If Madara gave his eyes to Nagato, why was he revived with rinnegan?

[Tagen]

What people thought was that Madara died with his rinnegan, and tobi was the one who implanted them into Nagato. In the recent chapter, we found out that Madara had given his eyes to Nagato already, before his death, so how on earth was Madara revived with his original sharingan/rinnegan?

I'm not taking ''Kabuto made him get revived with it'' as a valid response.

/Discuss

 

[Mischeif Maker]

go read how edo tensei works then read how kabuto made madara special etc

once you get all that info you will know your answer

 

[Tagen]

How edo tensei works

. You are revived as you are when you died.

 

[jt1891]

What people thought was that Madara died with his rinnegan, and tobi was the one who implanted them into Nagato. In the recent chapter, we found out that Madara had given his eyes to Nagato already, before his death, so how on earth was Madara revived with his original sharingan/rinnegan?

I'm not taking ''Kabuto made him get revived with it'' as a valid response.

/Discuss

That's really the only answer your going to get because it's the only possible one.

 

[Kyuubibomb]

when Tobi said he did it he was speaking as if he was Madara so everything he said during that time he did was actually the real Madara.

Bringing this up about Madara you need to bring up why Nagato and Itachi have there eyes still when they where taken from them.

sometimes you just have to accept it, thats how the edo tensie works.

 

[iSpeak]

How edo tensei works

. You are revived as you are when you died.

Never ever been stated anywhere in the Manga or Databooks whatsoever.

 

[Redemption]

What people thought was that Madara died with his rinnegan, and tobi was the one who implanted them into Nagato. In the recent chapter, we found out that Madara had given his eyes to Nagato already, before his death, so how on earth was Madara revived with his original sharingan/rinnegan?

I'm not taking ''Kabuto made him get revived with it'' as a valid response.

/Discuss

just like nagato and itachi were revived with their occular abillities even though post mortem they were removed from their corpses.It was written in their DNA that they posses those occular abillities.And you need ones dna to use edo tensei to revive him--->revived with rinnegan because it's written in your dna that you posses them

 

[Kyuubibomb]

just like nagato and itachi were revived with their occular abillities even though post mortem they were removed from their corpses.It was written in their DNA that they posses those occular abillities.And you need ones dna to use edo tensei to revive him--->revived with rinnegan because it's written in your dna that you posses them

amazing example +rep

 

[stu21]

Well but that was the case because Kabuto said the Madara was revived beyond his prime...

 

[Tagen]

when Tobi said he did it he was speaking as if he was Madara so everything he said during that time he did was actually the real Madara.

Bringing this up about Madara you need to bring up why Nagato and Itachi have there eyes still when they where taken from them.

sometimes you just have to accept it, thats how the edo tensie works.

Nagato and Itachi were revived with their eyes, because their eyes where still on their bodies when they died.

just like nagato and itachi were revived with their occular abillities even though post mortem they were removed from their corpses.It was written in their DNA that they posses those occular abillities.And you need ones dna to use edo tensei to revive him--->revived with rinnegan because it's written in your dna that you posses them

Exactly, Madara died without his eyes, therefore should be revived without them

 

[Troyg39]

That's not even the real question here. The real question is how on earth did he end up surviving the Hashi fight, and end up dying in the first place. And also, how on earth did he manage to even get his eyes transplanted if he himself said he can't even leave that little cave he's in

 

[Devo]

just like nagato and itachi were revived with their occular abillities even though post mortem they were removed from their corpses.It was written in their DNA that they posses those occular abillities.And you need ones dna to use edo tensei to revive him--->revived with rinnegan because it's written in your dna that you posses them

revived with rinnegan because it's written in your dna that you posses them

It is not written in Nagato's DNA that he posses Rinnegan. So how is he revived with rinnegan?

There is a big flaw in edo tensei i think......

 

[narutonish]

The thing is, EDO TENSEI has broken the plot and has led to enormous speculations. Everything is right and at the same time everything is wrong

Thats why I think, the manga is not interesting any more, Kishi just brings things out of his ass, you cant actually guess whats coming anymore.

 

[Redemption]

Nagato and Itachi were revived with their eyes, because their eyes where still on their bodies when they died.



Exactly, Madara died without his eyes, therefore should be revived without them

dude,dna imprints in itself every expirience it has,so if kabuto got hold of madara's dna from when he still possessed the rinnegan,than that's how he will be revived,it was never stated that he got madara's dna from his corpse.Given the fact that we don't know how,when and where did kabutomaru/orochimaru got madara's dna,we can only go by what the manga gives us,and that is that kabuto revived madara beyond his prime.Young,healthy,rinnegan,senju dna...it's just like how itachi was reveived with full ms abilities even though he was almost blind when he died(to lazy to search for the page,but if you find it,you can see that he doesn't have ms/3 tomoe at the moment he walk to sasuke at the ending of the battle,yet he is still alive)

 

[Kyuubibomb]

dude,dna imprints in itself every expirience it has,so if kabuto got hold of madara's dna from when he still possessed the rinnegan,than that's how he will be revived,it was never stated that he got madara's dna from his corpse.Given the fact that we don't know how,when and where did kabutomaru/orochimaru got madara's dna,we can only go by what the manga gives us,and that is that kabuto revived madara beyond his prime.Young,healthy,rinnegan,senju dna...it's just like how itachi was reveived with full ms abilities even though he was almost blind when he died(to lazy to search for the page,but if you find it,you can see that he doesn't have ms/3 tomoe at the moment he walk to sasuke at the ending of the battle,yet he is still alive)

thanks for explaining that couldn't be bothered XD

 

[apple pie of doom]

I don't know to be honest.
I'm also wondering why he is'nt an old man, since he's supposed to come back as he was ( I know he was ''perfected'', but this is kind of ridiculous ).
Even if so, would'nt this mean hos original plan would entail him to come back as an old man without the rinnegan ( rinne tensei ).
Bit strange, but I'm glad he came out with his powers at the top anyway.

 

[Tagen]

dna imprints in itself every expirience it has,so if kabuto got hold of madara's dna from when he still possessed the rinnegan,than that's how he will be revived,it was never stated that he got madara's dna from his corpse.

This is the best answer, and most plausible on this thread. +rep

 

[GdaTyler]

That's not even the real question here. The real question is how on earth did he end up surviving the Hashi fight, and end up dying in the first place. And also, how on earth did he manage to even get his eyes transplanted if he himself said he can't even leave that little cave he's in

You must be registered for see images

 

[psukkar]

go read how edo tensei works then read how kabuto made madara special etc

once you get all that info you will know your answer

what u talkign about,

hey give him a break dude, thats one thing long shot ur ideas

 

[Troyg39]

You must be registered for see images

Fail meme you troll. What part of "I can't leave this cave" do you not understand? The Mazou isn't portable. And he has no other way of life support. Otherwise Madara wouldn't have said "I can't leave this cave and I can't go away from this Mazou or I'll die". Smh