Search results

nessos i will be open to considering alice more d2 but i still think voting in demon/ansa, scumreads of mine independent of mech stuff, feels better. also from a practical standpoint, nobody else is buying your sus of alice and the d1 probably can't happen, even if i started agreeing.

hm maybe i shoulda colored my readslist next time maybe, lazy now

alright ill be awake for a couple more hours still think demon should just be the d1 at this point.

aight heres the big fluffy rabbit eod1 post summary of important thoughts from my catchup: 1. still think we should be voting demon, as i think it's almost universally agreed that he's scummy, and i don't that's a sign he's town because his game is too weak for partners to defend. demon is...

okay instead of doing post by post replies im just gonna make a big summary post tbh, since it's near eod

he said later on that he isoed shanks and doesn't actually scumread him anymore

i just didn't find you towny yet from your posting up till that point, but i'm feeling a bit more now. i mean probably being a hypocrite, but it makes me worry about poison a bit when very few of her reads seem to have reasons. i figured that out later, nessos had talked about targeting...

sup guys, have randomly been reading on mobile but ill do a proper catchup now still think this should be the d1 vote, and i'm kinda worried we arent gonna be able to get maj?? Vote: Demon

if he's scum, could easily see one of {rej demon ansa} being a partner

yeah ok i could see myself voting salt

actually idk maybe im wrong on salt ill think about it more

thanks for quotes, nessos i can see how that looks bad for salt. but i'm not sure the quoted posts are enough for me to scumread him. the main thing is, we come from a role-light culture where d1 mech talk is often actually scummy, so johan and salt scumreading it naively might not actually be...

just isoed rej and he said he had a migraine? disappearance nai. nothing actually that scummy. could easily be scum, but probably don't want to consider voting him until he posts more still rather vote demon

wait i guess i should ask the more general question: do you make any behavioral scumreads or are you used to just mostly mech solving?

do you have a read on demon?

like alice's posts just read like she's reporting exactly what she experienced and the possible mech reasons for it, and i don't see why she'd make any of it up. it's nai at worst.

nessos i read alice's posts and i don't think she mech slipped d1, and that's not the kind of vote i'm comfortable with. i'd rather vote a behavioral scumread. could i ask why you scumread salt again?

i still just think demon is scum tbh when i reread the beginning of the game i had such conviction on page 1 and i dont trust my townread that i developed later because it wasn't in real time and it was just for some townreads, which he could probably do as scum, and i still have an instinct...

but in general i dont necessarily think heavy focus on game mechanics is scummy in itself, especially when this game is so mechanics heavy and people seem to have real disagreements being town doesnt necessarily make somebody less inclined to talk mech for pages straight i do think there is a...

before i answer that im probably going to do some rereading to double check if i still feel the same way (and to collect quotes) but before i do that rereading i need to do other stuff in life i can try to give a full readslist in like 5-6 hours