It's fairly certain that Tobi is not a previously mentioned Character. Rebuttal?

[WZRD]

Tobi can't be Shisui. He was found dead in a river and based on his profile he was a stand up guy. He may not even have been a Uchiha. I think he may be some sort of experiment by Orochimaru from the early days, while he was trying to splice senju and uchiha cells. At first sight, he seems to know quite a bit about Madara, more than an average person would know. But, should not one of the greatest clan member's biographies be well known throughout the Uchiha Clan? And, stated from memory, EdoMadara didn't say anything about Tobi to Kabuto-Controlled EdoMuu. In the few instances that Tobi fights, he seems to lose appendages with regularity, and what is shown of his body seems to be similar to the make-up of Zetsu. Thoughts?

 

[jordan1]

we'll just have to wait for kishi to show

 

[Truffy]

Yeah. I have some thoughts, but its not about your thread :shrug: Welcome to
NB btw.

 

[WZRD]

C'mon, you guys gotta give me something.

 

[-Broly-]

C'mon, you guys gotta give me something.

Of course he's not shisui for the exact reason that you said plus he izuna lol

 

[IamMe]

I figure it is most likely an uchiha, just for knowing the moon eye plan. My monies on madara's brother

 

[WZRD]

And how would Izuna have survived longer than Madara, especially when it was implicitly hinted that he died after he gave his eyes to madara? I don't think there was much of an overlap with his approx lifespan and Orochimaru's either.

 

[dariusartigo]

For me tobi is somewhat Obito, one of the teammate of Kakashi when they are genin. because the sharinggan of tobi is just something similar to kakasshi. we all know that obito give his left eye to kakashi and tobi havd only sharinggan in his right eye. the technique also th same to kakashi, a dimensional sharinggan. it is the sharingan in which only tobi can manipulated because he is a pure uchiha and not one of the kind kakashi can manipulate this kind of technique due his not typically came from the uchiha clan. it is only my idea

 

[-Broly-]

And how would Izuna have survived longer than Madara, especially when it was implicitly hinted that he died after he gave his eyes to madara? I don't think there was much of an overlap with his approx lifespan and Orochimaru's either.

Well they showed shisui dead in the river and that wasn't real Madara may have used a rinnegan technique to revive him or he coulda just lived I mean ononki is like 100

 

[WZRD]

In Ch.510 p.8 It shows he has both eyes as sharingan. And we've never seen his sharingan turned off either, which kinda hints that he's not a real Uchiha.

 

[IamMe]

Well implications aside it had to be someone who was alive prior to ask the war. I feel like it would be madara's brother just cause of the knowledge of the plan, also as for the eyes couldn't he have just taken madara's old eyes. Since it was said each brother is the others spare. Then with the rumor of his death he could move seemlessly til all the necessary obstacles were overcome

 

[SAGEPATH]

You must be registered for see images

people who say it his izuna or tobi are idiots seriousily why would kishi give them a honorreble death and then bring them back with revenge seriously i challenge some people to answer this lets discuss

 

[-Broly-]

In Ch.510 p.8 It shows he has both eyes as sharingan. And we've never seen his sharingan turned off either, which kinda hints that he's not a real Uchiha.

Well he had to have used the mangekyou to control the ninetails because I don't think that a 3 Tomoe sharingan can also what about when he posed as tobi because I'm pretty sure everyone else would notice his sharingan especially deidara who hated the sharingan and was his partner

 

[-Broly-]

You must be registered for see images

people who say it his izuna or tobi are idiots seriousily why would kishi give them a honorreble death and then bring them back with revenge seriously i challenge some people to answer this lets discuss

How is dying on the battlefield with no eyes honorable

 

[~WastelandSociety~]

I think Tobi was made from Madara DNA and the 1st with the help of the rinn.

Or it's madara's brother....I guess we have to wait and see.

 

[WZRD]

Good point. But as Sagepath puts it, it just wouldn't be a very good plot option for it be Izuna.

 

[SAGEPATH]

How is dying on the battlefield with no eyes honorable

You must be registered for see images

look up this word first please sacrifice before i answer your question and read manga on how obito and izuna died:sy:

 

[-Broly-]

Good point. But as Sagepath puts it, it just wouldn't be a very good plot option for it be Izuna.

How much plot sense would it be to introduce a new character that knows this much about madara, his story, the sharingan, and when Kishi himself said that naruto is reaching its climax not to mention izuna has the same height weight and hair color as tobi

 

[Varada]

Tobi can't be Shisui. He was found dead in a river and based on his profile he was a stand up guy. He may not even have been a Uchiha. I think he may be some sort of experiment by Orochimaru from the early days, while he was trying to splice senju and uchiha cells. At first sight, he seems to know quite a bit about Madara, more than an average person would know. But, should not one of the greatest clan member's biographies be well known throughout the Uchiha Clan? And, stated from memory, EdoMadara didn't say anything about Tobi to Kabuto-Controlled EdoMuu. In the few instances that Tobi fights, he seems to lose appendages with regularity, and what is shown of his body seems to be similar to the make-up of Zetsu. Thoughts?

Maybe true. Also it seems like you like CuDi's new album.

 

[-Broly-]

You must be registered for see images

look up this word first please sacrifice before i answer your question and read manga on how obito and izuna died:sy:

Itachi said he got his eyes taken from him. So again how is this honorable