I made a thread referring to people like this who say Ninja A won Ninja B and Ninja B won Ninja C therefore Ninja A is greater than Ninja C.
Nagato, Itachi, Madara, Kisame were not killed by someone. Madara is even still alive. Kisame was defeated in his weakened state and still he killed himself. Itachi died out of sickness and Nagato died due to exhaustion of chakra. Konan was killed by a fellow Akatsuki. Hidan is not yet dead! lol! Kakuzu was outsmarted and KILLED. Agreed. Deidara BOMBED himself. Sasori let Chiyo kill him, Zetsu is still alive and Orochimar was killed when he was still sick.
Only Kakuzu has died clearly. The rest are either not dead or killed themselves
IT IS NOT MOSTLY TRUE! It can be true or false. And what about my other points? Have u agreed with them.
I'm not sure what your definition on the word
defeated is but it it seems as though you consider death to be a prerequisite. If this
is the case, then this is how your "points" would come across(or atleast how it comes across to me).:
=> Nagato wasn't defeated by Naruto (Your right, Naruto defeated Pain. But Nagato and Konan were talk-no-jutsu'd)
=> Itachi wasn't defeated (I agree with this. But he would have probably suffered the same fate eventually if he pushed his body too far.)
=> Kisame was defeated by Guy(I agree )
=> Hashirama did not defeat Madara (I certainly cant agree with this)
=> Hidan was not defeated by Shikamaru (do you really expect me to agree with this?)
=> Deidera was not defeated (I disagree. Deidera tried to kill Sasuke at the cost of his own life but his objective failed. I would only agree had Deidera succeeded)
=> Sasori was not defeated(in essence, Sasori "surrendered his King" after being pushed to the brink by a very old lady and a medical chuunin)
=> Kakuzu was defeated (I also agree)
My point is that these previous encounters have shown that these Akatsuki members are clearly nowhere as invincible as you make them out to be. The Kages aren't invincible either but if Kishi ever were to cook up such a match up then I'd place my money on the Kages.