Something weird about Tobi's S/T Jutsu...

[ShishaMastah420]

Now we've seen that when a part of the body is warped, it is violently ripped from the body as a whole;

You must be registered for see images

I use Kakashi's Kamui as an example, simply because it applies a simple logic; Something is being warped to a different dimension.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Now; Tobi's S/T Jutsu has been described as him warping the part of his body that is about to be inflicted with damage;

You must be registered for see images

As you can see above; what Tobi's S/T Jutsu does is warp a part of his body instead of the whole thing to a different dimension.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The things that i find weird is that;

How is Tobi able to warp his face without killing himself due to destroying his brain?

How is Tobi able to warp portions of his body but that portion of his body is still visible outside of the dimension it was warped to?

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

As you can see here;

You must be registered for see images

Deidara's arm no longer exist in the Earth Realm and it is ripped from his body, leaving him injured...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In conclusion; I don't think Tobi is simply using "One Jutsu" as Kakashi so proudly proclaimed, i think there is more to learn

Tell me your thoughts on this matter folks
Agree?Disagree?

 

[Hipster Madara]

I think Tobi is more skilled at using it and so does not hurt himself.
Also,why would Kakashi warp back Deidara's arm?

 

[R4mbl3]

Good thought, +rep. But i think Tobi's S/T jutsu is just more advanced..I mean, its the only reason explaining why he doesn't die from it.

 

[ITACHIUCHIA101]

i think since it is his jutsu and since the dimensions are overlapping thatit doesn't actully hurt him, or it is because he is part zetsu

 

[Punk Hazard]

This is what I've been saying! It makes no sense to me either.

 

[Awkward Linguist]

Kakashi's version is a doujutsu.

And Tobi's version is a Ninjutsu.

Ninjutsu won't hurt the user. Well most anyway...

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

An astute observation. I don't believe that Tobi's and Kakahsi's jutsu are the same, merely that they use the same dimension.

I will say that because Tobi remains "visible" in the real world, that he is somehow coexisting in both dimensions. It's difficult to make any assumptions beyond this though.

 

[Ldude]

I agree. I've thought about this before, and I think there are two possibilities:
1. It is not one jutsu, as you explained.
2. Kishimoto made an inconsistency in the story.

 

[ANBU Kakashi23]

i think kakashi's eye is offensive and meant to be used in an attack where tobi's eye is defense and meant to be used to enhance his defensive capabilities, kind of like how one of sasuke's eyes can cast amaterasu and the other can cloak himself in it

 

[nak]

tobis jutsu aint kamui yes?
they just use the same dimension and this^
if they are both obitos eyes, left eye "defence", right "offence"

dunno

 

[pervysage69]

Kakashi's version is a doujutsu.

And Tobi's version is a Ninjutsu.

Ninjutsu won't hurt the user. Well most anyway...

This is your answer and explanation for another difference between the two, when Kakashi uses it he has to use MS Tobi does not have MS active and is able to use his S/T jutsu. They are not using the same technique they are just using the same dimension for the technique.

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

i think kakashi's eye is offensive and meant to be used in an attack where tobi's eye is defense and meant to be used to enhance his defensive capabilities, kind of like how one of sasuke's eyes can cast amaterasu and the other can cloak himself in it

This right here ^^

And also I think because tobi is an uchiha and if he is obito then because it is his eye he is much more skilled with it and has better control I think this and what I quoted so be about right.

 

[nak]

and the as kakashi said "exists" in the pther world, but is still in this one whitout being actually here sound dumb tho

 

[Normal fanboy]

This the shit I don't like bang bang.

 

[ShishaMastah420]

I think Tobi is more skilled at using it and so does not hurt himself.
Also,why would Kakashi warp back Deidara's arm?

I'm not saying he would warp it back, but he did warp it to the the other dimension so isn't visible in the Earth Realm anymore

Kakashi's version is a doujutsu.

And Tobi's version is a Ninjutsu.

Ninjutsu won't hurt the user. Well most anyway...

Maybe... But the Jutsu is still transporting a portion of himself to somewhere else....

An astute observation. I don't believe that Tobi's and Kakahsi's jutsu are the same, merely that they use the same dimension.

I will say that because Tobi remains "visible" in the real world, that he is somehow coexisting in both dimensions. It's difficult to make any assumptions beyond this though.

How is he able to co-exist in both worlds o.o????

Weird

 

[thegame]

Well if u transfers just a part of a subject, obviously it should be ripped apart, also read from right to left........ it's almost as tobis, just not as perfect... not "violent"

 

[C WET]

i think that it is as simple as attack, and defense... think about it... if you want to hurt someone do like kakashi did.. as an attack... where as what tobi is doing is protecting himself.. i'd be willing to bet that he can do the same thing kakashi can do... oh wait we've seen it a shit load of times... but instead of ripping parts of ones body he just takes the whole person and puts them in his secret dimension ... i don't think it's that hard to understand guys...:ice:

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

Ok guys let's cut the crap, its BS it's all BS if kishi made the body part disappear we would know all along that he was using one jutsu so he had to make it seem like he was going ghost mode.

We just have to expect kishi's explanation he made the series he is god of the naruto world. If he says it doesn't exist in the real world but is still visible we just have to expect it.

 

[ShishaMastah420]

i think kakashi's eye is offensive and meant to be used in an attack where tobi's eye is defense and meant to be used to enhance his defensive capabilities, kind of like how one of sasuke's eyes can cast amaterasu and the other can cloak himself in it

Hmm Good point... Nonetheless the fundamentals aren't changing, He is still warping a portion of himself to a different dimension, which as we've seen should not allow him to retain that portion in the dimension it was warped from...

i think that it is as simple as attack, and defense... think about it... if you want to hurt someone do like kakashi did.. as an attack... where as what tobi is doing is protecting himself.. i'd be willing to bet that he can do the same thing kakashi can do... oh wait we've seen it a shit load of times... but instead of ripping parts of ones body he just takes the whole person and puts them in his secret dimension ... i don't think it's that hard to understand guys...:ice:

Its simple yet it makes no sense...

How is it possible that Tobi can co-exist in both dimensions?

Its not like he didn't warp that portion of his body because as you can see when Kakashi warped the Kamui, it hit the portion of Tobi's body that he warped away...

In the colored Scan,IMO, Tobi and Kakashi are basically doing the same thing; Warping something to a different dimension... Except what Tobi does makes no sense...

 

[MrSimple]

And this brings me back to Kakashi's MS, and how he awaken it...

Danzou was using teleportation and an incredible strong genjutsu with normal sharringan, while, no one in uchiha was using such techniques with normal sharringan but Tobi and Danzou doing it, while Kakashi an non- Uchiha using doujutsu with a connection with tobi's jutsu... it's too much..................