Kakashi's Kamui and Tobi's S/T ninjutsu being connected doesn't make sense!

[EpicRamenGuy]

tobi gets hit cus he was intangible, when he warps his body there thats when kakashi kamui hits him. i think that when kakashi tried kamui on tobi it didnt work because its just sending him to that dimension where he can easily come back and he is very familiar with that dimension so it didnt phase him cus he could easily come back.

 

[CurseSealofEarth]

The dimension is a mirror of the "real" dimension, that's why we can see Tobi when he is intangible. So when Kakashi sent the Rasengan to the other dimension and Tobi was still intangible he was hit as if he had been tangible and the Rasengan was still in the real dimension.

 

[LordHokage22]

So THAT'S how Tobi got another arm xD he took deidara's from the dimension! hahaha kidding. But yeah. If Tobi was ghost mode when Kakashi sent the arrow to a different dimension, Tobi would be dead

 

[Bloodytaste]

Its easy, while he is tangibale his body is in the other Dimension. If an Attack is beeing send there, there is a good chance to hit him, cuz his materilized body is still stuck at tobis dimension. Its rather easy then comlicated~

 

[LordHokage22]

tobi gets hit cus he was intangible, when he warps his body there thats when kakashi kamui hits him. i think that when kakashi tried kamui on tobi it didnt work because its just sending him to that dimension where he can easily come back and he is very familiar with that dimension so it didnt phase him cus he could easily come back.

Exactly!

 

[beastbomb9]

ATTACK- with somthing like rasengan, paper bomb , TBB and make Tobi has to use his S/T jutsu right after the attack
KAMUI- while tobi is in his S/T jutsu kakashi uses kamui on the attack to send it where Tobi is

when kakashi threw the kuni tobi redirected it at Naruto thts when kakashi was like dont worry about the kuni so naruto didnt dodge it he attacked tobi instead kakashi used kamui to get rid of the kuni tht was coming at naruto and narutos attack made tobi use his S/T jutsu thats how he got the scratch on his mask and kakashi being the genius he is figured all tht out in tht instant

 

[Evolve81]

When tobi is intangible whatever is in the dimension via kamui can affect tobi. Tobi was solid during the times you talk about. None of his mass was in the other dimension so he was not affected.

I have to agree with you on this one.
The reason Tobi was hit by the Rasengan is because Kakashi warped the Rasengan in the same dimension and area that Tobi was in. And Tobi must be able to warp differing parts of his body to that other diminsion, it may not have to just be strictly his whole body all at once, but I question how he is able to keep himself visible while he is warped in the other dimension?

 

[ANBU Kakashi23]

its not like those attacks just sit in a frozen state of motion and wait for tobi to use his intangibility, its a parallel dimension , its safe to assume that if the attack isnt happening in real time, then the attack wont connect with his body

 

[Q of the Sharingan]

1. The dimension is large.
2. Tobi has to be intangible for things in that dimension to affect him.

Just because there is an explosion in the pocket dimension doesn't mean it will hit Tobi wherever he is. Tobi's intangible body is in one place in the pocket dimension so anything sent there would have to actually hit him there.

 

[XxOUTZxX]

i think that when kakashi uses kamui around a close area to tobi when he goes intangible causes tobi to warp what ever kamui warped too....that is why when he became tangible again the rasengan reappeared

 

[festus 05]

he was obviousely not in the dimension when they ewrw being warped

 

[XxOUTZxX]

he was obviousely not in the dimension when they ewrw being warped

he warped/phased his arm to avoid naruto's rasengan...

 

[VangBro95]

Because he wasn't in other dimension when they got warped.