Problems with the battle system...

Rei

Legendary
Joined
May 22, 2008
Messages
12,015
Kin
5,001,259💸
Kumi
527💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I semi agree with this... i think people should be tested in terms of smarts, strategic thinking, and performance, its easy for someone to say they have alot of experience but its because they spar with the same person 100 times...
yeah it would be an overall review about all those things you have mentioned, not only jutsus, that's the key-idea. to set the ranks according not to the jutsus someone can use, but to how they are used and when.
There are battles here where ppl only post jutsus not even "i dodge that with that"...i don't like them, they are just copy-paste.

I agree with the FIRST part of this...
I think the sensei's approval is key... i think that after they get the sensei's approval 1 mod would be enough though... this would also give alot of relevance to the Order Of Elemental Sages too... 3 approvals would take way too long and be too arduous of a process to even bother with... and what happens if one of the members takes a leave of absence like madara... madara should be in charge of either lightning or fire... and hes not here right now... and if this goes into effect i can kiss the making of ANY water customs goodbye...
That's not how it will work, cause if the jutsus get first judged by the senseis, that means that in the current jutsu submission thread the mods will have to check the 1/3 of them, cause most will be declined in the way. it's less work for the mods and since the senseis will judge the "overpowerness" and the "dodge-ability" of them, mods will have to only make sure that senseis are being fair for all^^
also it wont be only one sensei for every element. it was an example.

Meh... i still kinda like 2... its not that easy to get to 10,000 posts... even for spammers...
there should be a time requirement of like 6 months added to the second one though imo...

Dont really see the point of this...
too much work for nexus...
and again what if nexus takes another break?
it is not easy i know, but it is pointless.
imagine this: now most of the members who fight have a post count around 5,000 more or less, its still an example don't stick to the number.
In 2 months they will all have 10,000 and then everyone will have 2 elements. what will happen then? an idea of a 3rd element will be dropped sooner or later. and it will become an endless circle ^^

Nexus is a very hard working person and cares for eth to be fair, still if he doesn't want to do it alone, the work can be split.
 

Devlin

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jan 16, 2009
Messages
4,821
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I think if your going to use his rules rei or are considering them i think you should make a thread bullet pointing everything,compare it to another set of rules or ideas then add a poll to it......:rolleyes:
 

Rei

Legendary
Joined
May 22, 2008
Messages
12,015
Kin
5,001,259💸
Kumi
527💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I think if your going to use his rules rei or are considering them i think you should make a thread bullet pointing everything,compare it to another set of rules or ideas then add a poll to it......:rolleyes:
Of course, nothing will be implemented without the members approval and Zanji is typing down more details about the battling system -with his ideas not mine-.
When he is done they will be brought up to discussion and voting.
 

Devlin

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jan 16, 2009
Messages
4,821
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Of course, nothing will be implemented without the members approval and Zanji is typing down more details about the battling system -with his ideas not mine-.
When he is done they will be brought up to discussion and voting.
Yeh thats no problems only reason i say that is so that it sums this whole thread up and what the rules would be etc....that way people get a clear outline of what they would be agreeing/disagreeing with not to dimene anyone just saying for those that might not understand and for the noobies who didn't know the original rules etc.... ;)
 

BishamonSama

Active member
Supreme
Joined
May 1, 2008
Messages
20,688
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
The topic is about that they are spamming their way up to battle ranks not spamming the forum in general.
o_O?

So?

It's still spamming, isn't it? O_O

If they're spamming their ways up to their battle ranks, that still fits under the category of spamming in general, and should be taken care of by the mods...

If they're spamming in the Chatterbox area, there's nothing to do about it, because that area's made for spamming. That is unless, of course, we put in some rules there... which wouldn't be a bad thing.
 

BishamonSama

Active member
Supreme
Joined
May 1, 2008
Messages
20,688
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I'd just like to add that TOURNAMENTS DON'T WORK.... never in the entire history of NB has there been one tournament that's actually ended... they fall apart.

The thing is, people don't like following structure on NB, probably on the internet in general.

Luckily, the Sensei Rules work well, but the Mission System is tanking pretty hard because of the lack of Mod support (I.E., people can't track their progress, and mods don't check over the missions quickly enough, which is not the mods' fault. They just need help.)

The Sensei system works because the senseis themselves help in the system; they administer tests and whatnot, so it's easier on the mods.

So Tsukoshi's/Rei's system might work, as they include the senseis. I think.
 

Zanji

Active member
Elite
Joined
May 13, 2008
Messages
8,720
Kin
8💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
hey hey hey hey hey I am working on sth as well :/ and it doesn't involve your post count AT all ^^

its different than what has been going on with the rules for the elements and the battling :p

just give me some time and I will have it done in no time hopefully by 12:30 am (central) 1:30 (Eastern) 6:30 (London) 8:30 (Greece) ^^
 

-Naruto Uzumaki-

Active member
Elite
Joined
Dec 12, 2008
Messages
6,520
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
hey hey hey hey hey I am working on sth as well :/ and it doesn't involve your post count AT all ^^

its different than what has been going on with the rules for the elements and the battling :p

just give me some time and I will have it done in no time hopefully by 12:30 am (central) 1:30 (Eastern) 6:30 (London) 8:30 (Greece) ^^
Thanks, Zanji.

I can't believe my thread was a success... The Battle Arena rules may actually get changed...
 

BishamonSama

Active member
Supreme
Joined
May 1, 2008
Messages
20,688
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
hey hey hey hey hey I am working on sth as well :/ and it doesn't involve your post count AT all ^^

its different than what has been going on with the rules for the elements and the battling :p

just give me some time and I will have it done in no time hopefully by 12:30 am (central) 1:30 (Eastern) 6:30 (London) 8:30 (Greece) ^^
If I come on MSN will you show me what you have so far? O_O?
 

Kiwii

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jan 23, 2009
Messages
6,170
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
hey hey hey hey hey I am working on sth as well :/ and it doesn't involve your post count AT all ^^

its different than what has been going on with the rules for the elements and the battling :p

just give me some time and I will have it done in no time hopefully by 12:30 am (central) 1:30 (Eastern) 6:30 (London) 8:30 (Greece) ^^
I cant wait for those... I hope that with those rules people start to use weapons and papper bombs and stuff (and their heads ) into the battle.
 

Rei

Legendary
Joined
May 22, 2008
Messages
12,015
Kin
5,001,259💸
Kumi
527💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
o_O?

So?

It's still spamming, isn't it? O_O

If they're spamming their ways up to their battle ranks, that still fits under the category of spamming in general, and should be taken care of by the mods...

If they're spamming in the Chatterbox area, there's nothing to do about it, because that area's made for spamming. That is unless, of course, we put in some rules there... which wouldn't be a bad thing.
ofc we are talking about the chatterbox, if you have some ideas about rules there, suggest them, i agree it could be useful.
and handling with the spam is not that easy as it may seem to you since many ppl don't even know what "spam" means, not to mention that some of them can't just admit the fact that they did spam, they can't even see it.

I'd just like to add that TOURNAMENTS DON'T WORK.... never in the entire history of NB has there been one tournament that's actually ended... they fall apart.
Maybe, but if the senseis and mods work together this might change, anyway it's the least important thing that one.

Luckily, the Sensei Rules work well, but the Mission System is tanking pretty hard because of the lack of Mod support (I.E., people can't track their progress, and mods don't check over the missions quickly enough, which is not the mods' fault. They just need help.)
Only 2 mods have powers there, so Zanji and I have no word there, not to mention that sometimes we can't agree with each other, simply cause we are different people with different personalities and I for example don't think that the missions should have been added with the current battling system, so i stay away^^
 
Top