it didn't just leave a mild cut on his shoulder, it did that across the whole area that the attack hit him, and that was much more damage than FRS did.
No, we got a close up of his shoulder, the cut was more prominent in the top and its size decreased down to the left side of his chest. We didn't get to see anything else, but its clear by the form of the cut that he wasn't injured anywhere else.
He wasn't shown to be stunned either, only briefly pushed back, the sealing unit couldn't even throw their cloth, unlike the time when he was struck by FRS.
Wait, in no way would giving the cloak to other characters = they'll still be injured by most attacks. The cloak chidori to the heart into a small cut, they'd be completely protected from any attack that was weaker than chidori, even ones as powerful as raiton enhanced blades.
Madara's katon that he used against the alliance wasn't of the highest level, his juubi-sized one is, and that's besides the point which is: fuuton having the elemental advantage does not mean it just treats the RnY as if it isn't there.
Temari and co's fuuton weren't on the same level as the FRS by temari's statements and reaction.
All that is speculation. Where was it stated that Chidori only made a small cut because of Ay's cloak? The Raikage(s) are durable because of their bodies, not because of their Raiton...
He overpowered several jutsus while having the elemental disadvantage and its not a high level jutsu because its not Bijuu sized? That's a ridiculous claim.
Futon nullifies the cloak not only because of its natural advantage but also because the cloak isn't meant for defense.
Whose Futon was superior doesn't matter here. What matters is that he tanked both attacks with moderate ease.
It's not just plausible, it's logically
You must be registered for see links
I have absolutely no idea how you can claim the bolded when we not only have explicit evidence of the V1 RnY blocking almost completely stopping chidori,
You must be registered for see links
and then the part where Sandaime takes far less damage from a far more powerful attack when he has the shield up. Even its name: raiton SHIELD implies it significantly increases the user's defenses.
Ay's comment can be interpreted in more than one way. He could be talking about speed, durability or the fact that Sasuke wasn't overwhelmed by electricity the moment he touched Ay. You already chose your option but for me this comment still remains ambiguous.
You can't measure how big the cloak's role was in tanking Sasuke's Chidori. For all we know Ay could very well have tanked most of the attack, which is very likely given the fact that his body is the source of his tankiness, something he inherited from the 3rd.
How Sasuke's sword went flying wasn't even showed... Ay possibly throwed it away, you can't tell.
....because we are explicitly shown that the cloak greatly increases their durability. IF Sasuke had hit base Ei with his chidori, Ei would be dead right now. If Naruto had hit base Sandaime raikage with FRS, sandaime would be dead right now. So if he can't tank something in base, it does not follow that he can't tank it with RnY, you have to compare how much his defenses increase when he uses the shield.
Not really. We're shown and told that the cloak increases their speed and that their bodies are what makes them tough < that is what i know its true.
You don't know if Ay or the 3rd would be dead, again, those are only assumptions determined by interpretation and opinion.
