[VS] 4 Uchiha VS 4 Hokage

who wins?

  • Team Hokage

    Votes: 13 61.9%
  • Team Uchiha

    Votes: 7 33.3%
  • All Die(Draw)

    Votes: 1 4.8%

  • Total voters
    21

KidGamer65

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Kin
8💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
The logic isn't flawed at all.

1. Tobirama canonically looks at the Mangekyō.

2. Tsukuyomi catches those that look at the Mangekyō.

3. Once caught, Tsukuyomi can only be countered by prodigious Sharingan users.

4. Tsukuyomi's strengths varies according to Itachi's whim, and can kill individuals if he desires.

So I'll tell you what's flawed. It's the bullshit assumption that Itachi can't force eye contact in his battles.

Or that just because someone knows of typical Sharingan genjutsu, that they'll evade eyes.

It should be a well-known fact that 99% of Sharingan genjutsu won't affect powerful ninja:

You must be registered for see images


The viz translation makes it more clear, but anybody should deduce the obvious:

Orochimaru knows about genjutsu. He's the king of knowledge and a Konoha veteran.

He's surprised that Itachi's genjutsu is strong enough to hold him, because Itach's genjutsu is ridiculously strong.

Hence why Orochimaru, Tobirama, A, etc. all canonically look at the Sharingan.

Because in ages past, the typical Sharingan user couldn't hold ninja of that caliber.

But Itachi is by no means a tpical Sharingan user, or genjutsu specialist for that matter.
When did I ever say that he can't force eye contact? Never, I suggest you re-read my post.

-Saying Itachi wins just because Tobirama has already looked at another Uchiha's eyes in one instance, implying that he will do the same in battle is bullshit logic. Forcing eye contact during battle is obviously another story.
 

Lilt

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jan 16, 2012
Messages
2,195
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
How is that bullshit?

Tobirama looks at Uchiha's eyes without special knowledge.

He has no special knowledge on Itachi.

Therefore, he will look at Itachi's eyes.

And if, like me, you think forcing eye contact is likely in most battles, then it is nigh guaranteed without special knowledge.
 

USSJ Future Trunks

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Nov 15, 2011
Messages
18,518
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
This logic is flawed beyond belief, especially since Tobirama already knows Sharingan casts Genjutsu.
no he doesnt as he clearly looked at an uchiha's MS. that is canonical. its likely that genjutsu users are rare even among uchihas. obito knows cos madara taught him. sasuke knows because he had itachi mindrape him three times. itachi is so good because of obito and shisui.
-Saying Itachi wins just because Tobirama has already looked at another Uchiha's eyes in one instance, implying that he will do the same in battle is bullshit logic.
theres also the problem that tobirama may think hes seen it all and will break any genjutsu thats thrown his way. but he has not battled against itachi before who has unique powers
 

enditallsin

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jun 17, 2011
Messages
1,940
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The kages can depending on which version of madara is fighting edo or ems? if ems madara is fighting than the kages definitely win but with mid difficulty(buts thats only because madara and obito), if edo madara is fighting the uchihas win with extremely high difficulty but that only because of madara and obito...........since itachi and sasuke are gonna get their asses killed in the cross fire. Kages>team uchiha(with ems madara) but (with edo madara)team uchiha>kages(but itachi and sasuke definitely die)
 

pateuvasiliu

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 1, 2013
Messages
8,740
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Imma stop you Itachi fanboys right here and remind you Edos do not feel pain and regenerate instantly, making Amaterasu and Tsukuyomi useless against them.
 
Last edited:

Zexion~

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jun 20, 2012
Messages
17,100
Kin
21💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
well that was ridiculously stupid that you allowed edo's into this ..ruined a climactic fight .... Only way they can lose is now with ****ing totska and KA ... thats it ...or if obito were to use the phantom dragon sealing technique ...Mean While Since their edo hirzuen can spam reaper death seal...Not to mention minato could as well ....
 

Lilt

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jan 16, 2012
Messages
2,195
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Imma stop you Itachi fanboys right here and remind you Edos do not feel pain and regenerate instantly, making Amaterasu and Tsukuyomi useless against them.
We saw Amaterasu was effective in knocking Nagato out for a time.

Tsukuyomi is said to attack the soul and mind, so it's perfect for an Edo.

Let me explain that last point: Itachi isn't hurting their body. He's making their mind think he's hurting their body.

So Edos, Sasori, Hidan would all feel pain in Tsukuyomi that they wouldn't in life.

The databook clearly implies as much when saying Superman's mind would collapse.

(Superman being the alluded man with a body of steel that can move at the speed of light.)
 

USSJ Future Trunks

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Nov 15, 2011
Messages
18,518
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
tsukiyomis overrated. sasuke overcame it. kakashi stayed conscious for a few minutes after eating one

The databook clearly implies as much when saying Superman's mind would collapse.
lol so kishimoto doesnt know superman has his own astral and mental prowess and has resisted mindrape far more advanced than anything itachi can throw at him?
 

Uverdore9

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jan 11, 2018
Messages
6,232
Kin
846💸
Kumi
421💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I interpret it as the author affirming the readers that Itachi is stratospheres >>>>> MS Obito.

Itachi possesses immaculate illusory skills, spiritual tools, and an overall fundamentally better skillset, and physical strats. To be specific, his speed is grossly undermined when he could acclimate the features extrapolated below; not to mention the fact that an exorbitant skill degree in casting illusions implicits that this incarnation of Obito, stands absolutely no chance against Itachi, like literally none. The exact reason why this would be case is that illusory abilities are spiritual, the latter can't really ghost phase through them, which is probably why he chronically feared a hypothetical bout with MS Itachi—not to mention the spirit items that he has under his belt, something that's intrinsically linked to his illusory abilities technically — therein, it could be extrapolated that he wouldn't bypass such spiritual items with Kāmui.

Obito consigning Pēin to pillage the Leaf only after Itachi's death (ie., Obito concretely knew that Itachi planned to orchestrate the fight between him, and Sasuke Uchiha, than meet his Maker in that battle simulation like implicited by his back & forth with Sasuke Uchiha in that hideout), and failing to trounce the strongest village on the earth; ie., the Leaf, for straight 18 years implies that there is definitively an entity who pulled the strings beneath the surface area, and that is definitively Itachi Uchiha like exemplified by his inferiority statements, and concrete physical implications. If he was truly stronger than Itachi, then he wouldn't have needed to wait it out for such a long ass time. On the flip-side however — the latter not actively exchanging in an extended bout with the former can be rationalized as him not feeling like doin' it—as the author consistently alludes to the fact that Itachi didn't like fighting, and that he was an innate pacifist who got traumatized by the cycle of warfare that was rampant on earth from the time that he was a little child.

This doesn't apply to Obito; however, as he had every intention to make the Gedø Mazóu eat the Jinchūūriki Chakras to transfigurate a Watered Down Jūūbi like exemplified in the War Arc.

Itachi has a near infinite ways to kill MS Obito.

  • HQ 80,000 Fourth World War Shinobi Alliance Acolytes' Puppet Mind Controlling Exorbitant Illusory Skills
  • The Sword Of Totsuka + Mirror Of Yata
  • Explosive Tricky Chakra Bunshins; that not even Elite Dójūtsu Applicants like 3T Kakashi couldn't perceptively penetrate.
  • MS Techniques like Tsókóyomi and Amaterasu (which cannonically exterminated him from the scene — ie., required a most powerful illusory spell like Izānagi to bypass — striking the fact that Itachi himself utilizing that ability would be stratospheres more powerful by virtue of the whole "An Experienced Castor >>>>> A Novice" line of logicality.
  • Magnificent Immaculate Speed Features that exceeds anything Jūūbi Jinchūuriki Obito has accomplished in this series, let alone MS Obito.
  • Supplementally — a key fact that is often overlooked is that Obito can only spiritualize the part of his body that is preconceived to be stricken with an offensive attack — IE., he can't warp the entire physique if he wants to acclimate offensive damage on the enemy which implies that Itachi can twirl kunais and shurikens in his blind spots to to take him off-guard like he accomplished against a Quasi Prime ET Nagato; whom Obito admitted inferiority to—on 2 different occasions.
Even characters like Hashirama are susceptible to such supplemental damage — Therein; arguably, Obito doesn't fare any better in this battle simulation hypothetically.
Post automatically merged:

I interpret it as the author affirming the readers that Itachi is stratospheres >>>>> MS Obito.

Itachi possesses immaculate illusory skills, spiritual tools, and an overall fundamentally better skillset, and physical strats. To be specific, his speed is grossly undermined when he could acclimate the features extrapolated below; not to mention the fact that an exorbitant skill degree in casting illusions implicits that this incarnation of Obito, stands absolutely no chance against Itachi, like literally none. The exact reason why this would be case is that illusory abilities are spiritual, the latter can't really ghost phase through them, which is probably why he chronically feared a hypothetical bout with MS Itachi—not to mention the spirit items that he has under his belt, something that's intrinsically linked to his illusory abilities technically — therein, it could be extrapolated that he wouldn't bypass such spiritual items with Kāmui.

Obito consigning Pēin to pillage the Leaf only after Itachi's death (ie., Obito concretely knew that Itachi planned to orchestrate the fight between him, and Sasuke Uchiha, than meet his Maker in that battle simulation like implicited by his back & forth with Sasuke Uchiha in that hideout), and failing to trounce the strongest village on the earth; ie., the Leaf, for straight 18 years implies that there is definitively an entity who pulled the strings beneath the surface area, and that is definitively Itachi Uchiha like exemplified by his inferiority statements, and concrete physical implications. If he was truly stronger than Itachi, then he wouldn't have needed to wait it out for such a long ass time. On the flip-side however — the latter not actively exchanging in an extended bout with the former can be rationalized as him not feeling like doin' it—as the author consistently alludes to the fact that Itachi didn't like fighting, and that he was an innate pacifist who got traumatized by the cycle of warfare that was rampant on earth from the time that he was a little child.

This doesn't apply to Obito; however, as he had every intention to make the Gedø Mazóu eat the Jinchūūriki Chakras to transfigurate a Watered Down Jūūbi like exemplified in the War Arc.

Itachi has a near infinite ways to kill MS Obito.

  • HQ 80,000 Fourth World War Shinobi Alliance Acolytes' Puppet Mind Controlling Exorbitant Illusory Skills
  • The Sword Of Totsuka + Mirror Of Yata
  • Explosive Tricky Chakra Bunshins; that not even Elite Dójūtsu Applicants like 3T Kakashi couldn't perceptively penetrate.
  • MS Techniques like Tsókóyomi and Amaterasu (which cannonically exterminated him from the scene — ie., required a most powerful illusory spell like Izānagi to bypass — striking the fact that Itachi himself utilizing that ability would be stratospheres more powerful by virtue of the whole "An Experienced Castor >>>>> A Novice" line of logicality.
  • Magnificent Immaculate Speed Features that exceeds anything Jūūbi Jinchūuriki Obito has accomplished in this series, let alone MS Obito.
  • Supplementally — a key fact that is often overlooked is that Obito can only spiritualize the part of his body that is preconceived to be stricken with an offensive attack — IE., he can't warp the entire physique if he wants to acclimate offensive damage on the enemy which implies that Itachi can twirl kunais and shurikens in his blind spots to to take him off-guard like he accomplished against a Quasi Prime ET Nagato; whom Obito admitted inferiority to—on 2 different occasions.
Even characters like Hashirama are susceptible to such supplemental damage — Therein; arguably, Obito doesn't fare any better in this battle simulation hypothetically.
 
Top