being randed together again is like some very slim chances. It would be the third game here they rand together. o - o

But if we forget about the past randed games , it makes sense.

What is your opinion of X rn and your theory about them after we saw Sk's flip?

@XTMF looks much better to me this phase than he did to me in the previous one.
I gave a reasoning as to what I thought was his reasons for going after Toujo and I THINK I might be right about that.

I like his case on Sagebee tbh.
Like if you think about it it does make sense that the reason I sus TSQ and Poison can be applied to Sage as well.

But what makes the difference for me is how Sage has been more consistent with his viewpoints while TSQ and Poison have flipped around.

X looks much better to me but I don't clear him yet and I am curious what hus response will be to my request.
I asked him to take a look at Toujo's lynch.

 

[-PK-]

Vote lynch - Poison Chan.

Let's end this saga as well. Gone on long enough. @Houtarou

 

[Tigerrr in the woods]

This is confusing honestly.
On one side we have 2 people taht make sense against Sagebee's role.
I myself suspect him to some degree

Don't both wasting your time looking for the bold because it simply didn't happen; he was adamant that Soul was not the correct lynch last phase, not that him and Poison could be teammates.

I think this is more an excuses and not real reason. I think many people have came up with good reasoning why SK could be scum. You just ignored them.



Lol Rej has his own reasons why he thinks SoulKiller could be scum. That's not Rej primary reason. Go read 3DP and 4DP.



Lol go read Tigerrr's read on SoulKiller. I think you actually didn't follow the thread. Read all player's opinion on SoulKiller. Is there any reason to be lazy??



Are you for real? This is ridiculous statement coming from you. Damn. @Michelle look here what Sagebee said about how you suspect SoulKiller.



You're not making sense here. All of those people have provided very good reasons why SoulKiller is scum to them.


Nah PK wasn't the only one.



Because I want to see how Poison fit in the world where SoulKiller is scum also. I mean in your world.

Then We have Sagebee who has been looking like a rational mind questioning the validity of votes and their reason

I think I did and pretty sure you gave a lynch without really explaining why.

I dont know thestatusquo status all I know is I haven't seen an arguement presented for him on why hes the best lynch.

I looked when you cast your lynch you gave no reason if you gave reason afterwards I have to look back and check.

I talked to tiger pk and you and looked up rejs reason all were superficial(stating the reasons earlier). Pk only one actually gave an arguement for scum case.

@Sagebee
He has been rational and chose to expose himself no matter the AI with the the push for poison.
If he is indeed scum he took a very risky strategy, hoping to openly flip the votes in one direction.

The push for Poison does make sense. She is being very strange, so strange that I thought it must be smth interfering with her normal self.
That 'interference' could be her role- aka wolf
Or outside 'interference'- I don't know here if this is true, because that would require hence ability to be very powerful. To manipulate someone to this degree.
( This would be an extremely powerful ability- not sure if it would exist in this world where we have one mafia already with lynch immunity)but anything is possible, hence why I am so confused.

:/
I don;t know what to make of Sagebee vs Poison chan rn

So I still think TSq to be a more stable lynch until further.

I will continue to read into Sagebee, see if I find anything to point me one way or the other.

 

[Tigerrr in the woods]

@XTMF looks much better to me this phase than he did to me in the previous one.
I gave a reasoning as to what I thought was his reasons for going after Toujo and I THINK I might be right about that.

I like his case on Sagebee tbh.
Like if you think about it it does make sense that the reason I sus TSQ and Poison can be applied to Sage as well.

But what makes the difference for me is how Sage has been more consistent with his viewpoints while TSQ and Poison have flipped around.

X looks much better to me but I don't clear him yet and I am curious what hus response will be to my request.
I asked him to take a look at Toujo's lynch.

So a world where Sagebee is in the same team as Poison?
WOW

 

[-PK-]

So a world where Sagebee is in the same team as Poison?
WOW

No. I don't think so.

At max 2/3 of those scum. I don't think its realistic that the entire scum team put all their eggs in one basket.

I am going for Poison. If she flips to be scum then I don't think Sage will be one.

 

[Alice in Noodleland]

Votelynch: TheStatusquo

I thought we all agreed the TSQ will be the Lynch today?




I'm giving X a benefit of a doubt this DP.
I'm still not putting Sagebee on my scum list yet.. I want to see more of him this DP

 

[-PK-]

Votelynch: TheStatusquo

I thought we all agreed the TSQ will be the Lynch today?




I'm giving X a benefit of a doubt this DP.
I'm still not putting Sagebee on my scum list yet.. I want to see more of him this DP

Either one of TSQ or Poison.

 

[Alice in Noodleland]

I need to review again the NP write ups to see how the Serial Killer use his NK.. If it's odd or even.

 

[Ansatsuken]

I'm going to give Sagebee a benefit of Doubt

Unvote

Vote: Thestatusquo

 

[Alice in Noodleland]

Lol.. Come to think of it.. If the serial killer is SK ( UN) who killed Soulkiller.(player) . The irony of it

 

[Poison]

I'm back.

 

[Michelle]

Lol.. Come to think of it.. If the serial killer is SK ( UN) who killed Soulkiller.(player) . The irony of it

Imagine the Serial killer with soulkiller role may shot soul after he was outed mafia.

This is speculation but that was a good shot, either was town vig or serial.

 

[Poison]

My town leans in the game michelle pk ansat aether rej tiger

Why the hell is Aether a town? scum read me ok. but why is Aether a town?

Was framing who in this scenario?

And dont think beeboat death is due to mafia if they were town people saw her scummy and wouldnt go after and if she was mafia obviously mafia wouldnt target them.

Not sure how beeboat being town clears them.

And again poison was an easy lynch but soul was deadset on going after you instead.

And poison was third to back gomes lynch which soul started shes definitely the best candidate.

1. Janitors are baiscally scum roles. so getting Janitored is a scum attack.
2. I have no idea why SK didn't bite me, but I think it's because he wanted me to believe he was town.

It's the first day and it was a scummy lynch on her part aswell. I thought soul acting erratic meant he was town we cany say scum indefinitely wont act like that.

And poison tried her best not participating in last lynch

the thing is, You hard tunnel me without reading me. @Sagebee it's not I "Tried hard to not participate" it's that "I could not have" that would have been suicidal.

 

[Tigerrr in the woods]

now this looks like normal poison to me ~_~ not trusting you in this game girl though sorry.