[Suggestion] Custom RP submission

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tsukune

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
12,622
Kin
105💸
Kumi
60💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Well, i was wondering. Could a thread be implemented where an RPer can submit an idea for site like NB tai, gen, and ken came to be? Like a special faction of jutsu, or even custom elements like rain/sound that could require a test to be passed? Even customs themselves, that can be learned then taught?

Any thoughts, suggestions, questions, feedback will be appreciated^^


Disclaimer: By posting in this thread you abide by all global rules, as such any spam, flaming etc will be reported. In addition, i'd like the feedback to be positive, don't say things like "Stupid idea" or "Would never work" even if you believe so.
 

Urda

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Aug 4, 2011
Messages
23,637
Kin
2,223💸
Kumi
7,705💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Are there not threads for the above mention? (=_=? Custom: Jutsu; and Element. Also, a Tai. Thread created by Scorps. Seems all nice and all, but what is the purpose? Members can just teach others their Jutsu. Allowing a test would just add an extra rule to something easy to obtain. It would also ruin the originalty.

You said be positive..... Make it more useful for all members. -Shrugs. *I think thats what you mean. (=_=)
 

Lyanna Stark

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 5, 2010
Messages
6,358
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I see wereyour coming from and i agree there are some things that need to beallowed to everyone such as some ce im not going to say any but they really unfair for just one person to have.The thing is it woud put everyone on equal and the older members might quit because of this.as some may not be liking the thought of being beaten by newer rpers as we knw several people do.(once again not mentioning names)There is also a load of old ce and cj that members who have left have allowed no one to cary on such as blood release(CE)I believe a test to be put in for someone to be able to gain the ce and others that have the samesituation.
 

Luther

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Sep 17, 2011
Messages
11,547
Kin
19💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Well, i was wondering. Could a thread be implemented where an RPer can submit an idea for site like NB tai, gen, and ken came to be? Like a special faction of jutsu, or even custom elements like rain/sound that could require a test to be passed? Even customs themselves, that can be learned then taught?

Any thoughts, suggestions, questions, feedback will be appreciated^^


Disclaimer: By posting in this thread you abide by all global rules, as such any spam, flaming etc will be reported. In addition, i'd like the feedback to be positive, don't say things like "Stupid idea" or "Would never work" even if you believe so.
You can not enforce someone opinion, and if my opinion is negative in regards to this suggestion, i am entitled to say it,provided it does not go against the global rules. I do not like the idea and feel it is unnecessary and would not showcase any positives if implemented.
 

Tsukune

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
12,622
Kin
105💸
Kumi
60💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Are there not threads for the above mention? (=_=? Custom: Jutsu; and Element. Also, a Tai. Thread created by Scorps. Seems all nice and all, but what is the purpose? Members can just teach others their Jutsu. Allowing a test would just add an extra rule to something easy to obtain. It would also ruin the originalty.

You said be positive..... Make it more useful for all members. -Shrugs. *I think thats what you mean. (=_=)
You misinterpret, what i am trying to say here. (I thought the examples would be dead giveaways lol) As an RPer, what if i have the idea to share an element, that i've created with the whole RPer community, just requiring permission or a test in order to learn it? Why can't there be a submission thread for this, that encompasses the whole RPer base? And not just teach it to a select few people.

I see wereyour coming from and i agree there are some things that need to be allowed to everyone such as some ce im not going to say any but they really unfair for just one person to have.The thing is it would put everyone on equal and the older members might quit because of this.as some may not be liking the thought of being beaten by newer rpers as we know several people do.(once again not mentioning names)There is also a load of old ce and cj that members who have left have allowed no one to carry on such as blood release(CE)I believe a test to be put in for someone to be able to gain the ce and others that have the same situation.
Well no, you also misunderstand. I don't mean to take CE/CJ etc created in the past, require a test to be learned and such, i mean a thread in which one creates say, a CFS for the RP itself. (CJ's and CE's are there creators property, unless we garnered permission we'd never be able to do such a thing)

You can not enforce someone opinion, and if my opinion is negative in regards to this suggestion, i am entitled to say it,provided it does not go against the global rules. I do not like the idea and feel it is unnecessary and would not showcase any positives if implemented.
You ought to read carefully, i said i'd like it to be positive, i mean if you want to be a complete jerk off, and be negative or un-constructive to the idea then your opinion is just un-needed. Was i enforcing it? Was i threatening to report you, or neg rep you, or go to a mod to infract you or some such thing? I was not, so there is no enforcing your opinion going on. It just seems like you had the intent to try and bash an idea without actually considering anything before posting.

Now then onto your opinion, un-necessary, possibly, but no positives? I disagree, to my knowledge aside from KG or special clan techniques, there are only three special elements: Rain, Sound, and Smoke. All lovely elements really, but what if an RPer wanted something different, not as a power boost having multiple, just wanted a different kind say as a random example acid? (I know its been created, and thats implausible, but like i said random example) Now, take that idea, and project it over the entire facet of the RP, with CFS's, CJ's, etc that can be learnt like NB tai or NB gen and such. Another random example, some well sounded minds could come together, and create NB nin, just like scorps, and emperor created NB gen, or izuna created NB ken (i apologize if others helped, i am unaware) or how izanami kaito/zenryoku created NB tai. The possibilities, and applications are entirely useful.

A sidenote to you personally thunderbolt, i know you've suggested many things in the past, and they got criticized, or bashed or whatever else, but theres no need to do the same to others without actually considering things. Like i said, your post kind of doesn't really even follow what i was saying, it looks like you skimmed it and may have gotten the wrong idea.
 

Blizzàrd1

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
13,534
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Its a cool thought but I will disagree with it. The only reason for that is because the ideas like NB Tai or NB Gen is what makes those things very unique. And not only that they reflect one of the greatest Role-players that role-played on the base and as a gift from them to the newer generation. It seems like a gold trophy and making it that common will just destroy that purpose. Not only that, it will also add to the OP'edness of some already super powered RP'iers. Ending up with more arguments and more things to worry about.
 

Tsukune

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
12,622
Kin
105💸
Kumi
60💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Its a cool thought but I will disagree with it. The only reason for that is because the ideas like NB Tai or NB Gen is what makes those things very unique. And not only that they reflect one of the greatest Role-players that role-played on the base and as a gift from them to the newer generation. It seems like a gold trophy and making it that common will just destroy that purpose. Not only that, it will also add to the OP'edness of some already super powered RP'iers. Ending up with more arguments and more things to worry about.
That may be true, but can one not become worth the possibility to create such a thing? I find that, if the ideas and everything else set into place by it were sound, it wouldn't be dulling the shining glory of the other things created in the past. As for OPedness aspect, thats generally a problem normally, but this being how it is, one could i don't know, say you can only learn two of these special facets of the RP such as: NB gen, and NB tai, or a special element submitted(This would automatically exclude the other special elements), and NB tai etc. It doesn't have to be a drive for power if we don't let it be. And let me make it clear, since basically ANYONE would be able to learn it(Provided they fit requirements,) it wouldn't really make anyone OP since others can learn it.

Feedback, is much appreciated despite your view on it^^
 

Alternative

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 27, 2011
Messages
6,373
Kin
300💸
Kumi
304💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I don't like the idea of "NB Gen". Emperor's Circus of Penguins or whatever it's called sounds much cooler. U_U
Stupid idea wouldn't work
Joking aside, wouldn't this kind of fall under the whole CFS ordeal? Either that, or custom clans? They seem to be very similar but just on a wider scale of teaching than those two. Maybe if something like this were to be implemented, it would require big accomplishments, like Official Sage or whatever.
 

Tsukune

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
12,622
Kin
105💸
Kumi
60💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I don't like the idea of "NB Gen". Emperor's Circus of Penguins or whatever it's called sounds much cooler. U_U
Stupid idea wouldn't work
Joking aside, wouldn't this kind of fall under the whole CFS ordeal? Either that, or custom clans? They seem to be very similar but just on a wider scale of teaching than those two. Maybe if something like this were to be implemented, it would require big accomplishments, like Official Sage or whatever.
lol

No, it wouldn't. CFS's can only be taught to 6 people whereas a CFS approved in the site submission thread could be taught to anyone, as long as they have a valid sensei status. Yea exactly, just with sound requirements.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Braveknight
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top