Search results

I don't remember him being especially suspicious of Red, and if Red was a Mafia member with him I doubt that she was the reason SoulKiller died, unless the other two members are basically non-entities. Which... does not feel right for me from a gut perspective. But I generally do not think it...

That's not how Mafia works. Mafia need to get town to die during the days to win the game. If all who ever dies during the day are Mafia, then they always lose. Power roles are a special type of unlynchable, unless you play role madness, since their claim alone will normally save them their...

Naomi is subbed out, so you'd have to vote for the replacement. Also, Naomi over Rej?

It adds a new perspective to her and influenced how she went on with the game from that point on, so yeah. I need to reread to see if her world building is consistent (but not forced), but it feels wholesome to me from my memory.

Mafia kill people threatening them. Threatening people are 1) power roles 2) unlynchable people 3) people with good reads in this order. I'm not sure anyone thought that he might be a power role and he definitely did not play in a way that made him unlynchable - his demeanor was very...

He was suspicious of Rej and me first and foremost and had Ansa as a potential deep wolf. Also suspicious of Moth and neutral on Poison, Luke and Elmage. This was an answer towards Rej, by the way.

Thanks for the link, Red, but it's not enough to shake my opinion for now. I will keep watching her going forward, but I don't think that Poison is the most suspect player right now.

An easy way to see who SK felt uneasy about is to look at who he voted. His last vote was on Rej, for example, so that is one. I personally remember him feeling suspect about me because.. well, it was me. I need to ISO him though to see who else he threatened. Regarding Poison, I see her ISOs...

From an outsiders perspective, if you are town you make for a fine mislynch at this point in time.

Interesting list. I'm looking forward to your reasoning. Can you narrow down the number? "At least" is a bit imprecise.

Exactly. We need to treat his flip as if we had mislynched a Vanilla Town yesterday regarding all purposes of the game. The scum team didn't know he was NOT town and thus they had all reason to be okay with his lynch as well.

I personally do not think it's Poison, unless I misunderstood something. Also, you should add another person to that list. If it is about feeling threatened by SoulKiller you need to consider all people SK felt uneasy about. Which would include Rej and myself.

..Wait, WHAT?

I do think that they are a bit above rand scum. I don't have anybody else that I can explain my suspicion on in that one minute I still have before leaving (and not coming back until an hour after EOD) and I do think that her scum likelihood is higher than her town likelihood based on her latest...

Also, just saying this right now, Rej: As town, if you ISO, you should always look for the points for AND against your argument, or at least have a good explanation for why the good points are no good points after all. It is town's job to figure out others and it is only natural that we might...

This is the moment when I finally realize that I will miss EOD since Wednesday is my late sports day. Which is kinda unfortunate. Unfortunately I did not have enough time to read far enough into the Rej-Moth argument to cast my vote there, on either of them. I did not get the scum vibes from...

The thing is, what Moth has pointed out wasn't inactivity - I'd gladly lynch half the game over it - but rather, not playing while interacting with the game itself. I am more than willing to listen to your explanation for why you cannot play and why you lost interest in playing the game. But you...

I'll be busy for the next few hours. Moth, a reminder to stay civil with your arguments. Even if, and that is a big if (I still lean town with some questions that I will ask him about later) , Rej was power wolfing I'd like to remind you that his wolf rand would be a chance, not a choice, and...

Sure, let's get those YAOI vibes going. So who is uke, who is seme?

Stuff tends to lead to more stuff tends to lead to screaming and shouting and forceful sub outs. You are welcome though.