I pick shanks for the win because those scars look good on him.
Well, how about this.
Blackbeard to shanks: Zehahaha! You look more handsome then ever! Those scars look good on you.
Blackbeard>Shanks
Blackbeard>Ace
Garp>Ace
Garp>Blackbeard
Garp>>>Shanks
Red-hair is gonna get renamed to red-pulp if he messes with Garp.
Goodness... Make up your mind.